Let me start by saying that I love David Cone. No beef with him as a person. I love him commentary, I loved him as a player. I loved him when I met him at a Joe Torre Gala several years ago. Class act through and through.
And David Cone is defending the Yankees, pointing to all the things happening behind the scenes that fans supposedly don't see. And I respect that.
Wonderful. Fantastic. Everybody gets a participation trophy.
Look, David Cone is a champion, a smart baseball man and a terrific analyst. But let's not ignore the obvious. Cone works for YES. The Yankees are part of his paycheck. That doesn't automatically make his opinion dishonest, but it certainly makes his defense of the organization a little less surprising.
And here's what bothers me about this whole argument.
Fans don't give a damn about what they can't see behind the scenes. They care about what they CAN see on the field. But even if they did care about what's happening behind the scenes... let's just say, what's happen AIN'T WORKING.
The Yankees haven't won a World Series since 2009. That's not an opinion. That's a fact. All the organizational meetings, analytics departments, scouting reports and internal conversations in the world don't change that.
But there's something much bigger happening here.
When former Yankees start talking about standards, accountability and what it once meant to wear the pinstripes, I hear something else.
I hear an indirect indictment of Aaron Boone. My Opinion.
Now, all these former players they know Boone. They like Boone. Nobody is questioning whether he's a decent human being.
But being a good guy and being a good manager are two entirely different things.
And I believe these former players know it they just can't say it out loud.
They remember a clubhouse where accountability wasn't optional. Where winning wasn't celebrated as an accomplishment in October unless you finished the job. Where the manager commanded respect, demanded excellence and wasn't afraid to make somebody uncomfortable.
Does that sound like Aaron Boone's Yankees to you?
Because it sure as hell doesn't to me.
Boone strikes me as a weak leader. Not because he doesn't care, but because he seems more interested in protecting his players than holding them accountable. There's always an explanation, always a positive takeaway, always another opportunity tomorrow.
At some point, enough is enough.
And perhaps that's what these former Yankees are really trying to tell us without directly embarrassing a guy they personally like.
David Cone can defend the process. Michael Kay can discuss all the things outsiders don't understand. That's their prerogative.
But the fans understand something perfectly well.
The Yankees used to measure success in championships. Now they seem to measure it in explanations.
And until somebody in that organization has the courage to demand more, we're going to keep getting more of the same.
Same leadership. Same excuses. Same disappointing ending.
You can defend the Yankees all you want, Coney.
But you can't defend away 17 years without a championship.
That's not a behind-the-scenes problem. That's a Yankees problem.



No comments:
Post a Comment
Thank you for commenting on Bleeding Yankee Blue.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.