Showing posts with label rafael palmeiro. Show all posts
Showing posts with label rafael palmeiro. Show all posts

Sunday, January 26, 2025

WHEN WILL THE HALL OF FAME WRITERS STOP THEIR MORAL JUDGEMENT?


Alex Rodriguez has shown significant growth since retiring from baseball, and his maturity was on full display as he extended heartfelt congratulations to this year’s Hall of Fame inductees this week. While his graciousness is admirable, it’s hard to ignore that he’s likely feeling some disappointment over not being considered for the Hall of Fame himself. After all, Rodriguez is undoubtedly one of the greatest hitters in baseball history. However, his connection to performance-enhancing drugs has cast a long shadow over his career, and it’s evident that sportswriters are reluctant to honor athletes tied to scandals or controversy.

Rodriguez’s career stats speak for themselves: three AL MVP awards, 696 home runs, 3,115 hits, 14 All-Star Game appearances, and a 2009 World Series championship with the Yankees. Yet, despite these achievements, he remains on the outside looking in, even as he appeared on the ballot for the fourth consecutive year. His predicament isn’t unique, as history shows that Hall of Fame voters consistently penalize players linked to performance-enhancing drugs or other ethical concerns.


Take Mark McGwire, for instance. Despite his record-breaking home run season and an illustrious career, McGwire has not been elected to the Hall of Fame due to his admitted steroid use. Similarly, Roger Clemens—who dominated as one of the best pitchers in MLB history—fell short of the 75% vote threshold in his final year of eligibility in 2022, earning just 65.2% of the vote. This trend reveals a clear pattern: past transgressions, whether proven or suspected, continue to hold players back from baseball’s highest honor. 

And it’s not just players from the steroid era who face scrutiny. Even Carlos Beltrán, whose involvement in the Houston Astros’ sign-stealing scandal tarnished his reputation, has found himself under the Hall of Fame microscope. Terry Collins, former Mets manager, recently spoke out about the situation, calling Beltrán’s treatment unfair. Collins pointed out that plenty of Hall of Famers likely benefited from knowing what pitches were coming, yet Beltrán seems to be bearing the brunt of the blame as one of the few players associated with the Astros scandal. Collins stated, “He wasn’t even a starting player, so it’s not like he gained much from what was happening.”

The broader question remains: when will this end? How long will Hall of Fame voters continue to blacklist players from the steroid era or those caught in controversial moments? At what point does the selective moral outrage stop? It’s worth questioning why certain players—such as Harold Baines, whose inclusion in the Hall sparked debate—are inducted while others with far more impressive resumes are excluded.  Think about it; even Jered Weaver tweaked this after Ichiro got in:

"1 writer said no on Ichiro?  another example of why Hall of Famers should vote on it and not writers"

He's not wrong. Why should these writers hold any power?

Barry Bonds, for example, is arguably the greatest hitter the sport has ever seen. Sammy Sosa, Rafael Palmeiro, and even Pete Rose—all legendary players in their own right—remain outside the Hall due to scandals or suspicions, despite their undeniable impact on the game. Isn’t it time for voters, many of whom have never played baseball at the professional level, to reconsider their stance?

The Hall of Fame is meant to honor the greatest players in the history of baseball, yet it feels increasingly like a battleground for moral judgment. If the goal is to preserve the integrity of the game, perhaps it’s time to reflect on whether this rigid gatekeeping is achieving that—or simply rewriting history.






Saturday, January 25, 2025

SABATHIA IS A TRUE TEAM GUY!


Andy Pettitte has always been beloved by Yankee fans, and for good reason. To many—including myself—it's baffling that Pettitte isn’t in the Hall of Fame yet. What stands out most about him, beyond his stellar stats, is the respect he commands from his peers. CC Sabathia, a true leader, phenomenal teammate, and competitor who just loves the game and winning above all else, spoke out about Pettitte's worthiness. Reflecting on his time with Pettitte, Sabathia said, “For me, Andy is a Hall of Famer. Getting a chance to pitch alongside him, getting a chance to still talk to him pretty much all the time, I believe he’s a Hall of Famer.”

Sabathia and Pettitte were teammates for four seasons, including the Yankees' 2009 World Series win. While Sabathia earned an overwhelming 86% of the vote in his first Hall of Fame ballot, Pettitte received just 27.9% this year—an improvement from the 13.5% he garnered in 2024, but still far from the threshold. Unfortunately, time is running out for Pettitte’s case.

For years, I’ve been highly critical of players linked to PEDs, but my stance has evolved. Yes, mistakes were made, and Andy Pettitte admitted to his, but those moments were minor compared to his otherwise remarkable career. His achievements are undeniable:

  • Pettitte compiled a 256–153 win-loss record, a 3.85 ERA, and 2,448 strikeouts across 3,316 innings.
  • He’s the only pitcher since 1930 to win at least 12 games in each of his first nine seasons.
  • He recorded the second-most career pickoffs (98), trailing only Steve Carlton (144).
  • Pettitte holds the record for the most postseason wins in MLB history, with 19.
  • He had 24 complete games, four shutouts, and never experienced a losing season in his career. In 16 of his 18 seasons, he won 11 or more games.
  • He was a five-time World Series champion with the Yankees.

Beyond the numbers, Pettitte’s pickoff move was legendary, and his consistency and poise in big games were unmatched. Yet, some writers seem to place him in the same moral category as others like Barry Bonds, Roger Clemens, and Rafael Palmeiro, despite Pettitte’s transparency and the relatively minor nature of his admitted misstep. The reason for the change in my stance is simple. When you start letting in lesser players with less impressive numbers just because you don't want to let monster players like Bonds or Pettitte in that's when things are unbalanced and wrong.

CC Sabathia’s support for Pettitte is a testament to the type of player and person Andy is. Sabathia has always been the kind of teammate to lift others up, and his endorsement should hold weight. Pettitte deserves his place in Cooperstown, and it’s about time the writers recognize it.




Thursday, April 30, 2015

REMEMBERING WHEN WILLIE MAYS 'HAD AMPHETAMINES'


It's been discussed for days now about how a San Francisco Giants fan wrote an open letter to Rob Manfred asking him to put an asterisk on Alex Rodriguez's 660 home run if he hits it to tie baseball great Willie Mays.  While I understand what the fan is trying to do, I don't think something like that would ever happen.  By the way, here's that letter:


I found it very interesting, and you know I'm a die hard baseball fan and I love my Yankees. I also respect the history of the game and the players and all of that.  You also know by now that I'm not an ARod fan.  I say all that because I was recently reminded about the time Willie Mays was accused of supplying amphetamines in the New York Mets locker room.  Don't know what I mean? Oh yeah, it was a big deal, for a brief moment back in the 80's and nothing ever came of it, but I was able to find the LA Times article written back in 1985.
"John Milner testified Thursday in a federal cocaine trafficking trial.The former Met said his first introduction to a liquid amphetamine called "red juice" was from a bottle he took from Mays' locker... 'Management wasn't giving me greenies or red juice or speed--Willie had the red juice,' Milner said. He added, however, that he had not seen Mays take amphetamines.

Mays, who joined the Mets in 1972, said that his locker 'was an open book. Anybody could go into my locker because I never had anything to hide.' As to whether he ever used "red juice" or any stimulant, Mays said: 'My record speaks for itself. I never missed a game for misusing my body. I'm 54 right now and I'm in fairly good shape. I could never have played like I did if I'd misused my body.'"
(In Photo: John Milner)
John Milner was a former teammate of Mays and got himself into trouble.  It was pretty ridiculous that he'd even drag Mays into his own mess... but he did. It didn't stick.

I only bring this up because fandom is a fascinating thing to me. With all this PEDs talk these days, we tend to forget that for years in clubhouses there were clouds of suspicion.  We've heard the stories of "bowls of greenies" players would take in locker rooms and there were alot of other suspicious stuff going on.  The reality is, Willie Mays was truly great, and I believed him then when he said he didn't misuse his body.


Then again, I believed Rafael Palmeiro when he testified he never used either.  You remember how that worked out.

Mays never used and no one ever did, or needed to do an investigation into Mays, probably because Willie Mays is the greatest, hands down.  But these days, everyone is under a microscope and under suspicion, hence, no one believes any of these players these days either.


Plus, even after all the Alex Rodriguez stuff, the Ryan Braun stuff, players like Ervin Santana are still getting suspending for 80 games for an illegal substance.  How unbelievable is that?  You would think these players would learn, but they don't, because they don't even know what they're putting into their bodies.


Am I accusing Willie of anything? No way, but when I saw that Open letter about ARod, the home run chase and Willie Mays, it brought me back to the 80's.  It was something I had to go back and look up, that's all.  The suspicions... the accusations... that's always been going on.  These days though, it's much, much more intense, that's all.

You've made BYB the fastest growing Yankees fan site in history. Now shop at the Bleeding Yankee Blue store!  Follow me on Twitter @BleednYankeeBlu and LIKE Bleeding Yankee Blue on Facebook!  Also, don't forget to check out the BYB Hub!

Thursday, January 16, 2014

SQUEEGEE TO AROD: "ADMIT TO WHAT YOU DID!"


I got an email the other day and it was important.  It was from an old friend, Luigi Squeegee, the author of the book Clubhouse Confidential and the former bat boy of the New York Yankees.  Luigi supported Bleeding Yankee Blue back when it was literally 4 of us, and we always stayed in touch. But under the circumstances of Alex Rodriguez and he being a former bat boy in the clubhouse... I knew this message was different.


You see, Luigi is a father like me. We've talked alot about how our kids see these big baseball heroes doing big things and now, all of them are under the cloud of suspicion, all because a group of individuals over the years decided that cheating and using PEDs was the way to go.


In short, it's out of control and for Squeegee, a guy that stood in the same clubhouse with the likes of ARod, Derek Jeter, Roger Clemens and Chuck Knoblauch, it was clear... he had enough.

So I did my best prep work for an interview that needed to be done, but Squeegee was so fired up, I scratched my questions and let him go.  This ladies and gentlemen is real.  You want to talk about frustration as a parent who doesn't know how to explain PEDs and cheating to their son or daughter? You want to talk about the loss of integrity in this great game because of liars and cheaters in baseball? Squeegee had plenty to say about it.  And before you think he irrelevant, understand this; Luigi Squeegee saw more stuff going on in that clubhouse than anyone I know.  Now sure, I'm not about to taint the Yankees, I love my team. The point is, he knows things and he's frustrated all these years later with Alex Rodriguez and his steroids charade.  So here's what Squeegee told me in his own words... and he's sharing it with my Bleeding Yankee Blue audience...  Enjoy this, I did:

Luigi Squeegee: "I left the Yankees in 2005. Steroids in baseball were going on then and today, all these years later, it is all people talk about.  No longer do people talk about just going to a game with their mother and father.  Instead, they talk about who's using and who isn't. It's a terrible message these cheaters are sending and steroid use is slowly becoming a virus.  It's disappointing."


BYB: This is clearly driven by you being a parent. You're pretty angry...

Luigi Squeegee: "Of course! I was in Yankees Spring Training sitting with guys like Derek Jeter watching Congress question Rafael Palmeiro and all those guys.  I was 18 years old, a bat boy for the Yankees and I was skinny and I was thinking to myself then, how can I get big? Is this the way?"

BYB: Right, because you're seeing players getting bigger, but denying their usage.

Luigi Squeegee: "Yup and all these years later, those players have all used even though they denied it. Look, I have kids and they look up to guys like Derek Jeter.  But they also looked up to ARod and Big Papi and when they see those players, they says to me, 'those guys hit the ball far!'  When they're on the field, my kids just want to hit it as far as them... when they can't, so they get upset.  So I ask you, when my kids are old enough and they're in the same situation, are they gonna think about wanting to use? You see what I mean?"


BYB: I hear you.  And when a player is playing well, my son will say, 'He's great... is he on drugs?'

Luigi Squeegee: "Right! Look at Ryan Braun. I thought he was totally honest with me and America and he lied to my face and I'll never trust him again.  I know I've made mistakes, but I admitted to my mistakes in my book. These people still deny."

BYB: I know, but Braun's disappeared now to serve his 65 games and he'll come back and continue racking up his numbers like nothing happened.

Luigi Squeegee: "And then you have all these players that play the game clean and now they are either accused or become frustrated because they can't compete with the cheaters.  


Look at a guy like Enrique Wilson.  He didn't make a lot of money but he was able to crush a guy like Pedro Martinez. He did it clean.  People forget what baseball is all about.  It's not about the mansions and the private jets, that's the wrong message.  It's about loving the game. Baseball is no longer loved, it's tainted."

BYB: Did you see physically see PEDs in the Yankee clubhouse?

Luigi Squeegee: "No... but I saw the size of these guys and how they got bigger from year to year, and even teams and owners know it's happening.  Look at a guy like Jason Giambi.  


He got real big in Oakland, but the Yankees still signed the guy. He ended up admitting to using something, but he's 41 years old and he's still playing.  It's crazy to think about this, and this is where I defend ARod and the ONLY time I do;  There are several guys that had admitted using and nothing happens to them.  Like Andy Pettitte for example. Meanwhile, ARod gets 162 games. There were others, why just him? Major League Baseball needs to go after everyone equally.  See, this is what I'm talking about. Everyone is focused on steroids for over a decade and it's sending the wrong message to our youth."

BYB: Yeah, Alex is the big fish. What was he like when you were the bat boy in 2004 and 2005?


Luigi Squeegee: "He's selfish. I wrote about it in my book! I remember in Spring Training 2004, I was assigned to be his personal assistant. But he didn't want the Yankees to give him an assistant. He wanted his own and he was trying to get the Yankees to give him someone from the Texas Rangers. The Yankees refused and so they eventually agreed on another guy. It was just this thing about him, he usually did things alone.  You wouldn't see him and Jeter hanging out other than a "Hi". Same with Ruben Sierra, they weren't "friends", just teammates. ARod did hang out with Robinson Cano or Melky Cabrera or Luis Sojo a bit.  But even in the plane, I remember we were flying home and Ruben (Sierra) and I were watching a movie and ARod was alone asking, 'Hey, what are you guys watching?'  Always alone.


The worst though had to be in 2004. I remember we lost to the Red Sox. Alex was sitting in his locker wearing his pinstriped pants and his blue Yankee shirt... and he's smoking a cigar talking to reporters.  WE JUST LOST TO THE SOX! I will never forget that. And now, years later he's banned for PEDs for the whole 2014 season."

BYB: I can tell you're pissed...

Luigi Squeegee: "That's because it's taking over baseball.  I used to be known as the bat boy of the World Champion Yankees.  Now I'm known at the bay boy of the steroid era.  People have recognized me from my book Clubhouse Confidential and said to me, 'the Yankees cheated when you were with them.'  I hate hearing that."

BYB: But what's the solution?

Luigi Squeegee: "One failed test and you're out of baseball.  If you're going to cheat, you're going to cheat again. I'd rather you're banned from the game if you fail a test 1 time."


BYB: And what's your message to Alex Rodriguez?

Luigi Squeegee: "Just admit to what you did!  That's my piece of advice. Alex, you’re already suspended so just come out an admit you cheated like you did back in 2009.  Apologize...  and maybe America will forgive you.  Maybe God didn't actually put you on this earth to hit 800 home runs.  Maybe God put you here to fix this wrong.  You could actually be the baseball player that fixed the steroid era. You still can make a change. Maybe you can come out and educate kids on the dangers of PEDs.  Maybe this is what God sent you here to do... Save baseball."

That's real. That's a conversation between 2 dads.  I particularly like his closing quote to Alex.  Fix the wrong, admit it. Educate kids.  I like that.

More importantly, it is what Luigi is doing for kids that I also found very noble and I spoke to him about that too.  Squeegee started a foundation called Squeegee’s Childrens Literacy Foundation. It's a not for profit foundation geared toward educating kids on the importance of education and reading.  We have part 2 of our interview with Luigi coming soon.  Look for it here on BYB.



Thank you to all the Bleeding Yankee Blue readers for continued success.  You've made BYB the fasted growing Yankees fan site in the history of Yankees fandom.  Thanks for reading, sharing and enjoying. Follow me on Twitter @BleednYankeeBlu and join the group Bleeding Yankee Blue (Official) on Facebook, just type it in.

Thursday, July 25, 2013

PUT PETE ROSE ON THE HALL OF FAME BALLOT!


With everything swirling around now in Major League Baseball, the PEDs, the accusations and how it's hurt this great game... What the hell did Pete Rose do as a player to ban him from baseball for life?  I'll tell you... Nothing.  Pete Rose was one of the hungriest players I've ever seen as a kid. For a short time in the 1970's, I lived in Lexington, Kentucky. I saw the guy play first hand and I wanted to be him.  I loved his grit and dedication to trying to be a better player every single day he was on the field.  Sure, Pete's world of betting on baseball as a manager banned him from baseball for life, I'm not stupid. At the time, it was a big deal.  Now though, as we look around baseball and see this news surrounding PEDs and the harsher fines that baseball is about to hand out...is what Pete Rose did really that bad anymore? Seriously, it's time to move on. Reinstate Pete.  Pete Rose needs to come back to baseball and needs to be put on the ballot. If anything, I think it would represent a new life of the true baseball player... natural and hungry to win.

I know, in the voting, there is a part of it that deals with a player's integrity and character, read HERE.  Honestly, I know for a fact when the subject of Rose being "written in" comes up and the voters see that integrity part, they are less likely to write him in... and I get it, it scares the voters off. But as a player, there was no one better than Pete Rose.


He was a good teammate with the Big Red Machine, a hard nosed athlete with 4256 hits in his career and 3 World championships. There are guys with less that are in the Hall... And you know what? From what I know... He didn't bet on baseball as a player and he didn' t take PEDs either. Take the betting out of the equation.  Pete Rose needs to go on the ballot.



Think about what PEDs has done to this game. These days, kids heroes are cheaters. Our kids are confused. "If cheating is wrong, why is Ryan Braun doing it?" Baseball is a mess right now, and right now, it doesn't feel right.  When Pete Rose was banned from the game, it didn't feel right either, but Rose's sin  didn't impact the game as much as PEDs has. Plus, Rose the player deserves a shot on the ballot. Think about it this way, If Pete Rose never bet on baseball as a manager, he'd be in the hall of fame right now and we wouldn't be writing about this.

I don't know, I just think all this PEDs stuff has really impacted the game in a negative way. Rose's betting didn't impact the game to the capacity that this scandal has, no way!  I mean, for him personally, morally, he was wrong, and he knows that, but he didn't do anything as a player that I didn't appreciate and you can understand where I'm coming from on that.  Rose was a gamer and he did it with what he had, not with what he could take to improve.


Put Pete Rose on the ballot... the time is now.

Read more about this in ENOUGHT'S ENOUGH. TIME FOR PETE ROSE TO GO TO COOPERSTOWN,   

"Think of it this way, the Barry Bonds and Mark McGwire's, the Sammy Sosa's and Rafael Palmeiro's are the guys under a cloud of suspicion for PEDs and we are actually going to figure out how to vote for these guys. Sadly, eventually all of them will go to the Hall of Fame, but Pete never will.  Yup, there have been op-ed's from people smarter than me saying, "How will the writer's vote in the steroid era?", yet God forbid someone says Pete Rose, you quickly hear a "He's banned," and they move on.  Well, let's not move on any longer."

I wrote that last year... and I'm right about this.

The Bleeding Yankee Blue store is opened! CLICK HERE TO START SHOPPING! Also, follow me on Twitter @BleednYankeeBlu and join the group Bleeding Yankee Blue (Official) on Facebook, just type it in.

Thursday, January 31, 2013

ALEX RODRIGUEZ PROVES MY CASE

I’m not even going to delve into the current PED mess floating around baseball right now. I will say this though, whether it's true or not, whomever linked Alex Rodriguez to this story has just done me a HUGE favor. What I’m about to say may blow your minds: Frank Thomas is the greatest power hitter of the last 25 years! WHAT? Yes! That's right, I said it.

Let’s all jump in our “way-back” machines to that magical year of 1990. The Yankees were dreadful. I was 11, really had nothing to cheer about (except for my hero Donnie Baseball). But it was another first baseman that competed for my heart way back then.

All of my friends and cousins instantly fell in love with Ken Griffey Jr. They did nothing but talk about his greatness and they all competed to see who could accumulate the most Griffey baseball cards. Not me, I was at the baseball card shop (do they even exist anymore?) seeking out Frank Thomas. 

Sure Griffey was fast and made playing centerfield look effortless, but there was something about this linebacker-sized guy playing first base and hitting monstrous home runs that caught my eye.

Thomas had a stellar career with the White Sox. He came back from a torn triceps muscle and continued putting up power numbers. Aside from all that thought, he had a terrific eye. He amassed over 1600 walks in his career. (A number that I’m sure is padded because of the fear opposing pitchers had facing him.) Ultimately it was the broken foot in 2004 that was the beginning of the end for Thomas.

When he finally called it quits in 2010, after sitting out all of 2009, Thomas had amassed a .301 lifetime batting average, 521 home runs, 1704 RBI, and a .974 OPS. His .301 puts him ahead of both Griffey and ARod. He’s currently tied for 18th all-time for home runs with 6 known or suspected PED users in front of him (Bonds, Rodriguez, Sosa, McGwire, Palmeiro, and Manny Ramirez) and 22nd in RBI. He did all of this playing his home games in pitcher friendly Comisky Park.

Over the weekend Thomas was quoted as saying that all of this talk about PEDs makes his accomplishments much more special, read HERE. And he’s correct. He’s never been linked to anything. Thomas came up as rookie as a large man and retired as the same large man. For the most part he was never flashy, never controversial, seemed to be a terrific teammate. Unless something earth shattering comes out over the next year he should be a first ballot Hall of Famer – something Alex Rodriguez will never accomplish.




--Lem Allen, BYB Contributor
Email me at: bybcurmudgeon@gmail.com



Please comment, we have DISQUS, it's easier than ever. Let me know what you think and follow me on Twitter @BleednYankeeBlu and join the group Bleeding Yankee Blue on Facebook, just type it in.

Saturday, September 22, 2012

MELKY DID GOOD, BUT SELIG'S GOT SOME EXPLAINING TO DO

Newspaper columnist Bob Klapisch writes a good piece every day.  Many times, I yell at my Bergen Record... Damn you Klapischhh!!!!  
Another good piece today titled Melky Cabrera did right thing bowing out, but come on Bob, how much is Major League Baseball paying you so you can say kind words about them? 

Let's agree on this; Melky Cabrera did what was morally right, he requested to be taken out of contention for the National League Batting title. That was great. That's not what I have a beef with. My beef is what Major League Baseball said 1 day earlier about the NL batting title.

They said that they wouldn't interfere, read HERE. Selig said “We’ll see how it all plays out... We generally don’t interfere in that process. We’ll take a look at it at the end of the year.”  So what's my point? Simple, How is that good for baseball and Selig? The only thing they did was agree to withdraw Melky's name, but Melky made the request, MLB didn't do anything. The solution fell in their lap.


It's my opinion that MLB should have pushed "rules" aside, took the reigns of their "Clean up of PEDs in Major League Baseball" campaign and acted like the authoirty. They are the ones that should have made the decision, before Melky came forward. Remember that dog and pony show in front of Congress that sparked this whole thing?

Remember Mark McGwire and Rafael Palmeiro being asked hard questions about PEDs in baseball? Remember Major League baseball coming forward after that enforcing new rules? MLB should have dropped the hammer the day Melky admitted it.  But no, they found the easy way out, they waited it out in the hopes that fans would forget again.
I love what  Melky Cabrera did yesterday, but I'm skittish when it comes to Major League Baseball, because it's personal for me.  Kids want answers. My kid wants answers.  Kids are confused and kids need to know that cheating is wrong, not just from their parents, but by the sports they follow. Remember, they want to be like these athletes.  Sure, Melky stepping forward was huge, but MLB needs to make stronger and tougher punishments for PEDs in baseball, bottom line.


And yeah, I've been beating this drum for a while now and I know, it's old and tired and I apologize.  But finally, Klapisch writes that everyone should be a fan of this purge because "it would slow cheating to a trickle." I disagree. Trickle only comes when the authority drops the hammer.  MLB is the authority. I doubt there will be a trickle, but I hope I'm wrong.

Sure, Klapisch and I disagree on things quite a bit, but damn he makes you think. You need to admire that.  OK, enough with Melky and PEDs... time for breakfast.

Please comment, we have DISQUS, it's easier than ever. Let me know what you think and follow me on Twitter @BleednYankeeBlu and join the group Bleeding Yankee Blue on Facebook, just type it in.

Thursday, August 16, 2012

MELKY CABRERA: WHEN SUNSHINE TURNS TO DARKNESS

I have expressed an appreciation for how Melky Cabrera’s road through the Major Leagues has been.  I like success stories.  I like when my kid can come up to me and say “I like that Melky guy now, he can hit!”  I don’t like it when I then have to wait for him to come up to me and say “What’s illegal substance mean?”  At that point, I want all these athletes who knowingly take PEDs to call my house. I want to put them on the phone with my 9 year old and have them explain to my kid who worships athletes that cheating isn’t the answer.  Why? I’ll tell you why…what happened to Melky Cabrera yesterday should not have happened, read HERE.) He had the talent, he just needed to play ball…that’s it. 

Look, I’ve stated my position on PEDs. I hate the topic. It makes me queasy.  There is no winner.  You have these players who may have “knowingly” or “not knowingly” dabbled in performance enhancing drugs and then you get stuck in the weeds trying to figure out what really happened. In the end, Major League baseball says it’s wrong, they test and leave it at that.  Enter Melky Cabrera, whom I expected more from, or maybe not.  There was no doubt Melky did this on purpose and then got caught. He admitted it in a statement yesterday, read below:

 "My positive test was the result of my use of a substance I should not have used. I accept my suspension under the Joint Drug Program and I will try to move on with my life. I am deeply sorry for my mistake and I apologize to my teammates, to the San Francisco Giants organization and to the fans for letting them down."

I’m disappointed, but maybe I’m not surprised. Why? Because Melky Cabrera was out to prove something.  He wanted everyone to know that he could be a great ballplayer and so, he looked for a short cut, he cheated.  When he won the MVP at the All-Star game, I was thrilled for him. When he did his “Crotch-chop” in Atlanta, I was quickly disappointed and I wondered “What’s up with the arrogance in this guy?”   
The guy just seems too immature to handle any of his recent fame and popularity and that’s the first thing that came to mind yesterday when I read about him failing the test.  He just doesn’t get it.

I try to tell my kids, don’t cheat and they get that, but what’s to say they’ll get it when they hit high school and some dude has a barrel full of protein mix in their locker. Or in college if they’re so lucky to continue playing and there’s a guy with a substance that will make them run faster and “no one has to know”…then what?   As a parent, you guide your kid, but you can’t hand them their towel in the locker room after a big college game, you know what I mean?  You teach values, but how do you make sure those values stick when Melky Cabrera or ARod or Rafael Palmeiro pops up? Interesting question, I think I have an answer.


Now, in fairness to Melky, he admitted it, much like Alex Rodriguez, much like Andy Pettitte and in the public eye, it seems to help…but it’s always in the back of people's mind…mine included. Many of us like when people admit wrongdoing, but it still sticks.  I think about it a lot, but there I go again, wondering what happened and if it was done intentionally or by mistake.  There are guys that probably took it and were never tested and guess what…we don’t know if it really happened or not, we just speculate. I hate all of this, but not because they did what they did to their bodies or the baseball records or all that crap, but for my kids.  Why the hell should I have to explain to my child about some other man’s mistakes? Why? So here’s my solution…

You want to make a real punishment for these players? Here’s a tip, in addition to a 50 game suspension from Major league baseball for testing positive on their first offense, they also must record a message that should be posted on the MLB website and also cut into a Public Service Announcement for television and radio of the player who failed the test. In that Public Service Announcement, it should simply state (and I’ll use Melky Cabrera as an example):
“My name is Melky Cabrera, I was an All-Star outfielder with the San Francisco Giants this season, but I tested positive for drugs and cheating.  I am now suspended for 50 games.  What I did was wrong.  Don’t be like me. I am not a role model. A role model works hard to achieve their goals.”   

MLB should have to spend the money on the ad space with money the player must pay when they're fined, plus their own dough.  After all they make millions, they can afford it.

Yeah, you want players to stop using PEDs? You will see a dramatic drop in PED use with this punishment, because I’ll tell you why… nobody likes to be publicly humiliated and this is a public shaming that needs to start happening.  Stop tip-toeing around this issue…  address it Major League Baseball, because it’s clear, the 50 game suspension isn’t even working.  Don’t believe me? Talk to Melky Cabrera who knew what he was doing…and clearly didn’t care.  And while you're at it, I'll give you my phone number, he needs to call my son and apologize.

 ORDER A BYB SHIRT NOW, DROB WEARS ONE! Also, Please comment, we have DISQUS, it's easier than ever. Let me know what you think and follow me on Twitter @BleednYankeeBlu and join the group Bleeding Yankee Blue on Facebook, just type it in.