In May of 1957, several Yankee players went out on the town to
celebrate
Billy Martin's 29th birthday. A mix of players and wives were
in the entourage of celebrants that wound up at famous New York hot
spot, the Copacabanna at 10 East 60th Street. Yogi Berra's wife, Carmen,
had ordered a cake for the occasion, and she made the point that this
was Billy's last chance to celebrate before he gets old!
The pastry chef at the Waldorf baked Billy's cake,
and Martin was toasted frequently during and after the birthday dinner.
The revelers had already made a couple of additional stops before
arriving at the Copa for the late show that featured Sammy Davis, Jr. A
couple of the Yankees might have already arrived at what Casey Stengel
called "whiskey slick" status.
Something happened that night that still remains
unclear 55 years later. Also in the club that evening were several
members of an upper Manhattan bowling club, one or more of whom got too
smart with the Yankee players and/or made racially disparaging remarks
directed at Sammy Davis. Whatever took place, the Yankee party
that included
Yogi Berra, Mickey Mantle,
Hank Bauer,
Whitey Ford,
Martin, and
Johnny Kucks took exception.
Both groups adjourned to the cloak room to settle their
differences. Mantle testified later in the subsequent grand jury proceedings
in June of 1957, that the victim came flying out and landed at his
feet. Mantle thought it was Martin and picked him up. (Read
HERE.) Upon seeing that
it was not Martin, Mickey dropped the unfortunate fellow back on the
floor. Mickey testified in court that the gentleman looked like
"Roy
Rogers rode through the Copa on Trigger and Trigger kicked the guy in
the face."
Courtroom witnesses reported that the grand jury
members were still laughing when charges were dismissed against
suspected culprit, and highly decorated ex-Marine, Hank Bauer. The Copa
six, as that group of players came to be known, were part of a four
year run from 1955 through 1958 when the Yankees managed to win
four consecutive American League pennants and two World Series.
While Bauer, Mantle, Ford, and Martin may have been
world class party boys, they were also world class baseball players and
laid it on the line every single game. Manager Casey Stengel said to
Hank Bauer, "You gave 110 percent every time you were in the lineup."
Stengel also referred to Bauer as one of his three best players in
1957. Mickey Mantle was at the pinnacle of his success. Mantle won the
AL MVP award in both 1956 and 1957, and baseball's Triple Crown in 1956
with a 52HR, 130RBI and .353BA year!
In spite of how history has sullied the reputations of
these Yankee players, especially Mantle, it is clear to me that the
group's bonhomie and "
hail fellow well met" approach to life enhanced,
rather than hindered, their baseball performance. (Read
HERE.)
The purpose of rehashing this story is to point out
qualities possessed by the Copa six and other Yankees of that era that
are seemingly missing on the 2012 squad. I know the social mores have
changed; I have lived through the changes that have occurred since the
mid-1950's, but the 2012 Yankees have not shown anything like the
toughness and camaraderie of that mid-fifties group.
When I watch
Robinson Cano stroll to first base on
ground balls, I certainly don't hearken back to the Yankees of the 50's
and 60's. Mickey Mantle, bad knees and all, busted his butt down the
first base line almost every time. The one time he failed to run hard
on a ground ball in 1960, it was a national story. Mantle was pulled
from the lineup and publicly rebuked by Stengel. We sure don't see that
kind of behavior from the current Yankee manager when Cano loafs to
first.
I have also noticed there are no war vets like Bauer
and Jerry
Coleman on the 2012 Yankees; There are no military vets at
all, as far as I know. Henry Albert "Hank" Bauer was a genuine WWII
hero. Bauer fought at Guadalcanal and Okinawa. He earned eleven
campaign ribbons, two Bronze Stars and two Purple Hearts during his 32
months of Pacific Theatre combat. In a desperate fight with the
Japanese at Okinawa, Bauer commanded a Marine unit of 64 men. Only six,
including a badly wounded Bauer, survived.
Does anyone really think Hank Bauer could survive that
ordeal and not acquire some real leadership skills? I know society has
changed and we will likely never see the Bauer, Mantle, Martin type of
players again. Hard scrabble lives make men tough, video games and
cell phones, not so much! Even so, there is no excuse for failing to
face reality and doing your job as well as it can be done. Today's
baseball players are nothing like the men who played the game in
post-war America.
Whereas Yankees like Bauer, Berra, and Martin showed a
fighting spirit, real leadership skills, and a strong bond as friends
and teammates, the current squad of Yankees has not even demonstrated a
sense of urgency during their extended baseball slump and funk. Manager
Joe Girardi seems to spend a lot of his time rationalizing and
apologizing for the poor play of his team. In fact,
all
we have heard from today's Yankee manager and players are platitudes,
excuses, and rationalizations. These are not good vibes if you are a
Yankee fan hoping for more from this team. Maybe it's just the sign of the times, who knows, but I do find it interesting.
Maybe the modern Yankees need to return to the rich
Yankee tradition of a strongly bound team as a first step toward
recovery. Maybe somebody needs to exert some real leadership skill in
the clubhouse. Maybe somebody needs to throw a birthday party, bake a
cake, go out to dinner, have some fun. Maybe the Yankees should have a drink, loosen up a bit and stop trying to protect those well
developed corporate images. Light a fire! Play some hardball baseball! Hey... just an observation... it's my take. What do you think? Comment.
--Frank Gentry, BYB Writer