MICHAEL KAY FINALLY SAID "STUMP MERRILL". WE DID THAT ALREADY

Michael Kay finally did it.

He looked at this Yankees mess and uttered two words that should send chills down the spine of anyone who's lived through the late '80s and early '90s:

Stump Merrill.

Welcome to the conversation. But if you're going to go after this team quoting the "Stump Merrill era" you have to blame Boone for being just as bad as Merrill was, but you won't because you get paid by the Yankees. We here at Bleeding Yankee Blue? We'll say it.

But seriously, the funny part isn't that Kay finally made the comparison. The funny part is that Bleeding Yankee Blue has been connecting those dots for years, long before it became acceptable on the airwaves.

Back in 2021 THE YANKEES ARE DEAD BECAUSE OF POOR LEADERSHIP, we wrote exactly where this train was heading:

"Aaron Boone is the reason this Yankee team is terrible. Leadership is vital in this game and Boone doesn't have it. You know who else didn't have it? Stump Merrill. Dallas Green. Those were dark times as a Yankee fan. We're back to those times."

That wasn't written after one bad week. That wasn't written to grab headlines. That was written because the same problems kept showing up over and over again and it's still happening.

Now here's where Michael Kay—and much of the mainstream Yankees media—stops because he has to. We don't.

Because if you're going to compare this era to the Stump Merrill years, then you have to be honest enough to explain why.

The Stump Merrill Yankees weren't remembered simply because the roster wasn't good. They were remembered because there wasn't leadership. There wasn't accountability. The clubhouse wasn't being driven by a manager capable of getting more from his players. That's why those teams drifted.

That's why those years became synonymous with mediocrity.

And here's the uncomfortable question...

What's different today? Sure, blame the players. Absolutely. They're the ones swinging the bats. They're the ones making the errors. They're the ones failing to deliver in October—or, lately, just failing to deliver. But baseball has always been bigger than the box score.

Leadership matters. Culture matters. Direction matters. A manager isn't there just to hand the baseball to the starting pitcher and fill out a lineup card. He's supposed to set the standard.

When the same mistakes happen every game and every season... When fundamentals disappear every season... When urgency vanishes every season...eventually the conversation has to move beyond the players.

It has to move to the men in charge. Aaron Boone.

Brian Cashman has wrapped Boone in enough bubble wrap to survive a five-story fall.

Every collapse comes with another excuse. Every poor decision is explained away. Every postseason disappointment is followed by another vote of confidence.

The result? No championships. No meaningful progress. The same movie playing on repeat. We've said it before because it's true now as it was then:

Leadership isn't optional. It's everything. That's why Buck Showalter changed the Yankees. That's why Joe Torre changed the Yankees. That's why Joe Girardi squeezed everything he could out of his clubs.

Managers matter. The Yankees themselves proved that for decades. So why are we suddenly pretending they don't? And here's where things get really interesting.

Michael Kay made the comparison. But he stopped short of saying what naturally comes next.

Why? You can decide for yourself, but hey, I'll tell you my thoughts...

Kay works inside the Yankees' orbit. Whether consciously or unconsciously, there are realities that come with that position. He can push the envelope, but only so far. We're not in that position at BYB. We don't answer to Yankee executives. We don't answer to YES Network producers. We answer to our readers.

That freedom matters. It allows us to say the quiet part out loud. If this really is the Stump Merrill era all over again—and we believe it is—then the comparison isn't primarily about the players.

It's about the leadership. It's about the manager. It's about a culture that has grown comfortable with excuses instead of accountability.

Michael Kay deserves credit for finally saying "Stump Merrill." But finishing the thought?

That's a different story. We've been finishing that thought for years. And until someone is willing to admit that leadership is just as broken as the roster, don't expect anything to change. Because championship teams don't just have talent.

They have leaders and right now? They don't have one.  Just ask me... I'll be truthful with you.

WANT MORE ABOUT STUMP MERRILL? READ THIS:

DOMINGUEZ JUST PROVED TO EVERYONE THAT BOONE'S NOT QUALIFIED

BOONE'S LEGACY IS ONLY ABOUT WINNING REGULAR SEASON GAMES

There was a time when the Yankees measured success with parades. Not playoff appearances. Not Wild Card berths. Not division titles. Championships.

That was the standard George Steinbrenner built. If you didn't win the World Series, you answered for it. There was accountability. There was urgency. There was an understanding that wearing pinstripes came with expectations unlike any other organization in sports.

Fast forward to today, and the standard feels... different. Aaron Boone has been the Yankees' manager since 2018. During that span, the Yankees have won plenty of regular-season games. They've reached the postseason repeatedly. They've had MVP-caliber players, Cy Young-caliber pitchers, and one of the highest payrolls in baseball almost every single season.

And yet... Zero championships. That's not an attack.

That's a fact.

Every October seems to end the same way. The Yankees fall short, the front office talks about what they learned, Boone talks about how close they were, and everyone comes back the following spring saying this year will be different. Eventually, "close" stops meaning anything. Because in New York, banners—not participation trophies—define greatness.

To hear the Yankees' front office tell it, Aaron Boone is exactly the right man for the job. Listen to the organization's messaging, tune into YES broadcasts, scroll through team-controlled social media, and you'll find praise for Boone's calm demeanor, his communication skills, and the culture he has supposedly built.

That's all well and good. But fans see something much simpler. No rings. That's the résumé that matters. Fair or unfair, that's the scoreboard. Now let's talk about accountability.

One of the biggest criticisms Boone has faced over the years isn't simply his bullpen decisions or lineup construction. It's the perception that too many things happen under his watch without meaningful consequences. Take Jazz Chisholm Jr.

Jazz is an electric player. His swagger is part of what makes him special. Baseball needs personalities like his. But when he showed up at the plate with a lollipop in his mouth earlier this season, it became national news. Boone publicly admitted afterward that the stunt "pissed" him off because of the safety concerns. Jazz responded by saying Boone's message was essentially to keep having fun—but to be smarter about it.

That's probably the right response. But it also illustrates the larger conversation surrounding Boone.

Fans don't necessarily question whether Boone likes his players. We really don't care. We question whether he demands enough from them.

There have been too many mental mistakes. Too many sloppy innings. Too many baserunning blunders. Too many games where the Yankees look flat. Is every one of those Boone's fault?

Of course not. But when those issues become recurring themes year after year, eventually the manager has to own part of the culture. Then there's Brian Cashman. Cashman deserves enormous credit for being a part of building championship teams in the late 1990s and early 2000s. No one can erase that.

But it's also fair to ask whether this version of the Yankees has become too comfortable with falling short. The Yankees have invested hundreds of millions of dollars. They've retained stars. They've traded prospects. They've changed coaches. They've adjusted philosophies. Yet the one thing that hasn't changed is the leadership at the very top. At some point, every organization has to ask itself a difficult question:

If the results never change, why should the decision-makers? This isn't about calling Boone a terrible baseball mind. I mean, he pretty much is but this post is about something different. It's about not closing. BOONE CAN'T CLOSE.

Sometimes a clubhouse simply needs a different voice. Sometimes a franchise chasing greatness has to stop accepting "good enough." Because let's be honest.

When fans think about Joe Torre, they think about championships. When they think about Casey Stengel, they think about championships. When they think about Joe Girardi, they think about the 2009 championship

No one is going to think about Aaron Boone being a great manager. No one.  What will they remember?

A lot of regular-season wins.

The dynasty years weren't built because the Yankees were satisfied with being competitive. They were built because ownership demanded excellence and refused to confuse potential with accomplishment.

Can the Yankees get back to that level? Absolutely.

Aaron Judge is still one of the best players on the planet. Ben Rice has emerged as a legitimate star. The core has talent.

But talent alone doesn't build dynasties. Leadership does. Vision does. Accountability does.

So, here's the question every Yankees fan should be asking as another postseason approaches:

If this season ends the same way the others have, and I truly believe it will, is it finally time for Brian Cashman and Aaron Boone to step aside?

Or will the Yankees once again convince themselves that next year will be different? Because eventually, "next year" becomes "another year."

And that's not the Yankee Way.

BOONE'S BIGGEST FAILURE IS THE CULTURE HE CREATED

When the leader stops leading, is when the collapse happens. This is a historic fact.  I encourage you to read this. It will open your eyes allowing you to understand the hell us Yankee fans are in the middle of.

Winning organizations rarely implode because of one bad employee, one lazy player, or one unfortunate decision. They unravel when leadership stops leading. Whether it's a baseball clubhouse, a Fortune 500 company, a military unit, or the United States Congress, the pattern is remarkably similar. Standards begin to slip. Accountability disappears. Small problems become accepted behavior. Eventually, losing becomes the culture.

The old saying that "everything rises and falls on leadership" isn't just motivational fluff. History repeatedly demonstrates that organizations reflect the standards—or lack thereof—set by the person in charge.

This is a lesson worth reading.  Discipline and accountability is important. But it must come from the top. Every successful championship manager understands one fundamental truth: if the captain has to become the disciplinarian, Like Aaron Judge yesterday, the manager has already lost part of the clubhouse.

The manager, in this case Boone, needs to establish expectations. The players execute them. When those roles reverse, something has gone wrong.

One of the greatest examples came from Joe Torre with the Yankees dynasty. Torre wasn't known for screaming every day, but players understood where the line was. Veterans like Derek Jeter, Paul O'Neill, Jorge Posada and Bernie Williams never questioned who was running the clubhouse. Torre balanced personalities while holding everyone accountable. Players who didn't buy in didn't stay long.

Likewise, Bill Belichick built the New England Patriots on a brutally simple principle: "Do Your Job." It didn't matter if you were Tom Brady or the last player on the roster. Mental mistakes had consequences. Star status didn't exempt anyone from accountability.

Even fiery managers like Lou Piniella and Billy Martin understood that discipline wasn't optional. Their methods weren't always popular, but players never wondered who was in charge.

Contrast that with teams that spiral. Repeated defensive mistakes. Repeated mental errors. Repeated lack of hustle. Repeated public displays that would never be tolerated elsewhere. Those aren't isolated incidents. They're symptoms.

Believe me, don't believe me. Whatever. I'm right. Corporate history tells the exact same story. Look at Enron. Executives created a culture where ethical shortcuts became normalized. Financial manipulation went unchecked because leadership rewarded results instead of integrity. The company collapsed into one of America's largest corporate scandals, destroying thousands of jobs and billions in retirement savings.

Wells Fargo CEO John Stumpf and Community Bank head Carrie Tolstedt

Remember Wells Fargo? Employees opened millions of unauthorized customer accounts to satisfy unrealistic sales goals. Executives ignored warning signs for years because the numbers looked good. The eventual scandal cost billions in fines, permanently damaged the company's reputation, and forced leadership changes.

Boeing. Following the two 737 MAX crashes, multiple investigations concluded that cultural failures and weakened oversight contributed to catastrophic decisions. Engineers raised concerns. Communication broke down. Production pressure often outweighed safety priorities. The consequences were devastating.

Different industries. Same pattern. Leadership tolerated behaviors until they became disasters. Now think about Boone and the Yankees.  No true leadership, coddling, making excuses, and zero accountability. Wow.

Think about Government. Congress often becomes mired in dysfunction when leadership cannot enforce discipline within its own caucus. Party leaders rely on consensus, negotiation and political pressure to keep members aligned, but when factions ignore leadership or refuse compromise, legislation stalls, deadlines are missed, government shutdown threats emerge, and public confidence erodes.

Leadership in politics isn't simply about giving speeches, or in Boone's case, word salading press conferences. It's about maintaining order among dozens—or hundreds—of competing personalities.

When that disappears, so does effectiveness. the bottom line is history shows that leadership matters. Military history reinforces the lesson.

During the Battle of Gettysburg, Union leadership under George G. Meade maintained cohesion under immense pressure despite facing repeated Confederate assaults. Command discipline and coordinated execution helped preserve Union lines during one of the Civil War's decisive battles.

By contrast, historians frequently cite failures of coordination and command in numerous military defeats throughout history, where unclear authority, inconsistent discipline, or commanders ignoring warning signs contributed to disastrous outcomes.

Organizations succeed when leaders establish standards that everyone understands—and enforce. Am I being dramatic? Maybe. But it all goes back to leadership... something the Yankees are lacking with Aaron Boone in charge.

When Aaron Judge was forced to speak to players and address the team's lack of focus following another embarrassing stretch, it sounded like a captain trying to do the manager's job. in fact, he WAS doing Boone's job, because Boone doesn't command respect.  In short, he has no balls.

Now look, captains absolutely should lead. They should encourage teammates. They should set examples. They should speak after losses. But when the captain has to become the disciplinarian, one uncomfortable question naturally follows:

Where is the manager?

Aaron Boone has repeatedly defended poor performances, minimized prolonged slumps, and continued writing the same struggling names into the lineup.

Anthony Volpe entered this recent eight-game stretch hitting just .194 (6-for-31).

Austin Wells was even worse, batting approximately .077 between June 24 and July 2.

Yet both continued receiving opportunities while the offense spiraled. Slumps happen. Every player goes through them. Managers are judged by how they respond. Sometimes leadership means showing confidence. Sometimes leadership means making difficult decisions. Sometimes leadership means sending a message that performance still matters. he coddles Volpe and Wells. They should NOT see the lineup, they are automatic outs.

If poor performance never changes playing time, accountability becomes difficult to see. Then there are the optics.

Jazz Chisholm Jr. casually eating a lollipop while playing on the field may strike some fans as harmless personality, while others see it as poor timing during a stretch of embarrassing baseball. Regardless of where one falls on that debate, strong leadership often recognizes when a team's public image no longer matches its performance. Teams enduring prolonged losing streaks generally benefit from projecting urgency rather than comfort.

The Yankees have committed an alarming number of defensive mistakes, repeatedly looked fundamentally unsound, and suffered through extended stretches of lifeless offense. Eventually, fans like me stop asking what's wrong with the players. They start asking who's allowing it. That's Aaron Boone.

Look, leadership isn't about being nice. The best leaders aren't necessarily the loudest. They aren't always the smartest. They're the ones willing to make uncomfortable decisions. Bench a struggling veteran. Call out lazy effort. Demand fundamentals. Protect the culture before protecting feelings.

Every successful organization eventually reaches the same conclusion:

Culture doesn't maintain itself.

Standards don't enforce themselves.

Winning doesn't happen accidentally.

Leadership drives all three.

When players continually repeat the same mistakes, when accountability appears absent, when the captain feels compelled to deliver the message that usually comes from the manager, and when losing becomes expected instead of unacceptable, criticism naturally shifts away from the roster and toward the person responsible for leading it.

History has shown this in sports, business and government. Leadership either sets the standard—or allows the standard to disappear.

Hey Hal, are you paying attention? This manager is driving this team into the dirt. He's a loser.

BOONE PREDICTED TO BE TOAST BY SEPTEMBER

There’s nowhere left for Aaron Boone to hide. The fanbase has hit its boiling point, and the “Fire Boone” chants are only getting louder. Yes, the Yankees beat the Twins 6-2 last night, but let’s not act like that’s some heroic feat. The Yankees are supposed to beat teams like the Twins. The problem is they only show up against the mediocre clubs while folding against the real contenders. And the Blue Jays? Solid team. The Red Sox? Above them in the standings. That’s just embarrassing.

Boone isn’t taking at-bats or fielding grounders, but he’s also not leading, and that’s the real sin. Managers need to manage. That's why there are managers. And when it comes to Aaron Boone, I can guarantee you nobody is watching this team and thinking, “Yep, they’d run through a brick wall for Boone.” You saw that with the Core Four under Joe Torre though. The difference? Torre had accountability. Boone has excuses.

The Yankees are teetering on the edge of missing the playoffs—this after an offseason full of splashy moves, deadline blockbusters, and one of baseball’s highest payrolls. Yet somehow, we’ve got a manager who still thinks mixing and matching lineups like a blindfolded chef is the path to October. Joseph Kallan of FanSided recently put it bluntly: whether it’s Boone’s random lineups, head-scratching pitching calls, or his allergy to accountability, the fanbase has had enough.

Kallan even predicted Boone would be gone by September 1, with Brian Cashman finally “putting his foot down” to end the chaos. But let’s be real—there’s zero sign of that. Cashman loves having Boone as his yes-man, and the truth is the rot goes deeper. Cashman is part of the problem. So is the front office. And Hal Steinbrenner? Completely MIA while the ship is sinking.

Still, firing Boone is the logical first step—rip off the band-aid, then clean out the rest of the front office. The Yankees won’t truly thrive until Boone is gone, and deep down, Cashman knows it. The fans definitely know it—so much so that tonight in the Yankee Stadium bleachers (sections 202–204) is “Fire Boone Night.” That’s where we are now.

Even Jorge Posada chimed in this week, saying the team’s struggles come down to mentality. “They just gotta get a little angry… have that chip on their shoulder. You can’t be friends with everybody.” That’s not just a comment—it’s a jab at Boone, the King of Coddling. This is the guy who will defend Anthony Volpe or Austin Wells no matter how poorly they’re playing, all in the name of “confidence.”

Posada’s right. Baseball isn’t therapy. It’s about putting the best nine guys on the field and expecting them to perform. Boone doesn’t lead. Boone enables. And for four years, I’ve been saying the same thing at Bleeding Yankee Blue: Boone needs to go. It’s past time. And here’s hoping Kallan’s prediction finally comes true.

YANKEES CHANCES ARE SLIPPING AWAY

The Yankees remain a roster loaded with talent but handicapped by one glaring weakness — the guy running the dugout. Aaron Boone is less a strategic mastermind and more a self-inflicted obstacle course the team trips over nightly.

Jon Heyman just poured a little salt in the wound, pointing out that the Yankees — with their $300 million payroll — are clinging to a measly half-game lead over the Guardians. Yes, the Guardians: a team with a third of New York’s payroll. If that’s not embarrassing enough, the Yankees’ recent skid has left them 62-55, six and a half games back in the AL East, and losers in six of their last seven. A 5-4 win yesterday barely counts as life support.

Look at Boone's career as manager. He doesn't win. 

And Brian Cashman this year? He basically left the trade deadline with a gift bag containing nothing but pocket lint and excuses.

Even Joe Torre — the man who delivered four World Series titles to the Bronx — is tiptoeing around the truth. Torre said, “I feel for Aaron Boone. I’ve been in that place where you’re trying to rearrange the furniture and hopefully it makes a difference… This club’s too good not to have a run, and there’s still time left.”

Translation: Boone’s not the guy, but Torre’s too classy to say it. Fans aren’t. We’ve seen Boone’s “track record” — overmanaging, ignoring instincts, and somehow choosing the one option that tanks the game. Remember the Nestor Cortes–Freeman debacle? Or bringing in Devin Williams the other night? It’s a constant uphill battle for the players just to overcome his blunders.

This isn’t chemistry, it’s chaos. Not leadership, but manager-loserville.

Sure, the Yankees might stumble into a Wild Card spot. But with Boone steering, it’ll end in the same sad way: an early exit and another round of excuses. The talent is here. The wins could be here. The problem is also here — in the dugout — and until Boone is gone, this team’s ceiling is hitting their heads on it.

Bottom line: fire him.

THERE ARE MUCH BETTER IN THE BUSINESS, ALEX CORA

I still can’t get over how absurd Alex Cora sounded when he suggested that Aaron Boone is "the best in the business." The best in the business? Are you kidding me? That has to be the dumbest thing I’ve ever heard. That’s why I titled this article DUMB AND STUPID. Because that’s exactly what this statement is. If Boone is the best, then what does that make Bruce Bochy? Or Joe Torre? Prophets? Baseball gods? Maybe we should just start building shrines to them because, compared to Boone, they’re untouchable legends.

It’s as if Cora just pulled this shit out of thin air to make his buddy look good. But let’s be real—Boone sucks. He always has. And Cora, by making such a laughable statement, just proved he has no integrity. He’s out here playing PR manager instead of speaking facts, and I’m not buying it.

There was an interesting sentence, a take from ClutchPoints that bothered me when writing about Cora and Boone. They wrote, and I quote, "A lack of talent cannot fairly fall on the manager, but it often does." I mean, what? The Yankees have had plenty of talent for years. The problem isn’t a shortage of skilled players—it’s a manager who has no goddamn clue how to use them effectively.

I’ve been saying it for years—the Yankees weren’t going to win the World Series under Boone, and guess what? I am right so far. Sure, they made it further than I predicted last year, but that wasn’t because of Boone’s genius managerial skills. That was because of talent. The same talent that Boone consistently fails to utilize properly. When things get tough, when a manager has to make the hard calls like Boone, that’s when you separate the truly elite from the frauds and that's where Boone does not rise. That’s when the so-called "best in the business" proves their worth. And Boone? He fucking folds, literally every time.

If Boone were anything close to elite, he’d be able to maximize his team’s potential. He’d recognize strengths, adjust for weaknesses, and make the tough, smart decisions that lead to winning. But isn't managing, the front office is. Boone doesn’t have the guts, the intelligence, or the leadership ability to do it. Girardi did. Girardi won. Girardi wasn't asked back because Girardi had balls!  And so back to Boone... that’s why, after all these years, he still hasn’t won a single goddamn championship.

Look at the history of baseball—managers get fired for far less. Some are let go after missing the playoffs. Some lose their jobs after a 10-game losing streak. The reason? Because they fail to manage, lead, motivate, and problem-solve. Yet somehow, Boone continues to skate by doing the bare minimum. The Yankees have embraced mediocrity, and it’s embarrassing.

And let’s talk about that mediocrity for a second. It’s not just Boone—it’s the entire Yankees front office. This team used to have a standard. A fire. A demand for excellence. But now? Now it’s all about participation trophies and "we’ll get ‘em next year." This isn’t Little League. This is the New York Yankees, the team that built a dynasty on winning. And here we are, stuck with a manager who embodies the very definition of "just enough."

Alex Cora’s statement was complete nonsense. That's why everyone is writing about it today. But we here at Bleeding Yankee Blue are going to be the only Yankee fan site to be honest about it. It's stupid. And ClutchPoints wrote in their piece was wrong, love you guys, but it's not accurate. Talent matters, but what a manager does with that talent matters even more. If this were the 1980s, Boone would have been fired a long time ago. If George Steinbrenner were still around, Billy Martin would be back in the dugout replacing Boone because, say what you will about Billy, he knew how to lead. He wasn’t a puppet. Boone? He’s nothing but that. A puppet controlled by an organization that has lost its way.

So, before we start throwing around empty praise, let’s remember what baseball is really about. It’s not just about trying—it’s about winning. And as Derek Jeter once said if a team doesn’t win the championship, the entire season is a failure. 

Well, Yankees fans, we’ve had plenty of failures. And it all comes down to one thing—we have a failed leader as our manager. F Cora. F Boone.

THAT TIME WADE BOGGS PITCHED

Yes, you heard that right.

Wade Boggs is a baseball legend—one of the best hitters to ever step up to the plate. The man was an absolute machine with a bat in his hands, racking up hit after hit for years in the major leagues. And, of course, his dominance landed him in the National Baseball Hall of Fame in 2005 on his very first ballot. But while everyone knows Boggs could hit, did you know he also had a secret weapon? A knuckleball.

For years, Boggs dreamed of taking the mound in a real MLB game, reports are he was always bugging his managers to let him pitch and even showing off his surprisingly wicked knuckleball in warmups. But, of course, when you're one of the greatest players in the game, teams tend to prefer keeping you in your usual spot. That all changed on August 19, 1997.

The Yankees were getting walloped by the Angels, trailing 12-4 in the eighth inning. With a doubleheader coming up the next day and the bullpen running on fumes, manager Joe Torre knew he needed a position player to finish things off. His first thought was Charlie Hayes, but the Yankees players had a different idea—they wanted to see Boggs' infamous knuckleball in action. Torre hesitated. This was Wade Boggs, a future Hall of Famer, a hitting savant—was it really right to send him to the mound in an eight-run blowout?

The answer? Yes please.

Boggs finally got his shot, stepping onto the mound with the confidence of a seasoned pitcher. And guess what? He absolutely delivered. He pitched a scoreless eighth inning, allowing no hits, walking just one batter, and even striking out Todd Greene swinging to end the frame. That knuckleball? It danced. The ballpark may not have been packed with tension, but for Boggs, it was a moment of pure baseball magic.

And that wasn’t the last time Boggs took the hill. Two years later, in 1999, now playing for the Tampa Bay Devil Rays, he got another chance to pitch when his team was on the wrong side of a 17-1 rout against the Orioles. Tampa Bay manager Larry Rothschild didn't think twice. "There wasn't much of a choice. It was going to be a position player, and Wade had done it before. He throws a knuckleball, so I don't worry as much about him hurting his arm."

After his pitching debut in 1997, Boggs had said: "It's something I've always wanted to do in my career, and I never really had the opportunity. Then I started feeling like Phil Niekro. I was Phil Niekro and Charlie Hough all rolled into one. It was great. I was glad it worked out."

Wade Boggs wasn’t just a Hall of Fame hitter; he was a guy who loved baseball with every fiber of his being. 

Whether he was lining doubles into the gap or floating knuckleballs past unsuspecting hitters, he made the game fun. And let’s be honest—how many Hall of Fame hitters can also say they’ve struck out a batter in a major league game? 

Just another reason Wade Boggs is one of the all-time greats.

--Alvin Izzo
BYB Yankee History Contributor

COMPLACENCY & MEDIOCRITY WIN THE DAY WITH STOOGE BOONE'S EXTENSION!

We as the Yankees are no longer are the team of grit, passion and championships.  We the fans are just feeding the Yankee piggy bank because of successes of years past.

These days Hal Steinbrenner has become complacent, plain and simple. The Yankees are no longer a team obsessed with winning championships—they're a brand, a massive, money-printing empire where the past is more valuable than the present. The merchandise flies off the shelves, the memorabilia from the glory years keeps the cash registers ringing, and as long as the Yankees logo is still a global icon, actually winning? Well, that’s just a bonus, not a priority. That’s why Aaron Boone—the puppet, the king of empty October appearances—has been handed a contract extension through 2027.

Oh, you didn’t hear? The Yankees just announced this morning that they’re extending Boone for two more years beyond his current deal, which was set to expire after 2025. Why? Because mediocrity is now acceptable in the Bronx. Yes, Boone has a winning record, but since when did that make someone a great manager? MLB Trade Rumors tried to defend him, stating:

"Boone is a divisive figure in the fanbase but there’s a lot of good stuff on his track record. The Yanks have made the postseason in six of his seven seasons at the helm, with the aforementioned 2023 campaign being the lone exception. They have had some tough postseason losses but, as mentioned, just went to the World Series a few months ago. As skipper, he has a regular season record of 603-429, a .584 winning percentage."

Okay, and? So, Boone padding managerial wins is important? WTF. We've all gone soft.

Getting to the postseason and failing isn't an achievement—it’s just prolonging the inevitable. So Boone is what, the best loser in the league? Give me a break. The Yankees lost the World Series last year. Before that, they missed the playoffs entirely in 2023—the worst season in three decades. They’ve been second place in the AL East more often than not under Boone and have exactly one World Series appearance in his tenure.

But sure, "the manager isn’t responsible for that," right? Tell that to Billy Martin. Tell that to every manager who’s ever been fired after a bad season. The reality is Boone isn’t qualified, he isn’t good under pressure, and when the moment is biggest, he panics. Just ask Nestor Cortes and Freddie Freeman—Boone made one of the worst managerial decisions in World Series history, and it cost the Yankees everything in a must-win game.

Let’s be real: Boone is still here because Steinbrenner doesn’t care about winning, and Brian Cashman keeps feeding him nonsense. Cashman even had the nerve to say this, per MLB.com’s Bryan Hoch:

“I think that is a strength, that is a benefit. I know that if he wasn’t the Yankee manager, it would be a feeding frenzy for him to be a manager that’s coveted elsewhere, objectively. That’s how we see it.”

So, let me get this straight: the Yankees kept Boone not because he was the best option, but because they didn’t want another team to have him? That’s the logic now? That’s the standard in the Bronx? What an absolutely ridiculous take.

And let’s not forget the Yankees marketing machine still playing that 2003 Boone walk-off against Boston like it’s some iconic championship moment. Do they forget what happened after? The Yankees lost the World Series. That homer meant nothing. Just like Boone’s entire tenure.

Great managers are carried off the field. Why? Cause a good manager will LEAD YOU TO A WORLD CHAMPIONSHIP.  That has never happened to Aaron Boone and with the amount of talent around him... it should have happened at least twice by now. But the reason is simple... Boone is not a great manager.

This extension is a joke. I will apologize if—and only if—the Yankees win the World Series under Boone. But let’s be real: they won’t. Because Aaron Boone doesn’t have what it takes. Joe Torre won four rings and was let go. Joe Girardi won a championship and was cut loose. But Boone? Still here, with zero titles to his name. Why? Because Hal Steinbrenner doesn’t care about championships. The money is still rolling in, even if the Yankees keep coming up short.

Pathetic.

HAL CAN'T BE SERIOUS ABOUT EXTENDING "NO CHAMPIONSHIPS" BOONE...

The mere fact that a contract extension for Aaron Boone is even on the table is an absolute disgrace. The New York Yankees, once the gold standard of winning, are now being reduced to a joke under the feckless leadership of Hal Steinbrenner and his incompetent front office.

Boone has won nothing. Not a single meaningful accomplishment to his name. Oh wait, he hit a home run against the Red Sox in the ALCS over 20 years ago... then busted his ankle the next season. But here we are, watching Hal Steinbrenner seriously consider extending his tenure as if failure is now the standard. Boone has had teams capable of competing for championships, but his tenure has been marred by playoff collapses, baffling in-game decisions, and a complete inability to inspire urgency or accountability. And yet, instead of cutting ties with this loser, the Yankees’ leadership is thinking about rewarding him. It’s beyond absurd.

Steinbrenner recently admitted that the Yankees will be speaking with Boone "in the days and weeks to come" regarding a contract extension. This would be his second extension despite his repeated failures in October. The fact that Boone has lasted this long is already an indictment of the Yankees’ current state. Extending him further? That would be sheer incompetence at its peak.

Boone initially signed a three-year deal in 2018, followed by another three-year extension in 2021, which included an option for 2025. Why? Because under Hal Steinbrenner’s soft and clueless leadership, the Yankees value familiarity over results. Brian Cashman has openly stated that the team envisioned Boone being a decade-long manager. For what reason? Joe Torre got 12 years and won four championships. Joe Girardi got 10 years and delivered a title while enduring the toughest post-dynasty era. And yet Boone, who has consistently failed when it matters most, is somehow being given the same treatment as if he’s earned anything.

Let’s be honest: Joe Girardi was fired because he wasn’t a pushover. He challenged the front office, held players accountable, and demanded excellence. That was the kind of manager George Steinbrenner would have respected. But Hal Steinbrenner, in his infinite mediocrity, would rather enable Boone—a man who makes terrible in-game decisions, refuses to hold his team accountable, and believes brushing off failure with empty platitudes is acceptable.

The Yankees used to be synonymous with excellence. Now, under Hal, they are just another team content with regular-season wins and postseason embarrassments. Boone was never the right guy for the job, and he never will be. But Hal Steinbrenner, the most inept and spineless owner in Yankees history, seems dead set on doubling down on failure.

Us Yankee fans deserve better. They deserve a front office that prioritizes championships, not one that continues to enable mediocrity. If Boone gets extended, it will be the final confirmation that winning is no longer the Yankees’ priority—because under Hal, it’s clear that failure is perfectly acceptable.

Yuk.

DAVID WELLS: THE ULTIMATE BAD BOY & THE LEGENDARY RISK

Over two decades ago, one of baseball's ultimate bad boys, David Wells, pulled off a stunt so rebellious and gutsy that it's become the stuff of legend. Wells, known for his fearless demeanor on and off the mound, decided to honor baseball's greatest icon, Babe Ruth, in a way only a true maverick could. He donned an original Babe Ruth cap during a game, breaking MLB's strict uniform rules and earning himself a spot in the annals of baseball folklore.

Let’s set the scene: It’s the 1990s, and David Wells, the big lefty with a reputation for being as tough as they come, walks into the ballpark with a secret weapon. He had shelled out a cool $35,000 for an authentic Babe Ruth cap, the same one the "Sultan of Swat" wore in a real Major League game. To Wells, this cap wasn’t just a piece of memorabilia—it was a living, breathing piece of Yankees history, something that demanded to be celebrated, not hidden away in a collector’s vault.

When Wells decided, “I’m gonna wear this s*cker,” you better believe he meant it. Joe Torre, the Yankees' legendary manager, got wind of the plan and immediately tried to put a stop to it. Torre, ever the professional, knew the rules and tried to steer Wells away from what he saw as a foolhardy move. But let’s face it, Wells wasn’t about to let some technicalities get in the way of making history.

During practice, Torre kept a hawk’s eye on Wells, ensuring the cap stayed off. But when the game was about to start, according to reports, Wells pulled a fast one. He slipped into the locker room, slapped on the Babe’s cap, and ran out onto the field like the rebel he was. The music blasted, the fans roared, and there was Wells, standing on the mound with the Babe’s cap firmly on his head.

Sure, Torre saw the cap and demanded it come off, but Wells, already on the mound, was in his element. He pitched with that cap, knowing full well that a fine was coming his way. And come it did—$2,500, a slap on the wrist for such a priceless moment.

Years later, Wells auctioned off the cap for a staggering half a million dollars. As fans, we can’t help but wish he never let it go, but the story? The story lives on, immortalized in the hearts of baseball lovers everywhere. It’s one of those epic tales that makes you appreciate the audacity of guys like Wells, who dare to break the mold for the love of the game.

So, hats off to David Wells—the tough guy, the bad boy, the legend who turned a simple cap into an unforgettable chapter in baseball history.

--Alvin Izzo
BYB Yankee History Contributor

LET'S NOT FORGET TONY FERNANDEZ & HIS TIME IN THE BRONX

Tony Fernández was more than just a baseball player; he was an artist on the field, a magician with the glove, and a professional to his core. His career spanned nearly two decades, and while he’ll always be most closely tied to the Toronto Blue Jays, his time in pinstripes proved that greatness has no home—it travels wherever the player goes.

It’s hard not to marvel at Fernández’s early career. With the Blue Jays, he was unstoppable, setting records, winning Gold Gloves, and dazzling fans with his smooth, almost effortless style of play. His bat was no slouch, either—hitting over .300 four times and leading the league with 17 triples in 1990. When the Jays traded him to the Padres in 1991, it felt like the end of an era. But for Fernández, it was just another chapter in a story that was far from finished.

He bounced around a bit after that, playing for the Padres and Mets before a trade brought him back to Toronto in 1993. It was a homecoming, and Fernández didn’t disappoint. He was instrumental in helping the Blue Jays clinch their second World Series, driving in nine runs in the Fall Classic—a record for shortstops. But after another stint with the Blue Jays and a solid year with the Reds, it was time for something new. 

In 1995, Fernández signed with the New York Yankees, and his journey took a turn into pinstripe history.

Joining the Yankees in the mid-90s meant stepping into a team on the verge of something special. Fernández, already a veteran, brought stability and leadership to the shortstop position. And while Derek Jeter was looming in the minors, the Yankees weren’t about to hand the job to a kid fresh out of AAA. Fernández was exactly what they needed—proven, reliable, and still capable of magic.

One of those magical moments came on September 3, 1995, in the Bronx. Fernández put on a show, going 4-for-5 against the Oakland A’s and hitting for the cycle.

 

It was the kind of performance that reminded everyone why Tony Fernández was a star. Only 10 players in Yankees history had done it before him, and his cycle felt like a moment of triumph in a season full of ups and downs.

Unfortunately, Fernández’s Yankees story is also intertwined with one of baseball’s most famous transitions. In spring training of 1996, Fernández suffered an elbow injury, sidelining him for the season. It was a tough break for a player who still had plenty to give, but it also paved the way for Derek Jeter to take the stage. While some players might have harbored bitterness, that wasn’t Fernández’s style. He handled the situation with the same grace and professionalism that defined his entire career.

When Fernández left the Yankees, he didn’t just walk away from a team—he left behind a legacy. He became the last player to wear the iconic No. 6 before Joe Torre donned it as manager and eventually had it retired. Even in a relatively short stint, Fernández had etched his name into Yankees lore.

The rest of his career saw him continue to play for several teams, always bringing his signature style and determination to the game. Age eventually caught up with him, as it does with all players, but Fernández never stopped being a gamer. He battled through life off the field as well, facing a diagnosis of polycystic kidney disease in 2017 with the same quiet resilience he showed in his playing days.

When Fernández passed away in 2020, it was a heartbreaking moment for baseball fans everywhere. He was more than just a player; he was a man who carried himself with dignity, a teammate who lifted those around him, and an athlete who left everything he had on the field.

Yes, he’ll always be a Blue Jays legend, but for a time, Tony Fernández was a Yankee. And in that time, he showed why he was one of the best to ever play the game. The Bronx got a glimpse of his brilliance, and it’s something Yankees fans won’t forget. He wasn’t just the guy who came before Derek Jeter. He was Tony Fernández—a player who made his mark wherever he went.

--Alvin Izzo

BYB Yankee History Contributor

FORGET IT. THE YANKEES WEREN'T SUPPOSED TO BE IN THE FALL CLASSIC ANYWAY

Last night I cannot blame on Aaron Boone. Crazy right?

But as a whole, in the bonehead moves he has made, in our 4th place finish last year... in the way he over tinkers, befriends his players, argues balls and strikes in meaningless games, and just plain sucks as a manager because of his inexperience, and now because we have gotten to the World Series and lost it, it only makes sense that we say goodbye to this guy and turn the page on making the Yankee organization leadership brighter and better moving forward. This HAS to be the end of the Boone Era. The experiment didn't work... not even alittle bit! Hal, are you listening?

Look, the Yankees were never supposed to be in the World Series this year.  Let's not fool ourselves. The Yankees have been so inconsistent all season, so the idea of making it to the World Series was a gift.  Did I hope they won this year? Of course, but do I think they actually are the best team in baseball, nope.  I'm a realist, this Yankee team is deeply flawed.

The Yankees made a few minor offseason tweaks even though we all knew they needed better pitching and that was the priority.  We got Juan Soto instead. Now, don't get me wrong, Juan Soto was fantastic, I loved seeing him in pinstripes, but as I said then, we got this guy for one year, what happens if we DON'T win it all?  And here we are... we didn't win it all.  And so, what happens next?

For one, Juan Soto will be a free agent.  That's big.  Seems like we had one opportunity, and it was just now, and yet, we didn't win. And so, if he leaves, do you really think we have what it takes to try and win again? We were lucky to get to the World Series this year WITH Juan Soto. If Juan Soto leaves, you can forget our chances. And that is where you really need to go after our Yankees front office and lightweight manager Aaron Boone.

Leadership in any business is vital, and this guy just doesn't have what it takes to lead this Yankees team.  

It's been a long time since Boone has been in the driver's seat. Here's the problem; he doesn't know how to drive stick.  This isn't a team you just hand over to a JV coach and say, "Here, try and tinker with this." These are the New York Yankees. They are celebrities, personalities and they are wearing the pinstripes and so the stakes are much higher.  While many people didn't like Joe Torre taking over after Buck Showalter in the 90's, the one thing Joe Torre had was experience. He was a long-time player and a manager, and while not a successful manager, he understood the game and surrounded himself with wisdom. In other words, he had a plan.  

I see Aaron Boone as a guy who wants to hang out with the celebrity Yankees, have barbeques, a few drinks, play a pickup basketball game with Cortes and Judge, and just enjoy life as a millionaire. The problem? He's not actually doing his job.  Being in the friend zone with Gerrit Cole doesn't win you a championship.  He doesn't understand the stakes, He doesn't understand much of anything.  

And I'll take it further. Better, smarter and more experienced managers in baseball have been fired for way less than what Boone's mistakes have led this Yankee team over the years.  Buck Showalter is probably one of the most respected baseball minds in the game and the Mets lost a few years ago, and they cut him loose right away.  Billy Martin was back and forth with George Steinbrenner for years, but when he couldn't win, he'd be fired. It was pretty simple.  

The White Sox fired La Russa after the club got off to a 26–38 start in 1986, yet LaRussa is one of only two managers in MLB history to win World Series championships in both the American and National leagues.  What's my point? My point is Boone should have been fired years ago. He's terrible.

Now last night's game you cannot blame on Aaron Boone. The 5th inning for the Yankees was the strangest thing I've ever seen.  You always hear that errors will cost you ballgames, and last night it was evident. It was big. It was horrible.  The Yankee club should be embarrassed. But let me be clear, errors are part of the game, and while no one wants to see the Yankees fold like they did, the bigger issue is our leadership.

Hal Steinbrenner either doesn't have his finger on the pulse or Brian Cashman has fooled him enough to handle this team and tricked big Hal into believing that "close enough" with Aaron Boone is "good enough" and the bottom line is as fans, we are very in tune with what's going on, but as fans we also love to watch our team win it all.  Us fans spend the money, and we root hard only to be heartbroken and then we do it all over again the next year with our shitty manager and a wish and a prayer that we can retain Juan Soto long term.  

None of it makes sense, yet we do it anyway. It's a trap. It's an abusive relationship and we're the ones getting mind fucked every season. And so, my biggest gripe with this team is simple; the management is stale, the hunger only comes when we hit home runs, and the idea of manufacturing runs is a very small part of the Yankees game and that my friends has been going on since the days of Jason Giambi.  We will never break the mold if the manager gives Hal what he "thinks" he wants.  Boone does not think for himself. Boone panders. Boone does what he's told. In essence, Boone isn't running this team as a true manager would.  

I will give Joe Girardi credit for one thing; he was tough as nails when it came to managing this club. He wasn't the best at it, but he also didn't bend over and tried his best to manage the team his way.  Many times, it didn't work, but one time it did and 2009 was glorious.

But 2009 was a long time ago and everyone knows that Aaron Boone's not winning us a championship.  I mean, that lineup never changed in this World Series and there were major problems with our hitting.  I am still baffled by the fact that Boone started Jose Trevino because Austin Wells was slumping just to then pinch-hit Wells for Trevino later in that game anyway.  That's a manager that doesn't trust himself and it's embarrassing.

And so now the season is over.  Last night will I PRAY brings real changes to the New York Yankees manager and coaching staff.  Seeing the Dodgers celebrate at Yankee Stadium was sad, but this is the game.  Someone had to lose and why not us... we don't have leadership anyway.

Finally, I'll leave you with this; Frank Sinatra's "New York, New York" is a staple for the Yankees when we win at the Stadium.  Last night the Yankees played that song while the Dodgers were celebrating.  While this was a total mind fuck for many of your fans, I clearly understood why they did it.  There are 2 reasons actually and while it's my opinion, I know I'm right. 

For one, it was a Thank you. It was a Thank you to the Yankees for the fight. It was a Thank You to us fans for sticking around and believing in the pinstripes. It was a "so long" as we head into the winter, not a "Goodbye".  Maybe it's my maturity, maybe I just understand symbolism, but for the love of God for silly fans and this Jomboy hack to make it appear that the Yankees "messed up" for playing that song are just ridiculous.

idc what it costs, Juan Soto needs to be a Yankee for life

You can't let this generational talent and attitude walk out the front doorpic.twitter.com/yd7a7eh1sr

— Mike Salvatore (@MikeSalvatore10) October 31, 2024

I have been a fan of this team since the old Yankee stadium, 1981, Yankees vs. Dodgers Game 1 of the World Series.  Even before that in '78 when I saw Ron Guidry strike out 18 Angels, but definitely in that World Series. The fans were loud, it just made sense to me that the Yankees were my team. And so, yes, I understand symbolism. I understand appreciation. The Yankees organization as a whole may not appear to be about the fans, but even they understood the gut punch last night.  It was a peace offering, a "we're sorry, but thank you". It was supposed to make you feel good about our team. And Secondly, they probably snuck this in too; While Sinatra was a Hoboken kid, he was a Dodgers fan. 

I know, I know, your brain just exploded. Well calm down, it's not that deep. It's symbolism and a gesture all the same. You may not have gotten it, but it was actually nice and guys like Jomboy make it about them and it's not. 

And so now we crawl into our caves and wait.  Hopefully Boone gets canned, it just makes sense at this point.  Hopefully the Yankees can figure out a way to retain Juan Soto while getting another top starting pitcher.  Hopefully we will see the fall classic next year and we win with a new manager and new hunger and an Aaron Judge who just tees off every at bat.

To our Bleeding Yankee Blue audience.  You are loyal, you are wonderful, and we thank you for your support and love. Many of you have been reading BYB since we started in September 2010. That is a long time, and we love you very much.  To the newbies, yeah, we complain about our Yankees a lot here, but we also celebrate them. Thank you for finding us and we hope you enjoy the ride.

Congrats to the Yankees for making it this far. You weren't supposed to be here, but you did prove many of us wrong and I respect the hell out of that.  I always will.

Go Yanks.

See you all in the offseason. We will not stop writing and will bring you as much news, info and humor as we can.  Thanks for reading Bleeding Yankee Blue.

-- Robert Casey
Chief & Head writer of Bleeding Yankee Blue
Twitter: @BleednYankeeBlu