IT'S NOT OFTEN THAT I AGREE WITH AROD, BUT IT JUST HAPPENED!

Ten years ago yesterday, August 12th, 2016, Alex Rodriguez played in his last game as a Yankee against the Rays. Oh how I look at that and think about the irony. Now he just sits back and talks about them and the strategy the Yankees should've taken to chase down the Rays in the AL East.

It's funny because he's been doing a lot of talking lately. I don't always agree with him. His idea that the Dodgers are good for baseball this week is one I don't agree with. However, the idea that the Yankees should've gone "all in" at the trade deadline I do agree with. If you missed it, check it out HERE. 

"The issue that you have with the Yankees, it's a tale of two stories," Rodriguez said. "They have the best pitching in baseball. They've collected some of the best pitchers, and by the way they haven't even been healthy all year but this is a championship-caliber pitching staff. I would've loved to see an extra arm or two because the by-product of not having a good offense, especially without Aaron Judge, they're pretty much 30th in every offensive category. What's gonna happen is you’re gonna play in a lot of tight games, you're not gonna blow anyone out. That means you're gonna tax your bullpen. You're gonna be the belly of your bullpen most of the year, and by the time September comes, their arms are gonna fall off. So that's my biggest concern."

We have wasted so many good, productive years in Judge's career. Next year he will be 35 and let's be honest, he's had some gnarly injuries. That's not going to get easier for the Yankees to manage. He's not going to be the young spring chicken anymore. Our starting pitching hasn't been this strong in a long time. Why waste that with an anemic offense that doesn't show up when Judge is out? It's even worse considering Cody Bellinger and Giancarlo Stanton are still out with their own injuries. It's like they are giving up without actually selling off the team.

Why not go "all in" as Rodriguez said and get some impact bats and upgrade your weaknesses that clearly aren't working? If you aren't going to sell, then don't just stand pat and make Band-Aid fixes! Cut the dead weight! Cutting Anthony Volpe wasn't enough. George Lombard Jr. getting his promotion needed to happen (it just wasn't an option not to), but they should've done more than just that. They needed to upgrade Austin Wells too!  That line from Brian Cashman about having "limited options" at catcher was a load of crap! Our rivals did it. That doesn't fix the Yankees but it sure is an addition by subtraction just getting rid of Wells who can't even hit his weight.

The Yankees needed to do more. They needed to be hungrier. The rest of these teams are looking at our starting rotation wishing they had it. They are envious for a moment, and then they realize all their offense has to do is 'keep them in the game' because they are likely to win those close games because our bullpen is not at the same level. A one run lead isn't as hard to protect for our rivals as it should be. You can't just rely on your starting pitching....the offense and bullpen need to also execute.

As Rodriguez said, "It's amazing how the whole fan base knew exactly how this was going to turn out and it did." That shouldn't be okay. That shouldn't be accepted and swept under the rug. Judge deserves more. The team deserves more. The fans deserve more. We deserve a front office with balls. We deserve a change from the top down. 

What a disgrace.

--Jeana Bellezza-Ochoa

BYB Senior Managing Editor

Twitter: @nyprincessj

ANOTHER YANKEE RALLY & MORE LOMBARD MAGIC!

The Yankees won again Tuesday night, beating the Mariners 4-1 for their third straight comeback victory.

That's the good news.

The other news? Can we please stop making “comeback” part of the nightly game plan?

Ryan Weathers deserved better than another night of waiting around for the offense to show up. He carried a one-hit shutout into the sixth and stretched his scoreless streak to 23 innings before Randy Arozarena finally got him with a solo homer. Weathers went 5.2 terrific innings, and the Yankee bullpen was spotless again.

And yet, there were the Yankees, trailing 1-0. Again. Thankfully, the bats eventually received the memo. In the seventh, Ryan McMahon delivered a two-run single and Trent Grisham followed with another two-run knock. Just like that, 1-0 became 4-1, and the Yankees had another win.

I love the fight. I love three straight comeback victories. But eventually, how about throwing the first punch? You can't keep spending six innings wandering around offensively and expect to flip a switch every night. Score early. Give your pitchers a lead. Maybe even make a game comfortable once in a while.

Crazy concept, I know.

But the moment I can't stop thinking about wasn't a hit.

It was George Lombard Jr.

In the first inning, a ground ball up the middle ricocheted off the second-base bag and changed direction. Lombard adjusted instantly, grabbed it with his bare hand and fired to first for the out.

Beautiful.

And here's what made it so impressive: it wasn't showboating. It was instinct. Lombard didn't barehand the ball because he wanted a highlight. He did it because his baseball brain immediately told him that's how the play had to be made.

You can't teach that. You can practice footwork, throwing mechanics and positioning. You can take 10,000 ground balls. But that internal clock — seeing something unexpected happen and reacting correctly without hesitation — is something special.

Lombard has it.

And I'm going to ask the question because every Yankee fan watching that play had to think about it:

After all the errors, misplays and routine grounders that somehow turned into adventures, do you think in a million years Anthony Volpe makes that play?

Come on. We've spent years being told how “elite” Volpe is defensively. Now we're watching Lombard play shortstop, and seemingly every game there's another defensive highlight. Great range. Smooth hands. Difficult throws made naturally. And now he's barehanding a ball that ricocheted off second base like somebody forgot to tell him the play was supposed to be difficult.

We're getting spoiled. Actually, maybe we're not. Maybe this is simply how a Yankee shortstop is supposed to operate. What was Yankee management doing force feeding Volpe on us? What a waste of time!

There's a difference between being told someone is an elite defender and watching someone whose instincts practically jump through the television. Lombard doesn't look frantic. He doesn't fight the position. He just plays it.

That's what makes this kid so impressive. The Yankees won 4-1. Weathers was terrific. McMahon and Grisham delivered. The bullpen did its job.

Three straight comeback wins. I'll happily take them. But tonight, maybe score before the seventh inning. And please, keep hitting the ball toward George Lombard Jr.

I want to see what the kid does next.

SO THIS IS WHAT "F'ING ELITE" IS NOW? COUNTING CLEAN PLAYS?

I’m trying to understand what world I’m living in.

Anthony Volpe is in the minor leagues. He’s now playing second base. And somehow, we’ve reached the point where we’re literally counting the number of plays he fields cleanly as proof that he’s adapting.

Are you kidding me? Greg Joyce of the New York Post wrote this: "Volpe played second base Saturday night at Triple-A Scranton/Wilkes-Barre, his first game at a position other than shortstop since 2021, and cleanly fielded all three balls hit to him."

I need you to think about this for a second.  This is the same Anthony Volpe that Aaron Boone once called “f’ing elite.”

Elite?

If Volpe were truly an elite shortstop, he’d be playing shortstop for the New York Yankees. Period. Instead, George Lombard Jr. has the job in the Bronx, while Volpe is in Scranton learning another position and we’re apparently supposed to get excited because he handled his chances cleanly.

According to the New York Post, Volpe is getting work at second base as the Yankees explore ways to increase his versatility and potentially create another route back to the majors.

Think about how insane that sentence would have sounded two years ago.

We went from “f’ing elite” to “maybe second base works.”

And that’s what gets me. This isn’t about rooting against Volpe. I want the kid to figure it out. But can we stop pretending this is anything other than a massive fall from where the Yankees told us he was?

We’re watching a former starting shortstop play second base in Triple-A and counting the clean plays.

One clean play. Two clean plays. Hey! There’s another one! What are we doing here? This is the New York Yankees, not instructional league. Maybe Volpe eventually figures it out. Maybe second base becomes his way back. Who knows... to be honest, I'm done with this stupid experiment.

Spare me the victory lap because he fielded a few baseballs cleanly in Scranton. “F’ing elite” was the standard. Now we’re counting clean ground balls.

THIS IS PATHETIC.

HEY CAMERON MAYBIN, YOU MISSED THE MARK WITH VOLPE

Former Yankees outfielder Cameron Maybin weighed in after Anthony Volpe's demotion and George Lombard Jr.'s promotion, urging fans to move on. He wrote:

"The kid grew up dreaming of being a Yankee, got to wear the pinstripes, and by every account gave that organization everything he had. That deserves respect. Be excited about George Lombard Jr. I am too. But why does that have to come with taking shots at Volpe? That's weird. It's always the people who've never competed on a stage anywhere close to that level who are the loudest tearing him down. Turn the page. Appreciate what Volpe gave, root for what's next, and stop pouring salt in the wound. Respect costs nothing."

Hey Cameron Maybin, this isn't personal against Anthony Volpe. The problem is that you're trying to make it personal when it never was.

Nobody is celebrating because Anthony Volpe failed. They're celebrating because the Yankees finally admitted they were wrong.

The organization spent years manufacturing a Derek Jeter type story around Volpe. They spotted a local kid on a high school field, fell in love with the narrative, and fast-tracked him through the system before he was ready. Why? Because there was already familiarity. Volpe's former summer coach, Matt Hyde, also happened to be a Yankees scout. Whether people want to acknowledge it or not, that relationship helped fuel an organizational belief that Volpe was destined to become the next great Yankees shortstop. Read HOW YANKEE SCOUTS LOST THEIR WAY IN THE VOLPE RECRUITMENT. Educate yourself.

The Yankees sold fans on the idea before the player had proven it on the field. That's not Anthony Volpe's fault. That's Brian Cashman's fault. Fans didn't reject Volpe because they disliked him. They rejected the Yankees' refusal to admit he'd been rushed. For years, the organization force-fed this experiment while fans watched a player trying to learn the hardest position on the diamond under the brightest lights in baseball.

So, when Maybin says we should appreciate what Volpe did for the clubhouse, it's a fair question:

What exactly did he do for the clubhouse?

The Yankees didn't win because of Anthony Volpe. They didn't become tougher. They didn't become more fundamentally sound. They didn't become champions.

What fans remember is years of inconsistency while the organization insisted everything was fine.

That's not personal. That's baseball.

Here's another thing. If you're a Yankees shortstop and have access to Derek Jeter, why wouldn't you bend his ear every chance you got? Maybe conversations happened privately, maybe they didn't, but Jeter said he "didn't know" Anthony and that's a red flag. Fans never saw that relationship blossom. If the organization was going to market Volpe as the heir to Jeter, then learning from No. 2 himself should have been part of the equation.

Instead, the Yankees pushed the image before the player was ready to carry it.

Maybin can defend Volpe all he wants, but he's defending the wrong thing. Fans weren't attacking the kid. They were demanding accountability from the front office that put him in an impossible situation.

Then the Yankees finally made the move everyone had been asking for. Volpe was optioned to Triple-A.

Ironically, even that has created another question.

As of August 6, Scranton/Wilkes-Barre manager Shelley Duncan confirmed Volpe still hadn't officially reported to the RailRiders. Yes, players are typically given up to 72 hours to report after being optioned, so there's nothing unusual procedurally.

But if you're determined to prove everyone wrong, why aren't you on the first ride to Scranton? Maybe there's a perfectly reasonable explanation. Maybe not. Still, it doesn't exactly scream urgency. If you want to be treated like a big leaguer, then go to work like one.

And that's why Maybin's comments miss the mark. This isn't about hurt feelings. This is about winning baseball games.

George Lombard Jr. takes the field looking confident, fearless and prepared. Win or lose, the Yankees already feel different. They look looser. They look more athletic. They look like they're finally playing baseball instead of trying to protect an organizational decision.

Anthony Volpe is probably a good kid. Most fans would agree with that. But the Yankees rushed him. The Yankees damaged his development. The Yankees refused to admit their mistake until fan pressure became impossible to ignore.

So no, Cameron Maybin. This was never personal. It was always business.

And Yankees fans weren't rooting against Anthony Volpe. They were rooting for the Yankees to stop pretending he was ready.

Stop trying to be provocative.

LOMBARD JR. HAS CHANGED THE FEEL OF THE YANKEES IN JUST 2 GAMES

The Yankees lost 3-1 to the Cardinals. They stranded 11 runners. They went 0-for-10 with runners in scoring position. The stadium lights quit on them twice. It was one of those nights where everything that could short-circuit did.

Everything except the shortstop.

And that's exactly why this loss felt different. George Lombard Jr. has been the Yankees' starting shortstop for exactly two games, and somehow the entire organization already feels lighter. Maybe it's because we're finally watching baseball instead of a science experiment that everyone knew had failed except the people running the lab.

For years, Yankees fans were told to ignore what they were seeing. Anthony Volpe just needed more time. Then more time after that. Then some patience. Then another season. Somewhere along the way, "development" became code for "please stop asking questions."

Finally, it was enough.

Lombard showed up, homered in his Major League debut, followed it up with another hit, stole one away on defense, and suddenly the most important position on the field looks... normal.

You know, the way it's supposed to.

Will Warren probably summed it up better than anyone. "I made a joke with him earlier: 'He's everywhere.' It's nice to have that behind you."

Read between those lines. Pitchers don't hand out compliments like Halloween candy. They know when the guy behind them can erase mistakes instead of creating new ones. The comfort level is obvious. The confidence is obvious. The energy is obvious. It's almost as if having a legitimate shortstop playing shortstop is good for baseball. Revolutionary concept, I know.

Meanwhile, back in Scranton, Anthony Volpe is getting regular at-bats while rotating between shortstop and second base. Good. That's exactly where he needs to be.

The problem is the Yankees still can't seem to let go of the fantasy that Volpe is somehow their long-term answer at shortstop. That ship didn't just sail—it filed a change-of-address form. Just watch Lombard for a few innings.

The first step. The range. The instincts. The athleticism.

It's simply reality. Some guys have "it." Others spend three years convincing an organization they might eventually find it. George Lombard Jr. already has it. Personally? I've said it before and I'll say it again. Volpe's best chance to carve out a Major League career is probably at second base... with another organization.

Because this isn't really about Anthony Volpe anymore. It's about what happens when the Yankees stop forcing a narrative and let talent speak for itself. Even the clubhouse feels different. We actually have a chance to win it all.

Trent Grisham talked about believing the offense will eventually come around, and maybe it will. But confidence is contagious, and so is competence.

For the first time in a long time, the Yankees look like they're playing with both. Fans aren't holding their breath every time a routine ground ball is hit to short. Pitchers aren't wondering if they need four outs in an inning. And perhaps best of all, nobody has to spend the postgame explaining why what everyone just watched wasn't actually what they watched.

That's progress. George Lombard Jr. has been in the Bronx for two days.

Two.

And somehow the Yankees already feel like a team trying to win baseball games instead of trying to win an argument. That's the biggest difference of all. Brian Cashman may still be clinging to the Volpe dream like it's the last life raft on the Titanic.

The rest of us have already climbed aboard the Lombard ship. And judging by the reaction inside that clubhouse, the Yankees and the Yankees social media has too.

Wow. 

Volpe who?

THE RIDICULOUS YANKEES! BEST TEAM ADDITION WAS ALREADY IN HOUSE!

You know, I'm really not happy about how the Yankees botched the trade deadline. They really screwed that up to the point that the Red Sox and the Rays are off in the distance pointing and laughing at us. Our rivals made the upgrades that Brian Cashman claimed weren't possible. There were "limited opportunities" on the market. Limited to who? Only Cashman who can't seem to get the job done.

He has one job, and that is to build a championship caliber team, and find ways to improve upon it. Other teams did it, but he's just not capable. Sure, I know he added Heliot Ramos and Luis Garcia Jr. He added offense which is needed because this lineup is dead without Aaron Judge but, it's a band-aid fix. Neither of these guys play catcher or can come out of the bullpen. They are fine. I want more than fine. I am tired of settling or being complacent while our biggest competitors become more dangerous.

Nothing against Ramos or Garcia. They are just bats the Yankees hope will add some offense to the lineup. Meanwhile, we are still stuck with Austin Wells who can just continue to suck without having an excuse like he's under too much pressure and folding because of it. Now he can just suck because the Yankees will let him because now they have no opportunities instead of "limited opportunities." The only plus to this is Anthony Volpe can suck down in Triple-A and we don't have to watch him night after night screaming the same obscenities when he doesn't hit or screws up defensively. 

So the win for Cashman is we stop bitching about Volpe and now we get to watch George Lombard Jr. finally get his opportunity. He's as untouchable as one could be for a while, but the Yankees stupidly stuck with Volpe for too long. He certainly wasn't holding onto his spot because he earned it, they just wanted Volpe to blossom into something he was never going to be. If the Yankees weren't going to trade Lombard Jr, they needed to give him a chance. It's not like he could be worse. That's almost impossible....

So now you have to wonder if the Yankees best addition was actually a subtraction of Volpe and calling up top prospect Lombard Jr. That was their trade deadline. We got better by sending down a scrub. That's it. Lombard Jr is a talent for sure, we saw it last night there is so much potential there but.....this can't be the big splash for a team with championship aspirations!

We are defined as a team that makes additions by subtraction....that's what we have become. These "decision makers" are a joke. Time will tell, but I hope Lombard Jr. makes the Yankees regret being stupid for so long.

--Jeana Bellezza-Ochoa

BYB Senior Managing Editor

Twitter: @nyprincessj

REAL TALENT DOESN'T REQUIRE A PUBLIC RELATIONS DEPARTMENT

Before the Yankees even threw a pitch tonight, the mood around the Bronx had already changed. No, it wasn't just because George Lombard Jr. had finally arrived. It was because Anthony Volpe was gone. That's a fact folks, and I speak honesty so let's stop pretending otherwise. 

The excitement wasn't simply about baseball's top shortstop prospect getting his chance. The real electricity came from the fact that the Yankees had finally waved the white flag on one of the most stubborn, tone-deaf personnel decisions in recent franchise history. Fans weren't celebrating someone getting called up. They were celebrating that someone else had finally been taken out of the lineup.

That says everything.

The game itself wasn't loaded with drama, but George Lombard Jr. made sure nobody would forget it. In the fifth inning, Hunter Dobbins tried to sneak an 81-mph sweeper past him.

Bad idea.

Lombard unloaded, launching the pitch into the left-field seats for his first Major League hit and first Major League home run. The swing was smooth. The reaction was genuine. The smile stretched ear to ear. It looked... natural. And that word matters.

Because today Aaron Boone said something that should make every Yankees fan stop and think. His message to Lombard before the game?

"Go be you."

Really? Go be you? That's fascinating. Because that's the exact opposite of what this organization spent over three years doing with Anthony Volpe. Volpe was never allowed to simply just be Anthony Volpe... that's because they manufactured that poor kid. I would even suggest they ruined him. Remember, the Yankees needed Volpe to become the golden child. it was forced. The face of the future. The captain-in-waiting. The defensive wizard. The homegrown superstar who justified every scouting report, every promotional campaign, every spring training interview and every ridiculous sound bite coming out of the front office.

Remember when Boone called him "f-ing elite?" Of course you do. That wasn't confidence. That was advertising.

It always felt like Boone was reading from a script handed to him upstairs. Every time Volpe struggled, the talking points stayed exactly the same. Ignore what your eyes are seeing. Trust us. He's elite. He's special. He's untouchable. Fans were told to believe the slogan instead of the baseball Volpe was playing until it was too obvious, he wasn't close to ready. Brian Cashman and Aaron Boone spent years trying to convince everyone that the emperor was wearing pinstripes.

The problem? The emperor forgot his bat. Meanwhile, George Lombard Jr. arrives with none of that baggage. Nobody is trying to sell him. Nobody is demanding that fans buy into a marketing campaign (Well, not they are of course). Nobody is asking the media to lower expectations while simultaneously calling him a franchise cornerstone.

They're simply saying... "Go be you."

Why?

Because real talent doesn't require a public relations department.

Watching tonight's game, you could almost feel the tension disappear. The dugout looked looser. The at-bats looked freer. The energy was different. Even Boone looked like someone who wasn't managing every pitch with one eye on the front office.

And that's because Lombard doesn't feel like an obligation. He feels like a baseball player.

He earned every rung of the ladder. He developed in the minors. He learned the game. He wasn't rushed because somebody needed a feel-good story for Opening Day. 

Will he struggle? Absolutely. Every young player does. But there's a huge difference between allowing a gifted prospect to experience growing pains and desperately hoping a player eventually becomes the guy you've spent three years insisting he already is. That's where the Yankees completely lost the plot with Volpe.

Every ground ball became an adventure. Every at-bat felt like a coin flip. If we're being honest, and I am, it wasn't just the fans sitting on pins and needles. Most likely 3 years in it was Brian Cashman too.

Because every error...

Every strikeout...

Every ugly night chipped away at a narrative the organization had spent years manufacturing.

Lombard doesn't need a narrative.

He belongs. That's what stood out tonight. Not just because he homered. Because nothing about him looked forced. He looked comfortable and confident. He looked exactly like a kid who has spent his entire life preparing for this moment instead of trying to live up to somebody else's press release.

People love tossing around Derek Jeter comparisons, and I hate doing it because they're unfair. But here's what I will say.

George Lombard Jr. looks real. He's authentic. He's playing baseball instead of acting in a Yankees commercial. And that's why this feels different.

What happens next? Nobody knows. Baseball has always been unpredictable. Just ask Wally Pipp. Sometimes history changes because a player gets hurt. Sometimes it changes because an organization finally runs out of excuses.

Maybe tonight was one of those moments. Maybe years from now we'll look back at Anthony Volpe being sent to Scranton the same way previous generations remembered lineup changes that nobody appreciated at the time. Either way, one thing became crystal clear.

The Yankees finally put the right shortstop on the field. It just took Brian Cashman and Aaron Boone about two years longer than it should have.

Congratulations, George Lombard Jr. You didn't get here because of hype and a false narrative. You didn't get here because of slogans. You didn't get here because someone in the front office kept insisting you were something you hadn't yet proven.

You got here because you earned it.

Now go be you.

The funny thing is... that might be the one piece of advice this organization should've been giving its young players all along.

Imagine that. 

CASHMAN'S TRADE DEADLINE MALPRACTICE

He knew the Yankees needed a catcher, and he did nothing. Brian Cashman wants Yankees fans to believe the catching market dried up before the trade deadline.

That's convenient. It's also absolute nonsense.

How I picture Brian Cashman Today (Altered Image)

After the deadline, Cashman claimed there was a "limited opportunity" to acquire a catcher, suggesting his hands were tied. That's the kind of explanation you give when you're trying to justify doing nothing.

Here's the problem. Doing nothing is exactly what Brian Cashman did.

This wasn't some hidden flaw that only the analytics department could uncover. Every person watching Yankees baseball knew the catching position was a liability months ago. Fans knew it. The media knew it. Opposing teams certainly knew it. Bleeding Yankee Blue has been reporting it for months.

Cashman knew it too, and he still let the deadline come and go without making a meaningful upgrade. Austin Wells has been one of the weakest offensive catchers in baseball this season. He's hitting .167 after 221 at bats with just 8 home runs and 16 RBIs. His year has been derailed by a prolonged slump, followed by a stint on the injured list because of cervical headaches. Since returning, the Yankees are still waiting for the breakout they've been promised. He's the weakest catcher in the league... but don't worry he still rates burritos and wears the orange catching gear as an homage to one of the greatest catchers of our lifetime, Thurman Munson.  But that doesn't change the fact that he is weak.

Hope by the Yankees front office isn't a strategy. Wells needs to pack up and take the bus to somewhere else and bring Volpe and those ridiculous scouts with you... cause they all got it wrong.

Then there's Ali Sánchez.

Sure, he's hitting .273, but let's not pretend that's solving anything. Sánchez is a backup catcher who gives you defense and little else. If he's your safety net on a club chasing a World Series, you've already got a problem.

Cashman admitted the Yankees have struggled offensively, especially from the catching position.

Great.

Now explain why you ignored it. This is where the excuses fall apart. The market was NOT empty.

The Boston Red Sox landed Adley Rutschman, arguably the biggest impact catcher available, and they did it while breathing down the Yankees' necks in the standings. Think about that for a second. The Yankees' biggest rival identified a weakness, acted aggressively, and came away with a franchise cornerstone.

The Yankees? They watched it happen.

The Tampa Bay Rays strengthened themselves by acquiring Liam Hicks, a young catcher with offensive upside and years of club control. Arguably better than Austin Wells.  The Los Angeles Dodgers, facing injuries behind the plate, refused to sit around waiting for good luck. They added Ben Rortvedt and Hunter Feduccia because smart organizations understand that depth matters in August and September.

Everywhere you looked, contenders were improving. Except in the Bronx.

Cashman's lone catching move was acquiring Omar Alfonzo, a minor league prospect who isn't helping the Yankees win one game this season. That's not fixing the major league roster. That's filing paperwork.

And that's become Brian Cashman's trademark.

For years, the Yankees have operated as though urgency is optional. Every deadline feels the same. They identify obvious weaknesses, spend days leaking how hard they're working, then congratulate themselves for making half-measures while pretending the market didn't cooperate.

Enough.

The job description of a general manager isn't to explain why something couldn't be done. It's to find a way to get it done.

No one is paying Brian Cashman to shrug his shoulders. He's paid to outwork other front offices, identify opportunities before anyone else, and improve his roster. Instead, he watched Boston get dramatically better. He watched Tampa solve a need. He watched Los Angeles reinforce its roster. And he did what has become far too common under his leadership.

He settled.

Yankees fans are tired of hearing about "limited opportunities." Winners create opportunities. Aggressive front offices manufacture deals. Championship executives don't hide behind excuses after the fact. Cashman had one clear assignment at this deadline: improve a catching corps that has been an offensive black hole all season.

He failed. Not because the players weren't available. Not because the Yankees lacked resources.

Because the general manager lacked the urgency to do the job. And if the Yankees' season ends with another October disappointment, remember this deadline. Remember that Brian Cashman saw one of the biggest holes on his roster, acknowledged it publicly, and then chose to leave it exactly as it was.

That's not bad luck.

That's bad management. Bad leadership. You should be ashamed of yourself.

FAN PRESSURE BREAKS THE YANKEES. VOLPE SENT DOWN

They have nobody to blame but themselves. It is my opinion that the New York Yankees thought they could bury the story.

Late Monday night after getting embarrassed 13-7 by the St. Louis Cardinals, the organization quietly slipped out the biggest roster news of the season through YES Network's Jack Curry, long after the daily baseball news cycle had slowed down. It wasn't an accident. It was calculated.

The Yankees announced that Anthony Volpe had been optioned to Triple-A Scranton/Wilkes-Barre. Top prospect George Lombard Jr. was finally getting the call to become the club's regular shortstop. Jasson Domínguez was also sent back to Triple-A as part of the roster shuffle.

This wasn't just a baseball move. This was an organization finally cracking under the weight of fan pressure and years of its own failures. Let's be honest. Brian Cashman backed himself into this corner and did a horrible job at the trade deadline. After another deadline where the Yankees failed to make the kind of significant moves that could actually change the direction of this club, something had to give. The fan base has been screaming for accountability while Cashman continued to sell patience. Well, patience ran out.

George Lombard Jr. didn't suddenly become ready overnight. He's been outperforming Anthony Volpe offensively all season. He possesses the higher ceiling, the better physical tools, and frankly, he looks like the future. Everyone could see it except the Yankees, who stubbornly continued forcing the Volpe experiment long after the evidence suggested it wasn't working.

The Yankees didn't make this move because they wanted to. They made it because they had no other choice. That's the embarrassing part.

Instead of acting proactively, they waited until the pressure became unbearable. They waited until another ugly loss. They waited until fans had completely lost faith in the front office's decision-making. Then they quietly released the news after hours, hoping it wouldn't dominate headlines.

Sorry. Fans aren't stupid. This is one of the biggest organizational decisions they've made in years, and it deserves to be treated that way.

Give George Lombard Jr. credit. He's earned this opportunity. He actually earned it. Nobody handed him anything. He forced the Yankees to make this decision with his performance, not with hype, not with promises, and certainly not because anyone owed him a favor. 

That's what makes this promotion so refreshing. Lombard climbed the ladder the way prospects are supposed to—by producing. Meanwhile, Anthony Volpe spent years being sold to the fan base as the next great Yankee before he ever proved he could consistently hit major league pitching. The organization fell in love with the projection and refused to let go, even as the evidence piled up.

I have had questions about whether personal relationships and internal loyalties clouded the Yankees' evaluation of Volpe. Read HOW YANKEE SCOUTS LOST THEIR WAY IN THE VOLPE RECRUITMENT. Whether those relationships influenced decision-making or not, the perception exists because the organization kept doubling down on him long after the results stopped justifying it. Instead of letting competition determine who deserved the job, the Yankees appeared determined to make sure Volpe succeeded no matter how long it took.  This is all my opinion of course; it's just through my research. But I think I'm right.

That's the real travesty with this whole thing though. Merit seemed to take a back seat to organizational pride. The Yankees invested so much in proving they were right that they ignored what everyone else could plainly see. Volpe simply never developed into the everyday major league shortstop they promised he would become. Every player deserves a chance, but no player deserves an unlimited leash while better options waited for an opportunity. Volpe got that, it was wrong on many levels.

George Lombard Jr. didn't ask for special treatment. He earned his shot the old-fashioned way. The Yankees should have recognized that months ago instead of clinging to a failed experiment because admitting a mistake was apparently harder than fixing one.

As for Anthony Volpe, I am thrilled he was sent down. The only thing better would have been for him to be traded and out of the Yankee organization. The Yankees kept insisting he'd figure it out while ignoring what everyone else was watching. Development isn't helped by pretending struggles don't exist.

For years, the Yankees acted as if admitting they were wrong about Volpe would somehow be worse than continuing to run him out there while the offense suffered. The Yankees failed.

Now they're asking George Lombard Jr. to clean up the mess they created.  It would be the right move to allow Lombard the same leash they allowed Volpe. But listen, don't get it twisted, this move is absolutely the right one.

It also should have happened a long, long time ago.

If the Yankees are serious about changing the culture, this can't be where accountability ends. It shouldn't stop with Anthony Volpe. It shouldn't stop with one promotion.

The organization owes its fans more than a late-night announcement designed to soften the blow after another humiliating loss. They owe them honesty. They owe them urgency. And they owe them a front office willing to admit when it's wrong instead of hiding behind carefully timed press releases.

The fans forced this change. Not Brian Cashman. Not the Yankees' baseball operations department. Not ownership. The fans did. We should be proud. Us kept demanding accountability, they kept questioning the organization's blind loyalty to a failed experiment, and eventually the Yankees had nowhere left to hide.

George Lombard Jr. earned this opportunity. The Yankees simply took far too long to realize it. The only thing that would be better? Trade Volpe. Get him out of the Bronx and let's finally concentrate on baseball. 

YANKS NEED A REAL SHORTSTOP

The Yankees have a problem. No, not the bullpen. Not the bench. Not even third base. Their biggest problem is standing 90 feet from second base pretending everything is fine.

Anthony Volpe has become the player you're no longer allowed to criticize because someone always has another excuse ready.

"He'll figure it out."

"He's still young."

"There's nobody better."

Really?

The Yankees are trying to win a World Series—not host a three-year science experiment.

Before I dive in, let me say this: I've got nothing against Empire Sports Media. They do a nice job covering the Yankees. We simply see this one differently.

They recently wrote in Yankees’ deadline decision at shortstop could get ugly:

"I would not make a panicked trade just to say the Yankees did something. Shortstop is not a vending machine where you drop in a prospect and get an obvious upgrade. A rental needs to be better now, fit the clubhouse and leave the club with a clean plan when Volpe is still on the roster tomorrow."

Here's my response...

Who said anything about panic?

This isn't panic.

This is accountability.

The Yankees have given Anthony Volpe every opportunity imaginable. They've let him hit through slumps. They've defended his mistakes. They've convinced themselves—and tried convincing us—that tomorrow would always be better than today. Well... tomorrow keeps looking an awful lot like yesterday.

Empire Sports Media is right about one thing: shortstop isn't a vending machine. True. Nobody expects Brian Cashman to press "B-12" and have Cal Ripken Jr. fall into the slot. But that's also a straw-man argument.

Nobody is asking for perfection. We're asking for better. Better defense. Better at-bats. Better baseball. Because right now, "better than Anthony Volpe" isn't exactly the highest mountain to climb.

Then came the part that really made me scratch my head.

Empire Sports Media says any move should "leave the club with a clean plan when Volpe is still on the roster tomorrow."

But why? Who decided tomorrow has to include Anthony Volpe? That's the flaw in the entire argument. The Yankees don't owe Volpe a career. They owe Aaron Judge a championship. They owe Gerrit Cole, Max Fried, Cody Bellinger and every veteran in that clubhouse a roster built to win now.

If Volpe can't hold onto the job, then he loses the job. Welcome to professional sports. This organization has spent years protecting Anthony Volpe because of what he might become instead of evaluating what he actually is. That's backwards.

You don't hand someone baseball's most important infield position because they were once a top prospect. You earn it.

The Yankees keep talking about "championship standards." Great. Then start acting like it. Because championship organizations don't keep rewarding bad baseball simply because admitting a first-round pick didn't work out is uncomfortable.

That's pride talking. Not baseball. Again, no disrespect to Empire Sports Media. This isn't personal. It's just my opinion. Anthony Volpe's leash has become longer than his list of accomplishments, and every game the Yankees continue pretending he's the answer at shortstop is another game they're putting loyalty ahead of winning.

The Yankees had an obligation to upgrade the Shortstop and Catching position today.  They failed.  It's a disgrace to this organization. 

For a franchise with 27 championships, that should never be acceptable.

My take.

NO RIGHT TURNS: IS CASHMAN STEERING YANKEES LINEUP INTO A LEFTY DEAD END?

In the latest episode of "what the hell is Brian Cashman doing now?" we focus on the next player that the Yankees acquired that isn't what the Yankees really need. We have a long list of needs so in theory finding something to chase that isn't what we need should be hard, right?

Not unless you are Cashman. He has this knack for dumpster diving for junk. I won't even call it shopping in the clearance section because even the clearance bin would be insulted. The Yankees need better relief pitching, sound outfield depth, a catcher, the balls to dump Anthony Volpe and right handed hitting. None of that has happened....

But what has happened is the Yankees traded for Nationals First baseman Luis Garcia Jr. Who else is scratching their head right now besides me? It's crazy and true and you can read more about it HERE. The Yankees certainly need a boost offensively because they are awful without Aaron Judge so the connection to Garcia Jr makes sense when he has a .283 BA this season. Dig a little deeper and stats show he has a .293 BA against right handed pitchers.

This team certainly needs offense. A guy that hits near 300 is great, but they Yankees need more of that. One guy isn't going to bring the change this team needs without addressing positional needs also. But aside from that, it's insane because this move doesn't make sense. Adding another guy that plays first base is insane. He's not an upgrade over Paul Goldschmidt and what about Ben Rice? That's just another reason to make him more dispensable.

It's just a giant log jam. He can play first base against a righty pitcher and then Rice can DH while Goldy rides the bench. When a lefty is on the mound, Goldy can play first and the Yankees can shuffle DH. That's exactly what happens here. It's a cluster-you-know-what and I say that because Garcia Jr has played second base and shortstop also but he was awful at both positions so it's not like you can sit Jazz Chisholm or Volpe expecting an upgrade. It's just a giant puzzle that Aaron Boone is gonna have to piece together every night and it's one more opportunity for him to screw up. He was already good at that before adding another infielder to the equation so this could get even uglier.

Look am I glad Cashman finally woke up from his nap? Sure. I hate complacency. I wanted to see moves made more than anyone.....this one just doesn't fix any of the Yankees major weaknesses. So without fixing those this accomplishes nothing. We don't need another first baseman and we don't need anymore left handed bats for crying out loud! Sorry, not sorry.....but I call it like I see it.

--Jeana Bellezza-Ochoa

BYB Senior Managing Editor

Twitter: @nyprincessj

ARE THE YANKEES READY TO MOVE VOLPE?

God, I hope so.

I've reached my limit with Anthony Volpe. I used to defend this guy. I've waited for the breakout. I've bought into the "he's still young" argument. I've watched the flashes of brilliance and convinced myself they would eventually outweigh the mistakes. They haven't. And then I got annoyed. I researched why they babied this kid as long as they have.  Reported about it in: HOW YANKEE SCOUTS LOST THEIR WAY IN THE VOLPE RECRUITMENT.  What I found was startling. And so, things changed for me.  This kid is a special treatment case. Not earned... it's who you know.

Volpe is making headlines for all the wrong reasons. Defensive miscues continue to pile up, the bat has never become the weapon the Yankees envisioned, and every game seems to feature another reminder that this experiment simply isn't working.

The good news? I'm not the only one who feels this way anymore.

For the first time since Volpe arrived in the Bronx, legitimate baseball insiders are openly discussing the possibility that the Yankees could move him before his value sinks any further. That's a significant shift. This isn't social media overreaction. This is baseball people acknowledging that the Yankees may finally be ready to pivot.

And honestly? It's about time. the chatter is getting louder.  The rumors aren't coming from one source. They're coming from several respected voices, and they're all pointing in the same direction.

Jim Bowden has floated one of the more intriguing ideas, suggesting the Yankees could package Volpe with reliever Camilo Doval in a deal with the Minnesota Twins for catcher Ryan Jeffers. It's a move that would address one of New York's biggest weaknesses behind the plate while giving Minnesota a young, controllable shortstop to gamble on.

Chris Kirschner of The Athletic has also identified Volpe as one of the Yankees' most logical trade chips. His thinking is simple: if the Yankees are serious about upgrading this roster, they have to be willing to move players who haven't lived up to expectations. Volpe fits that description whether fans want to admit it or not.

Ryan Garcia has reported that rival clubs continue to show genuine interest in Volpe. Why? Because he's still just 25 years old, he's inexpensive, and another organization may believe a change of scenery unlocks the player scouts once projected him to become.

That's the key.

The Yankees may no longer believe they can fix him.

Another team might.

Devon Platana went a step further by predicting Volpe could be one of the first underperforming Yankees shown the door if Brian Cashman decides this club needs a serious shakeup before the deadline. That's not exactly shocking.

If the Yankees are going to change the direction of this roster, they can't keep clinging to former top prospects simply because of where they were drafted.

Now look, for me, Ryan Jeffers makes too much sense. If Minnesota is willing to listen, Ryan Jeffers should absolutely be near the top of Brian Cashman's wish list. The Yankees have desperately needed offensive production from the catcher position, and Jeffers immediately upgrades the lineup. He gives the Yankees another legitimate bat while stabilizing a position that's been an offensive black hole for far too long.

Would it hurt to give up Volpe? Not even alittle. Maybe he'd cry which only means to me that he's been babied too much by the Yankees organization.  It also solves two problems at once. Minnesota gets a young shortstop they can develop. The Yankees get a catcher capable of helping them win now. That's exactly the kind of baseball trade contenders make.

Then there's CJ Abrams of the Nationals. I don't actually see this happening, but wow what a rumor. If the Washington Nationals decide to entertain offers, Abrams would represent everything the Yankees hoped Volpe would become. He's an All-Star caliber shortstop with game-changing speed, legitimate power and the type of offensive production that transforms a lineup. While injuries have forced other Yankees stars to carry more of the load, Abrams has emerged as one of the most dynamic young players in baseball.

Replacing Volpe with Abrams isn't just an upgrade. It's a statement. It shows us Yankee fans that the Yankees are actually series 9 years into Boone's managerial career.  

And there's another catcher worth watching by the way. If Minnesota asks for too much, Cincinnati's Tyler Stephenson becomes another fascinating alternative.

Stephenson has been mentioned repeatedly in trade discussions because he fills the exact hole the Yankees need to address. He's a proven offensive catcher capable of lengthening the lineup while giving the pitching staff a dependable presence behind the plate.

Would the Reds want Volpe as part of that conversation? Given his age and years of club control, they just might. Plus, I was convinced last year Volpe would become a Red for some strange reason.  Google it.  It just makes sense to me.

And here's the other reality nobody wants to ignore. George Lombard Jr. is coming.

The Yankees' top prospect continues to impress throughout the minor leagues, and there's a growing belief inside baseball that he's the organization's future at shortstop. If the Yankees truly believe Lombard is the better long-term answer, why keep forcing Volpe into a role he hasn't fully claimed?

Sometimes the hardest move is admitting you were wrong. Sometimes it's also the smartest one. Think about that.

But look, it's time, and this isn't about piling on Anthony Volpe. No, I don't think he's a legit major leaguer, but I also don't hate the kid as a person. He was put into this situation but a bunch of guys in a room that chose him because a scout in the Yankees organization knew him.

In the beginning, not knowing that? I wanted him to succeed. But the Yankees don't hand out trophies for patience. They are supposed to chase championships.

If Volpe's biggest value now is bringing back a catcher like Ryan Jeffers, opening the door for George Lombard Jr., or becoming part of a blockbuster for someone like CJ Abrams, then Brian Cashman has to seriously consider pulling the trigger.

Holding onto a player because you're afraid of watching him succeed somewhere else isn't a strategy. It's fear.

And the Yankees have spent enough time hoping Anthony Volpe becomes something he hasn't shown he can consistently be. Sometimes the best move for both sides is admitting it's over.

This might finally be that moment.