Saturday, November 21, 2026

THE YANKEES LET LUIS GIL WALK. NOW WATCH WHO PICKS HIM UP.


The Yankees let Luis Gil walk on Friday, and my first thought was simple. Please don’t let Tampa Bay get him.

You know how that movie goes. The Rays pick him up, get his fastball back, and by July we’re watching him strike out eight Yankees while somebody in the booth tells us what a savvy pickup he was. I can already hear it, and I’m already annoyed.

Gil and Fernando Cruz became free agents after the Yankees declined to offer them contracts for 2027. On the same day, MLB.com reported that the Yankees had agreed to bring back Jonathan Loáisiga on a two-year deal worth about $18 million, pending a physical. Well, there’s your offseason conversation starter.

I understand why they moved on from Gil. He walked 18 and struck out 17 in 27⅓ innings this year. His shoulder cost him months, and MLB.com reported that his velocity and command had slipped. But he’s 28, and two seasons ago he won Rookie of the Year with a 3.50 ERA and 171 strikeouts. The Yankees have seen exactly what he can do when he’s right. Now every other club gets to decide what it’s worth to find out if he can get there again.


And I like Loáisiga. He earned another deal with the season he had in Arizona. What gets me is that the Yankees are paying for a comeback another team already got to enjoy while walking away from a pitcher whose best season happened right here. These are different pitchers with different jobs. They’re also two decisions that tell you where Brian Cashman was willing to bet on an arm Friday. 

My question for Cashman is simple. What would it have cost to give Gil one more spring? Maybe the Yankees saw enough in the drop in velocity to make that an easy call. Fine. Then let’s see what they do with the roster spot. If they turn it into a pitcher who can give them meaningful innings in October, I’ll happily give them credit.

Until then, I’m watching the transaction wire. And if Gil ends up in Tampa Bay, somebody please take the remote away from me before his first start against us.




Friday, November 20, 2026

THE YANKEES CAN FIND TALENT BUT CAN'T DEVELOP IT


Jake Bauers hit 26 home runs for the World Series champion Milwaukee Brewers, won NLCS MVP, and just signed a four-year, $58 million deal with the Red Sox. The Yankees traded him to Milwaukee in 2023 for two minor league outfielders. Now they get to reacquaint themselves with his swing 13 times a year. Hell of a way to keep tabs on a former employee.

Bauers was already a veteran when the Yankees moved him, and it took three seasons in Milwaukee for him to have that breakout. The Brewers saw enough in his bat to take a chance, and when he finally put it together, he helped them win a damn World Series. That’s the part that should make Brian Cashman uncomfortable. What are other clubs seeing in these guys that the Yankees keep missing?

Which brings us to Jasson Domínguez. He’s hitting in winter ball, and Cashman says other teams are calling about him. Funny how a 23-year-old switch-hitter with power sounds intriguing when somebody else is on the phone. His defense was rough enough to get him sent down in September. Fine. Pick a position, get him the work, and give him enough games to show whether it’s taking. I’d love to hear as much about the Yankees’ plan for Domínguez as we’re hearing about their incoming calls.

Then there’s Spencer Jones. Cashman says Jones did the work and took a spot in 2026. He says he’d be comfortable with Jones in center, though he thinks Jones fits better in a corner. Last I checked, Aaron Judge and Cody Bellinger already have those corners covered. So where does that leave the kid who improved enough to earn his shot? “Good for him” is what you say when your nephew makes varsity. The general manager is supposed to have a second sentence.

Nobody needs a starting job handed to him in November. What these guys need is a real chance to earn one and enough room to have a lousy Tuesday without disappearing from the lineup on Wednesday. If Jones wins center, play him. If the Yankees believe Domínguez can handle an outfield spot, give him a clear path to it. And if Cashman trades either one, the return had better be worth more than the convenience of letting someone else figure him out.

Bauers already gave us the punch line. Milwaukee got the October home runs. Boston gets the bat. And the Yankees get to spend another winter telling us how much they like the guys they still have but then mishandle them.

We're in a bad cycle folks, and it's not getting better any time soon.

God, I cannot stand this front office.



WELCOME BACK, LOÁISIGA. NOW SURPRISE US, CASHMAN


I’m happy Jonathan Loáisiga is coming back to the Bronx. When that sinker is working and hitters are pounding it into the dirt, he’s a whole lot of fun to watch. And after what he did in Arizona, he’s earned a warm welcome. Loáisiga put up a 2.42 ERA in 67 appearances for the Diamondbacks, and the Yankees reportedly agreed to bring him back on a two-year deal with an option for a third. Good for him. Good for the bullpen. nypost.com

Now, Brian, do something that makes me spill my coffee.

David Bednar is back. Tim Hill is back. Loáisiga is on his way back. At this rate, the Yankees could save a few bucks on offseason graphics by leaving the old ones in the drafts folder. Each of those moves makes sense for the bullpen. Put them together, though, and you can see why fans are already wondering how much of this winter will be spent calling people whose numbers Cashman already has. nypost.com

Cashman has grown complacent, and it’s pathetic watching a franchise with this much pull act like its best ideas are sitting in last year’s contacts. Go find a hitter who makes opposing managers rethink how they get through the bottom of the order. Make a trade that costs you a player you actually like because the guy coming back makes you better. Give us something to argue about at Thanksgiving besides whether we’ve had this exact same conversation before.

I’ll cheer the first time Loáisiga gets a double-play ball at Yankee Stadium. I’ll probably be out of my seat before the throw gets to first. That’s the fun part of being a fan. The front office’s job is to give us more reasons to get out of that seat in October.

Welcome home, Johnny. And Cashman, there’s still a whole winter in front of you. Unless the Yankees start thinking differently about how they build this team, we aren’t gonna win a thing.



TRADE AARON JUDGE? THIS CALLER HAS MORE GUTS THAN CASHMAN

Every once in a while, somebody calls into The Michael Kay Show and says something so outrageous that you immediately wonder what the hell they've been drinking.

And then you think about it.

And suddenly, the crazy guy doesn't sound so crazy anymore.

The other day a caller named Tony from Dobbs Ferry proposed trading Aaron Judge to the Chicago Cubs for Pete Crow-Armstrong, Nico Hoerner and Shota Imanaga. Then, take the money saved and make a run at Tarik Skubal.

Wait. WHAT?


Trade Aaron Judge? The Captain? The face of the Yankees? The one guy in that lineup who consistently reminds us what greatness looks like?

That's baseball blasphemy in the Bronx.

But I'll give Tony credit for one thing. He's got balls. Something Brian Cashman hasn't demonstrated in years. And here's the uncomfortable part. There's actually some logic behind this madness.

Think about it.

Pete Crow-Armstrong gives the Yankees youth, athleticism, speed and tremendous defensive ability in center field. Nico Hoerner brings contact, versatility and the kind of fundamentally sound baseball this organization seems to have forgotten exists. Shota Imanaga adds another legitimate starting pitcher.

Three players who could address multiple weaknesses in one enormous move.

And if the Yankees somehow followed that up by acquiring and signing Tarik Skubal long-term? Suddenly, you're talking about a completely different baseball team.

A younger, more athletic, potentially better-balanced team. Imagine that. The Yankees actually building a roster instead of collecting expensive names and hoping October works itself out.

THE PROBLEM? YOU'RE TRADING AARON FREAKING JUDGE.

Let's not pretend replacing Judge is as simple as changing the name on the lineup card.

Judge isn't just another slugger. He's the heartbeat of this franchise. He's the guy opposing pitchers fear. He's the guy who makes Yankee Stadium come alive. He's the player you build around, not the player you casually ship to Chicago because somebody called a radio show.

And here's another little problem with Tony's master plan.

Why would the Cubs surrender three valuable players for an aging superstar with an enormous contract? Would Judge approve a trade? And does anybody seriously believe saving money automatically delivers Skubal to the Bronx?

Skubal isn't sitting outside Yankee Stadium with a suitcase waiting for Cashman to call. Acquiring him would require its own massive commitment, and potentially another blockbuster trade.

Besides, moving Judge's salary doesn't magically create enough financial flexibility to make all of this happen.


There are plenty of reasons this deal probably never gets beyond sports-radio entertainment.

But that's not really the point.

The point is that Tony is thinking bigger than Brian Cashman. He's willing to consider something dramatic. Something uncomfortable. A shake up. Something that might actually change the direction of a franchise that has become painfully predictable.

Cashman? He'll probably find another reclamation project, talk about internal improvements and tell us how difficult the market is.

Same movie. Different offseason. Terrible ending.

Look, I love Aaron Judge. Absolutely love him. I want him to finish his career wearing pinstripes. I want him holding a World Series trophy above his head. I want him remembered alongside the greatest Yankees ever.

And for that reason, I couldn't pull the trigger on this trade. Not today. But damn it, Tony. This is appealing. Not because I want Judge gone. Because I want the Yankees to stop being afraid of making bold decisions. I want a front office that recognizes talent, builds complete teams and understands that championships require more than one superstar carrying everyone else.

Would I make this trade? Probably not. Would I listen? You bet your ass I would. And that's the difference between thinking about winning and actually having the courage to pursue it.

Tony from Dobbs Ferry, I salute you.

You may have proposed the craziest trade of the offseason.

But at least you've got the guts to try something Cashman never would.

And after years of watching this organization spin its wheels, that's pretty damn refreshing.



Thursday, November 19, 2026

CONE CAN DEFEND THE YANKEES ALL HE WANTS. THE RESULTS TELL ANOTHER STORY.


Let me start by saying that I love David Cone.  No beef with him as a person. I love him commentary, I loved him as a player. I loved him when I met him at a Joe Torre Gala several years ago.  Class act through and through.

And David Cone is defending the Yankees, pointing to all the things happening behind the scenes that fans supposedly don't see. And I respect that.

Wonderful. Fantastic. Everybody gets a participation trophy.

Look, David Cone is a champion, a smart baseball man and a terrific analyst. But let's not ignore the obvious. Cone works for YES. The Yankees are part of his paycheck. That doesn't automatically make his opinion dishonest, but it certainly makes his defense of the organization a little less surprising.

And here's what bothers me about this whole argument.

Fans don't give a damn about what they can't see behind the scenes. They care about what they CAN see on the field. But even if they did care about what's happening behind the scenes... let's just say, what's happen AIN'T WORKING.

The Yankees haven't won a World Series since 2009. That's not an opinion. That's a fact. All the organizational meetings, analytics departments, scouting reports and internal conversations in the world don't change that.

But there's something much bigger happening here.

When former Yankees start talking about standards, accountability and what it once meant to wear the pinstripes, I hear something else.

I hear an indirect indictment of Aaron Boone. My Opinion.

Now, all these former players they know Boone. They like Boone. Nobody is questioning whether he's a decent human being.

But being a good guy and being a good manager are two entirely different things.

And I believe these former players know it they just can't say it out loud.

They remember a clubhouse where accountability wasn't optional. Where winning wasn't celebrated as an accomplishment in October unless you finished the job. Where the manager commanded respect, demanded excellence and wasn't afraid to make somebody uncomfortable.

Does that sound like Aaron Boone's Yankees to you?

Because it sure as hell doesn't to me.

Boone strikes me as a weak leader. Not because he doesn't care, but because he seems more interested in protecting his players than holding them accountable. There's always an explanation, always a positive takeaway, always another opportunity tomorrow.

At some point, enough is enough.

And perhaps that's what these former Yankees are really trying to tell us without directly embarrassing a guy they personally like.

David Cone can defend the process. Michael Kay can discuss all the things outsiders don't understand. That's their prerogative.

But the fans understand something perfectly well.

The Yankees used to measure success in championships. Now they seem to measure it in explanations.

And until somebody in that organization has the courage to demand more, we're going to keep getting more of the same.

Same leadership. Same excuses. Same disappointing ending.

You can defend the Yankees all you want, Coney.

But you can't defend away 17 years without a championship.

That's not a behind-the-scenes problem. That's a Yankees problem.



 

THE YANKEES SAW A SPARE PART. THE RED SOX SEE A CLEANUP HITTER

The Yankees traded Jake Bauers three years ago. Now they get to spend the next four summers hoping he comes up with the bases empty.

Boston signed Bauers to a four-year deal reportedly worth $58 million after he hit 26 home runs and posted a .389 on-base percentage for the World Series champion Brewers. The Yankees had him in pinstripes in 2023 and dealt him to Milwaukee for two minor league outfielders. Funny how a guy can go from expendable to expensive once somebody figures out what to do with him.

Brewers manager Pat Murphy said Bauers “was a huge part of that room for the last three years.” He was happy to see him get rewarded, even if it meant losing him. That’s the part that stuck with me. We can all read the home run column. Murphy was talking about what Bauers meant to a team that won the whole damn thing.

I understood the trade in 2023. Bauers had power, he struck out a ton, and you could go a week without seeing enough of the former to put up with the latter. The question I’d put to Brian Cashman is this. What did Milwaukee see in the same player that made them willing to keep working with him? By 2026, he drew 94 walks and finished second in the National League in on-base percentage. The Yankees spend plenty of time talking about controlling the strike zone. Turns out they traded a guy who was still learning how to do it. Boston Red Sox

And of course it had to be Boston. Cleveland could’ve signed him. Seattle could’ve brought him back. Instead, the Yankees get a left-handed hitter with power and patience taking aim at the short porch in a Red Sox uniform. I can already hear the postgame explanation about how they made a good pitch.

The part that should bother Yankees fans is how close this one was. They had Bauers in their clubhouse, in their lineup and in their own batting cage. Milwaukee got the best of him. Boston is paying for it. And the first time he puts one in the right-field seats to beat the Yankees, we’ll be the ones paying for it, too.



Wednesday, November 18, 2026

THE YANKEES BROUGHT BACK BEDNAR. NOW SHOW US WHAT’S CHANGING.

David Bednar is coming back. Good. He accepted the Yankees’ one-year, $23.15 million qualifying offer after putting up a 2.47 ERA and saving 35 games. When you find a guy who can handle the ninth inning in the Bronx, you hang on to him.

Now, Brian Cashman, what else you got?

That’s the question Yankee fans want answered. We’ve spent enough winters watching this front office bring back familiar faces, move a few pieces around and tell us how much it likes the group. Of course you like the group, Brian. You picked it.

Bednar earned his money. He also needs a lead to protect. Who’s getting the big hit when Aaron Judge gets pitched around? Who’s making a good starter work when the first three innings fly by in 30 pitches? And when the same holes show up in October, who in that front office is willing to admit they saw them in November?

That’s where I want to see some guts. Go get a hitter who makes a pitcher think twice about walking Judge. Be willing to move a player you like if it makes the lineup better. And spare me the annual speech about how healthy everybody looks in Tampa. They all look terrific hitting off a tee.

I’m glad Bednar is back. I’ll be glad again the first time he comes in with a one-run lead and slams the door. But the Yankees have spent a lot of winters telling us how close they are. At some point, you’d think somebody upstairs would get as tired of saying it as we are of hearing it.



CASHMAN BUILT A TRAFFIC JAM & JON HEYMAN WANTS TO MAKE IT WORSE!


If Jon Heyman says it, then it must be true! Or, something like that. Or, something not like that at all. It could be the complete opposite. It could be complete garbage. According to Heyman, the Yankees are sniffing around another outfielder because sure.....that's exactly what we need (insert sarcasm here).

Of all the pieces we desperately need to rebuild this team, supposedly the Yankees are interested in Randy Arozarena, read more HERE. Talk about an insane roster fit. That's just another log jam waiting to happen but the Yankees are desperate for a right handed bat and one that can actually hit because let's face it Aaron Judge can't do everything, which is especially true when he's injured.

So the Yankees are either desperate or the Yankees just don't know what the hell they are doing. Pick one. You can make an argument for either and I wouldn't think you are crazy. I do think the Yankees are crazy though if this rumor is true. We'll know Heyman is really serious about this story when he throws out the "mystery team" like he is known to do.

Brian Cashman says he is prioritizing the bullpen, so the outfield connection is odd. The Yankees lose Trent Grisham to free agency but they still have an elite outfield tandem with Judge and Cody Bellinger so it's not a major concern. The Yankees also have Spencer Jones who did better than I thought he was going to do in his rookie season and he could be the team's primary center fielder, but he's probably better suited as a corner outfielder. 


The Yankees have also committed to Giancarlo Stanton heading into whatever spring training will look like this year, so he'll need some DH opportunities. They also need to save some DH duties to rest Judge and then the Yankees also have a small challenge of carrying Ben Rice AND Luis Garcia Jr that both pencil in as first basemen. Oh and don't forget about bench outfielder Heliot Ramos if they don't end up trading him. What about Jasson Dominguez? He's entering his year of minor league options, so add another piece to the puzzle. The Yankees don't have designated hitter at-bats to offer all of these guys.

It's the potential for another log jam that Cashman is so good at creating. The Yankees just aren't a likely fit for him, but if you are the Yankees there's no harm in checking and perhaps driving the price up for everyone else.

Okay Heyman - let's just cut to the chase. Just name the mystery team in the mix so we can go straight to the lockout and forget this insane idea ever happened.



--Jeana Bellezza-Ochoa
BYB Senior Managing Editor
Twitter: @nyprincessj






Tuesday, November 17, 2026

THE YANKEES' COMFORT ZONE IS KILLING THEM & I'M SICK OF IT.

Here we go again. Another offseason. Another round of Brian Cashman shopping in the same aisle, looking at the same merchandise, hoping somehow the results will be different.

The latest report from NJ.com has the Yankees making an offer to a coveted free-agent reliever. And while improving the bullpen is certainly necessary, I can't help but ask a simple question: Does this organization have any idea how to do something different?

Because I'm sick of it.

The Yankees operate inside a bubble. A comfortable, predictable, unimaginative bubble where familiar names are recycled, old relationships are revisited, and every offseason feels like a rerun of a television show that should have been canceled years ago.

Tim Hill is back. There's interest in Paul Blackburn. David Bednar remains a priority. And now there's even talk of another reunion with Jonathan Loáisiga.

Seriously? I love Loáisiga, but what the hell is this death spiral we're in? Are we building a championship roster or organizing a high school reunion?

Look, I have nothing against these players. Some can absolutely contribute. But that's not the point. The Yankees keep confusing maintaining a roster with building a champion. Those are two entirely different things.

Cashman talks about casting a wide net. Wonderful. But somehow that net keeps landing in the same damn pond.

Meanwhile, the Dodgers operate with ambition. Other organizations identify weaknesses and aggressively address them. The Yankees? They seem determined to convince themselves that the same philosophy, with a few different spare parts, will finally produce a championship.

It won't.


And please, spare me the 93 wins. Spare me the playoff appearances. Spare me the annual speech about how difficult it is to win a World Series.

This is the New York Yankees. Not a franchise that should be throwing itself a parade for reaching October.

The standard used to be championships. Now it seems to be remaining competitive enough to sell the next season.

That's what bothers me most. It's not one reliever. It's not one transaction. It's an organizational philosophy that has become painfully stale.

The Yankees need fresh thinking, fresh talent, a different approach to constructing a roster, and the courage to admit that what they've been doing simply hasn't worked.

Instead, we're treated to another offseason of familiarity disguised as progress.

At some point, somebody in that front office needs to realize that you cannot keep reheating yesterday's dinner and calling it a brand-new menu.

I'm tired of the excuses. I'm tired of the recycled solutions. And I'm especially tired of watching a franchise with the Yankees' resources behave as though taking a genuine risk might bankrupt the organization.

Get outside the bubble, Brian. Break something. Change something. Do something that actually moves this franchise forward.

Because until the Yankees change the way they think, they aren't winning a goddamn thing.

And frankly, this fan base deserves a hell of a lot better.



Monday, November 16, 2026

LUIS GIL JUST REOPENED THE SOTO WOUND


Apparently, somebody forgot to tell Luis Gil that Yankee fans are supposed to be over Juan Soto.

In a recent interview with Mike Rodriguez, Gil reportedly reflected warmly on the 2024 clubhouse and said the players wanted Soto back. That doesn’t sound like a guy everybody was eager to help pack.

It also makes the ending sting a little more.

The Yankees had something worth keeping together. They owed their fans a serious effort to preserve it—and a convincing plan if they couldn’t. Fans are entitled to judge how well that replacement plan worked.

But spare me the presentation of Soto as somebody who was kidnapped and transported to Queens against his will.

He chose the Mets. He was entitled to choose his payday, his perks and his future. We’re equally entitled to think that choice put Juan Soto first.

That’s free agency. Just don’t ask us to confuse it with a love story.

Apparently, clubhouse chemistry is wonderful until direct deposit enters the conversation.

And the Yankees don’t get to hide behind his decision forever, either. Cashman’s job includes preparing for the answer he doesn’t want. “We tried” can explain losing a negotiation. It cannot serve as the organization’s permanent business plan.

Gil’s comments don’t prove the Yankees could have kept Soto. They do remind us that the people sharing his clubhouse wanted him there.

The players valued what they had. Soto chose something else. The Yankees still owe everyone a team good enough to make the conversation less painful.

Winning a championship would help.

It generally beats asking the fans to get over it.




TIM HILL IS BACK. IS THIS THE STARTING OF 'RUN IT BACK 2.0'?


Well, we all heard Brian Cashman say that his main priority was rebuilding the bullpen at the GM Meetings. I guess the first priority to sign for that was Tim Hill because he's back, read more HERE. It's definitely a choice that some fans are not completely excited about.

It's definitely a choice. Look, we need relievers for sure. We also need guys that can go a few innings because we've seen our starters last five innings creating a lengthy bridge to the closer. Hill can certainly give some length but....was he the guy Cashman should start rebuilding the bullpen with?

The Yankees need new energy and they need to embrace baseball fundamentals. The Yankees don't need to focus on reunions and "running it back" for next season. I understand the idea of 'if it ain't broke don't fix it' but the Yankees are broken. If the Yankees strategy worked we wouldn't be 17 years without a championship.

 In 2025, Hill was solid. He was the guy I had the most confidence in. This season, not so much. He looked solid again in the first half of the season and was the dominant lefty killer we were used to. The second half was rough and he was beat up by opposing hitters. I think he was overused a bit, and let's face it he's a not a spring chicken anymore. I love me a ground ball specialist but he struggled to keep the ball on the ground and he gave up a career high 12 home runs and seven of those were to right-handed hitters. He looked like he crashed down to earth and his 4.60 ERA in 67 appearances is a hard pill to swallow considering Cashman just made Hill his first signing to shore up the bullpen.

I hope this isn't a sign of what's to come. The lockout is coming, and teams are going to spend some money before December 1st. I'd feel a lot better about the Yankees strategy if they would focus on injecting some new talent into this roster instead of running it back with the guys we already have that couldn't get the job done. 

It's time to blow up the roster and the "leadership" within. The return of Hill just shows us that Cashman doesn't know how to do this job anymore. He can't evolve, he can only wash, rinse and repeat. He doesn't think like a winner.....so he can't build a winning team.

Hill isn't the guy you sign early in the offseason. He's not a splash! He's not a game changer but....welcome back, I guess.


--Jeana Bellezza-Ochoa
BYB Senior Managing Editor
Twitter: @nyprincessj






Sunday, November 15, 2026

THE YANKEES BROUGHT A SALES PITCH. NOW GIVE ODA A REASON TO BELIEVE.


The Yankees reportedly made their presentation to Japanese pitching prospect Shoki Oda this week, emphasizing player development. The Dodgers are among the clubs pursuing the 18-year-old, so getting a meeting is only the beginning.

Here’s what interests me: What can the Yankees show this kid that makes choosing the Bronx an easy decision?

Everybody can put together a presentation. Everybody has facilities, technology and people who promise to maximize potential. Oda deserves specifics. Who would work with him? What needs improving? How would the organization help him adjust to professional baseball and life in another country?

The Yankees reportedly involved senior pitching-development director Sam Briend in their pitch. Good. Put the people responsible for developing the player in the room. Give him something more useful than a history lesson about championships won before he was born.

I want the Yankees aggressive here. I want them competing for young talent with a convincing plan and the people to carry it out. Fans should care about that just as much as the next expensive veteran.

And spare us any victory lap over a productive meeting. Until Oda chooses a team, all anybody has accomplished is a conversation.

The Yankees have made their pitch. Now let’s see whether they gave him a reason to say yes.