Monday, November 16, 2026

LUIS GIL JUST REOPENED THE SOTO WOUND


Apparently, somebody forgot to tell Luis Gil that Yankee fans are supposed to be over Juan Soto.

In a recent interview with Mike Rodriguez, Gil reportedly reflected warmly on the 2024 clubhouse and said the players wanted Soto back. That doesn’t sound like a guy everybody was eager to help pack.

It also makes the ending sting a little more.

The Yankees had something worth keeping together. They owed their fans a serious effort to preserve it—and a convincing plan if they couldn’t. Fans are entitled to judge how well that replacement plan worked.

But spare me the presentation of Soto as somebody who was kidnapped and transported to Queens against his will.

He chose the Mets. He was entitled to choose his payday, his perks and his future. We’re equally entitled to think that choice put Juan Soto first.

That’s free agency. Just don’t ask us to confuse it with a love story.

Apparently, clubhouse chemistry is wonderful until direct deposit enters the conversation.

And the Yankees don’t get to hide behind his decision forever, either. Cashman’s job includes preparing for the answer he doesn’t want. “We tried” can explain losing a negotiation. It cannot serve as the organization’s permanent business plan.

Gil’s comments don’t prove the Yankees could have kept Soto. They do remind us that the people sharing his clubhouse wanted him there.

The players valued what they had. Soto chose something else. The Yankees still owe everyone a team good enough to make the conversation less painful.

Winning a championship would help.

It generally beats asking the fans to get over it.




No comments:

Post a Comment

Thank you for commenting on Bleeding Yankee Blue.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.