I still remember his rookie card. It was the 1981 Topps card that I remember best partly because Valenzuela just had this look on his face like he wasn't ready for his picture to be taken and partly because Mike Scioscia was also on the card.
Anyway, not to get off track, but recently, one of my buddy’s tweeted me about Manny Banuelos…. "Fernando Valenzuela Part II" he wrote. It got me thinking, “Maybe Carlos is right.” I mean, not since Fernando was I this excited about a Mexican pitcher like I am about Manny Banuelos. So much so that I would have given away Dellin Betances, Andrew Brackman, and Jesus Montero but still would have held onto Manny at the trade deadline.
Now look, Manny hasn’t exactly been lights out this year, but he is a lefty and he has some really good stuff as a young arm in the minor leagues. In 2 games right now with Scranton Wilkes Barres, he has a 2.45 ERA, 0-1 with 16.2 innings pitched. He's given up 20 hits, 6 earned runs, struck out 16 and walked 7. It's still early for this kid, and again, those number don't seem great, but I have faith. I see him making an appearance in the big show before the end of the season, but coming out of the pen...and it's exciting.
Then I got curious, what were Fernando Valenzuela's minor league numbers. Well, for San Antonio AA ball, he had a season of 13-9, with a 3.10 ERA, 27 games, 174 innings pitched. He gave up 60 earned runs on 156 hits, but he also struck out 162.
Compare that to Manny's AA numbers, Manny had the following: a 4-6 record, a 3.58 ERA in 23 games. In 110.2 Innings pitched he game up only 44 earned runs and 109 hits. he also struck out 111.
So, is there just too much hype when it comes to Manny? I'm not sure, but I still like what I see and if there is any way he can come up so we can get a glance and he can work against big league hitters, something may click. I can’t help but wonder when Manny comes up to the big show, will he take the world by storm the way Fernando Valenzuela did?
It’s tough to put this much pressure on these kids. Clearly they all want to pitch in the pros, but in a world of pitch counts and training, when is the right time for a call up? Brian Cashman made it clear early on that he didn’t want to rush these kids. Bleeding Yankee Blue is rooting for a promotion though and hopefully a call out of the pen as a lefty specialist this fall is truly in the works. But like we’ve seen with Stephen Strasburg, rushing these guys could do more damage than good. Strasburg should bounce back, but to be that young and to be hurt as quickly as he was, you need to worry. Read about Strasburg HERE.
Could Manny be the next Fernando Valenzuela? Who knows, Valenzuela had some great years and Manny early on in the farm system has proven he could handle batters, and hopefully he'll improve. One thing is for sure, I can't help but think about all the chatter about him in Spring Training. Time will tell, but there’s no question, it’s getting exciting in Yankeeland.
First of all, thank you profusely...it is an honor to be cited by the BEST Yankees blog on the net, bar none!
ReplyDeleteLike you, I too had those Fernando memories, especially Game 3 of the 1981 World Series in LA, when they began to turn the series around. (sadly for us)
Cool comparison in terms of the numbers, and you are right the pressure is enormous, to live up to, in terms of the great Valenzuela.
"Brian Cashman made it clear early on that he didn’t want to rush these kids. Bleeding Yankee Blue is rooting for a promotion though and hopefully a call out of the pen as a lefty specialist this fall is truly in the works."
Lastly, though we want to be careful, I don't see why he could not give us a spot inning here and there, down the stretch in September, in say non-stressful situations...