AARON JUDGE IS A YANKEE LEGEND IN THE MAKING

Aaron Judge’s 2024 season stands as a towering achievement in the storied history of the New York Yankees, a franchise synonymous with excellence and greatness. By capturing the American League MVP Award, Judge etched his name alongside some of the most legendary figures ever to don the iconic pinstripes.

Judge became just the third Yankee to win an MVP while serving as team captain, joining the revered Thurman Munson and the indomitable Lou Gehrig. These names evoke the rich tapestry of Yankees lore — Gehrig, the Iron Horse whose durability and grace defined an era, and Munson, the gritty heart of the 1970s Yankees resurgence. Judge, towering both literally and figuratively, continues their legacy, reminding fans that Yankees history is alive and thriving.

The magnitude of Judge’s 2024 MVP win only grows when considering he is just the second Yankee to receive the honor unanimously, joining none other than Mickey Mantle. Mantle’s unanimous MVP in 1956 remains a benchmark for dominance, achieved during a season when the Mick hit for the Triple Crown. Mantle's .353 batting average, 52 home runs, and 130 RBI in that magical year have become the stuff of baseball folklore. Now, Judge has earned his place in that rarefied air, proving that Yankee greatness transcends generations.

In 2024, Aaron Judge put together a season that will be remembered as one of the greatest in Yankees history. Playing a career-high 158 games, Judge slashed .322/.434/.725, a masterful performance that included a jaw-dropping 58 home runs and a league-leading 144 RBIs. His 1.159 OPS cemented him as the most fearsome hitter in the game. Judge’s brilliance helped the Yankees reclaim their throne atop the AL East with a 94-68 record, a testament to his leadership on and off the field.

Comparisons to the Yankee legends that came before him feel inevitable and deserved. Mantle, the five-tool phenomenon of the 1950s and ’60s, finished in the top five of MVP voting nine times, taking home the award in 1956, 1957, and 1962. In his back-to-back MVP seasons, Mantle slashed .358/.487/.686, hitting a staggering 86 home runs across those two campaigns. And then there’s Gehrig, whose MVP wins in 1927 and 1936 remain emblematic of his unparalleled consistency and power. Gehrig's 1927 campaign coincided with the Yankees' historic Murderers' Row lineup, while his 1936 MVP season came as he seamlessly transitioned to a leadership role following Babe Ruth’s departure.

Judge embodies the same traits that made Mantle, Gehrig, and Munson such revered figures in Yankees history: a combination of skill, leadership, and a sense of destiny that makes fans feel they are witnessing something transcendent. It’s humbling to think we are living in an era where we can watch Judge patrol Yankee Stadium, hit towering home runs, and make history with every swing of the bat. For Yankees fans, Judge’s brilliance is a reminder that while the legends of Mantle, Gehrig, and Munson may seem like folklore, their spirit lives on every time Judge steps onto the diamond.

--Alvin Izzo

BYB Yankee History Contributor