If there has been one constant bright spot in the Yankees' lineup this season, it's been Ben Rice.
What started as an opportunity has turned into a full-fledged breakout, and Rice has rewarded the Yankees' faith in him every step of the way. He's evolved into one of the most dangerous left-handed hitters in baseball, giving the lineup power, patience, and a mature approach that has made him one of the American League's biggest surprises.
At the All-Star break, Rice had established himself among the league leaders with 29 home runs, nearly 70 RBIs and an OPS hovering around .970, while consistently producing quality at-bats and driving the baseball to all fields. His advanced metrics are just as impressive, with elite exit velocities, hard-hit percentages and barrel rates confirming that this isn't smoke and mirrors—Ben Rice has become one of baseball's legitimate impact hitters.
Perhaps what's been most impressive is how complete his offensive game has become. Rice isn't simply swinging for the fences. He's taking walks, hitting with runners in scoring position, and consistently delivering in big moments. Whether he's launching tape-measure home runs or lining doubles into the gap, he's become the type of hitter opposing pitchers genuinely fear.
He's been everything the Yankees could have hoped for—and then some.
That made Monday night's Home Run Derby such an interesting—and perhaps concerning—storyline.
Rice accepted the invitation to participate, making it a memorable family affair by having his father, Dan, throw batting practice to him. It was one of the more heartwarming moments of All-Star Week and something Rice will undoubtedly treasure forever. Unfortunately, the results on the field weren't nearly as memorable.
Rice managed just seven home runs, the fewest of any participant, and was eliminated in the opening round. Afterward, he admitted he became overly anxious and rushed his swing instead of staying within himself. Even so, he called the experience a success because he was able to share it with his father.
The Derby itself isn't the concern.
What happens after the Derby is.
For decades, baseball has debated the so-called "Home Run Derby Curse." Is it real? Or is it simply coincidence?
There have certainly been players who fueled the legend.
Bobby Abreu put on one of the greatest Derby performances ever in 2005, crushing an astonishing 41 home runs in the opening round. But after the All-Star break, his production dipped noticeably, and many pointed to the Derby as the culprit.
Josh Hamilton's unforgettable 2008 Derby performance remains one of baseball's iconic moments after he blasted 28 first-round home runs. While he remained productive overall, his second-half numbers declined, reigniting debate about whether the Derby had altered his swing or simply worn him down.
Aaron Judge experienced something similar in 2017. After winning the Derby in Miami, his second-half production dipped significantly. Was it because of the Derby? Or because pitchers adjusted to him and the grind of a 162-game season caught up with a rookie? Even Judge himself has never blamed the event, but the discussion has lingered for years.
Of course, there are just as many examples proving the opposite.
Pete Alonso has won multiple Home Run Derbies without seeing his swing disappear afterward. Vladimir Guerrero Jr. has participated and continued producing. Juan Soto has remained one of baseball's elite hitters regardless of Derby appearances.
That's what makes this debate so fascinating. Is there truly a curse? Or do fans simply remember the slumps and forget the players who kept right on hitting? Now that question belongs to Ben Rice.
Could one night of trying to launch every baseball into the upper deck throw off the smooth, controlled swing that has made him one of the Yankees' best hitters? Could his timing be affected? Could he begin overswinging in search of home runs?
Or will this simply become a fun memory from an incredible first half before he picks up exactly where he left off?
Personally, there's every reason to believe Rice will be just fine.
Everything we've seen this season suggests he's more than just a slugger. He's a disciplined hitter with an advanced understanding of the strike zone, tremendous bat speed, and a mature offensive approach that doesn't rely solely on brute force. Those qualities generally survive temporary mechanical hiccups.
Still, baseball is a game built on rhythm, timing and routine. Even the smallest change can snowball into something larger. The Yankees don't just need Ben Rice to be good in the second half. They need him to continue being one of the most dangerous hitters in their lineup. If he does, the Yankees' offense remains capable of carrying this club deep into October. If the Derby somehow disrupts that rhythm—even temporarily—it becomes one of the more intriguing storylines to watch over the next several weeks.
Hopefully, years from now, fans will remember Ben Rice's first Home Run Derby not because it started a slump, but because it marked the season he officially announced himself as one of baseball's brightest young stars.
The Yankees—and their fans—are certainly hoping that's exactly how this story ends.
