STANTON LIVES!

Everyone's waiting for Aaron Judge to return, but apparently Giancarlo Stanton isn't completely dead for 2026 either. Wild.

Aaron Boone says Stanton is hitting and gave us the always-informative “we’ll see.”

Thanks, Aaron. Pulitzer stuff.

Look, Stanton hasn't played since April 24 because his calf apparently has the structural integrity of wet toilet paper. At 36, expecting him to suddenly become Cal Ripken Jr. is ridiculous.

But here's the funny part: I still want him.

Because if October comes and I need one gigantic human being to walk to the plate and scare the absolute hell out of a pitcher, give me Big G.

Judge and Stanton back for October?

I'll believe it when I see it.

But I'm certainly not deleting Stanton's number yet. Interesting.

GIANCARLO STANTON SHOULD RETIRE. THERE, I SAID IT.

I hate writing this because I actually like Giancarlo Stanton.

The guy has never bothered me. He works. He doesn't make excuses. He has delivered some monster moments for the Yankees, especially when the lights get brighter. And when he gets a hold of one, it's still one of the greatest sights in baseball.

But enough. Giancarlo Stanton should retire.

Not because he's a bad player. Not because he's a bad teammate. And certainly not because I'm blaming the guy for getting hurt. I'm saying it because at some point your body gets a vote.

And Stanton's body has been voting NO for years. Since coming to the Yankees, we've seen injuries involving his biceps, shoulder, knee, quad, ankle, Achilles, hamstrings, elbows and enough calf problems to make you wonder if the Yankees should just bubble-wrap him between at-bats.

That's not being cruel. That's the history. In 2019, Stanton played just 18 regular-season games. Then came more calf trouble in 2020, along with a hamstring strain. The quad followed in 2021. Ankle and Achilles issues arrived in 2022. Another significant hamstring injury cost him nearly two months in 2023. Another hamstring strain cost him 28 games in 2024.

Last year? Both elbows. Stanton missed the first 70 games of 2025 dealing with tendon problems. And somehow, 2026 has topped all of it. Stanton hurt his right calf in April. He spent nearly four months trying to get back. He had already suffered a setback with that calf earlier in the process.

Then, finally, he reached what was essentially the last major hurdle before beginning a rehab assignment: running the bases.

And he fell. And strained the other calf. You can't make this stuff up. The Yankees announced yesterday that Stanton suffered a moderate strain of his left calf while working his way back from the right calf injury. Aaron Boone acknowledged that, this late in the calendar, getting Stanton back this season has become extremely challenging.

He has played 24 games this season. Twenty-four. That's where my opinion changed. This isn't about waiting for Stanton to get healthy anymore. We've been waiting for Stanton to get healthy for most of his Yankee career. It's about reliability.

The Yankees are supposed to be building a championship roster, and you simply cannot construct that roster while repeatedly reserving an important spot for a player you have absolutely no idea will be available.

That's not roster construction. That's roulette. And before somebody tells me Stanton can still hit — I know. That's what makes this sad. There is still serious power in that bat. There are still moments when Stanton looks like the most terrifying guy walking toward the batter's box. This isn't Willie Mays stumbling around with the Mets. Stanton can still punish a baseball.

The problem is getting him into the batter's box in the first place. He's 36 years old. He's under contract through 2027. And after this latest setback, the Yankees are once again discussing whether he'll even make it back onto a baseball field this season.

How many more times are we going to do this? Injury. IL. Rehab. Running. Setback. Aaron Boone update. More rehab. Hope. Another body part.

Stanton has had a hell of a career. MVP. Five-time All-Star. One of the premier power hitters of his generation. He has carried himself professionally in New York and given Yankee fans some unforgettable postseason moments.

That's how I'd rather remember him. Not as a 37-year-old trying to coax one more season out of legs that have been screaming at him for years. There is dignity in knowing when it's time. And for Giancarlo Stanton, I think we've reached it.

Retire, Big G. It's the right move as much as I don't want to see it happen. Retire.

Not because you can't hit anymore. Because the Yankees and us fans can't keep waiting to find out whether you'll be healthy enough to try.

WHAT THE HELL HAPPENED TO GIANCARLO STANTON?

At some point, somebody needs to explain what the hell happened to Giancarlo Stanton.

Stanton has been out since April 24 with a right calf strain. Then he suffered another setback in that same calf in June. Now, while finally working his way toward a return, Stanton fell while running the bases and strained his left calf. Aaron Boone called it a moderate strain, and with the calendar sitting in late August, his season is suddenly in serious jeopardy.

Unbelievable.

And yes, Stanton has an extensive injury history. Nobody is pretending otherwise. But I have questions for the Yankees, too.

What exactly is happening with this organization's training, rehabilitation and recovery operation?

This isn't some guy who rushed back after two weeks. Stanton has spent nearly four months rehabbing. The entire purpose of that process is to carefully rebuild the body so the player can eventually handle baseball activities again. Yet here we are: Stanton was rehabbing one calf and somehow injured the other one running the bases.

How?

Maybe this is simply terrible luck. Maybe Stanton's 36-year-old body just isn't cooperating anymore. But the Yankees have had enough injury and rehabilitation headaches over the years that their process deserves scrutiny.

Because Stanton played just 24 games this season, and now there's a legitimate possibility we won't see him again in 2026.

That's not just disappointing. It's ridiculous.

Somebody inside that organization needs to start asking harder questions about why getting important players healthy — and keeping them healthy — continues to feel like such an adventure.

FRIED AGAIN? YANKS CAN’T KEEP ANYBODY HEALTHY

Just when you thought the Yankees were finally getting their rotation together, Max Fried is back on the injured list. Again.

Fried was placed on the 15-day IL just a short time ago with a left elbow bone bruise — the same injury that cost him nearly two months earlier this season. Seriously, why the hell can’t the Yankees stay healthy?

We literally just got finished talking about how exciting it would be to finally see Gerrit Cole, Max Fried and Carlos Rodón healthy and pitching in the same rotation. That's the kind of three-headed monster that can carry you through October.

And right on cue, Rodón is ready to return Tuesday after dealing with his own elbow inflammation and Fried goes down. You can't make this stuff up.

At some point, I think it's fair to start asking questions beyond simple bad luck. Should the Yankees be taking a serious look at their medical staff, training staff, strength and conditioning programs and the way they manage player health?

I'm not accusing anyone of causing injuries. Pitchers get hurt. That's baseball. But when you're constantly waiting for Judge, Stanton, Bellinger, Rodón, Fried and others to get healthy, eventually somebody needs to examine the bigger picture. The Yankees' current injury list includes several major pieces, and Fried's latest setback only adds to it.

Because this is getting ridiculous.

The Yankees have spent a fortune assembling a championship-caliber roster. It would be nice if we could actually see the damn roster on the field at the same time.

IT'S NOT OFTEN THAT I AGREE WITH AROD, BUT IT JUST HAPPENED!

Ten years ago yesterday, August 12th, 2016, Alex Rodriguez played in his last game as a Yankee against the Rays. Oh how I look at that and think about the irony. Now he just sits back and talks about them and the strategy the Yankees should've taken to chase down the Rays in the AL East.

It's funny because he's been doing a lot of talking lately. I don't always agree with him. His idea that the Dodgers are good for baseball this week is one I don't agree with. However, the idea that the Yankees should've gone "all in" at the trade deadline I do agree with. If you missed it, check it out HERE. 

"The issue that you have with the Yankees, it's a tale of two stories," Rodriguez said. "They have the best pitching in baseball. They've collected some of the best pitchers, and by the way they haven't even been healthy all year but this is a championship-caliber pitching staff. I would've loved to see an extra arm or two because the by-product of not having a good offense, especially without Aaron Judge, they're pretty much 30th in every offensive category. What's gonna happen is you’re gonna play in a lot of tight games, you're not gonna blow anyone out. That means you're gonna tax your bullpen. You're gonna be the belly of your bullpen most of the year, and by the time September comes, their arms are gonna fall off. So that's my biggest concern."

We have wasted so many good, productive years in Judge's career. Next year he will be 35 and let's be honest, he's had some gnarly injuries. That's not going to get easier for the Yankees to manage. He's not going to be the young spring chicken anymore. Our starting pitching hasn't been this strong in a long time. Why waste that with an anemic offense that doesn't show up when Judge is out? It's even worse considering Cody Bellinger and Giancarlo Stanton are still out with their own injuries. It's like they are giving up without actually selling off the team.

Why not go "all in" as Rodriguez said and get some impact bats and upgrade your weaknesses that clearly aren't working? If you aren't going to sell, then don't just stand pat and make Band-Aid fixes! Cut the dead weight! Cutting Anthony Volpe wasn't enough. George Lombard Jr. getting his promotion needed to happen (it just wasn't an option not to), but they should've done more than just that. They needed to upgrade Austin Wells too!  That line from Brian Cashman about having "limited options" at catcher was a load of crap! Our rivals did it. That doesn't fix the Yankees but it sure is an addition by subtraction just getting rid of Wells who can't even hit his weight.

The Yankees needed to do more. They needed to be hungrier. The rest of these teams are looking at our starting rotation wishing they had it. They are envious for a moment, and then they realize all their offense has to do is 'keep them in the game' because they are likely to win those close games because our bullpen is not at the same level. A one run lead isn't as hard to protect for our rivals as it should be. You can't just rely on your starting pitching....the offense and bullpen need to also execute.

As Rodriguez said, "It's amazing how the whole fan base knew exactly how this was going to turn out and it did." That shouldn't be okay. That shouldn't be accepted and swept under the rug. Judge deserves more. The team deserves more. The fans deserve more. We deserve a front office with balls. We deserve a change from the top down. 

What a disgrace.

--Jeana Bellezza-Ochoa

BYB Senior Managing Editor

Twitter: @nyprincessj

SOX ON FIRE, YANKEES ON EDGE!

Almost 4 months ago, the Boston Red Sox fired Alex Cora and it looked like Boston was done for. All of Yankee land was laughing as we enjoyed looking down at Boston all the way at the bottom of the AL East. They were deflated, we were in first place and that what we want to see. 

My how times have changed. Since then, the Yankees have lost heavy hitters in Aaron Judge, Giancarlo Stanton and Cody Bellinger. Add in pitcher Carlos Rodon and it is doomsday. The Yankees have been trying to tread water and the Red Sox literally lit a fire underneath everyone and went on winning streaks of 26-3 and 32-5 while the Yankees continue to stagger and stumble. Now the Yankees are literally feeling the Red Sox breathe down the necks. Suddenly a slip to third is very possible.

And I sit here and hate it all while being in amazement of George Lombard Jr and be pleasantly surprised at times by Spencer Jones. Those bright moments have come too late though because we are now as uncomfortable as it gets. What was once a 15 game lead over the Red Sox is now down to a game and a half.

I always say never underestimate the Red Sox. You never count them out....ever. They just reminded us of this. Months ago it looked like a minimum of a first Wild Card spot was likely. The American League is curiously weak compared to the National League. If the Yankees couldn't catch the Rays, we would at least have the first Wild Card spot. But....that the reality is, that might not be what happens here.

Not unless the Yankees start playing like their hair and asses are on fire! Rodon should be back soon, and Judge is progressing. Hopefully we also have Bellinger back by the time we see Boston again but that's not a guarantee. No doubt our injuries have hurt us, and we are missing our star power but both teams feed off of their starting pitching. The Red Sox have still found a way to win with a lineup that is not exactly loaded with big names or contracts.

The difference between these two teams is heart. The Yankees have shown we have that recently, but we need more of it to get us to the finish line. This is going to be a dog fight to the very end, and it's not going to be easy. 

Just in case you need a reminder.....NEVER underestimate the Red Sox.....EVER!

--Jeana Bellezza-Ochoa

BYB Senior Managing Editor

Twitter: @nyprincessj

STANTON IS FINALLY RUNNING, BUT DO THE YANKEES REALLY NEED HIM RIGHT NOW?

We finally have a little Giancarlo Stanton news, and this time it involves something other than swinging a bat.

Stanton has reached one of the more important stages of his recovery from a right calf strain: running.

Aaron Boone said Stanton jogged in the outfield Friday and has started easing into some baserunning work. That might not sound like some gigantic breakthrough, but with Stanton, it matters. Hitting has never really been the biggest concern during this rehab. It's whether that calf can hold up when he has to actually move.

Running the bases puts a completely different kind of stress on the body. Stanton has to accelerate, stop, turn, push off and react naturally without worrying about protecting that calf. That's the real test, and that's why the Yankees have been waiting to see him reach this point.

There is still no firm timetable for his return, and quite frankly, I'm not losing sleep over it.

Do the Yankees really need Stanton back right now? No. Look at what this team has been doing without him, especially this past week. They're playing good baseball, they're producing offensively and they're finding ways to win. That's what matters.

I'm not saying a healthy Stanton can't help. Of course he can. When he's locked in, he can still change a game with one swing. But the Yankees shouldn't be rearranging everything or rushing him back just because his name is Giancarlo Stanton. If the current lineup is clicking, let it click.

Stanton needs to prove he can run the bases, recover the next day and eventually handle everything that comes with playing in an actual game. Until then, there's really no reason to get overly excited about a few jogs in the outfield. So, we'll see what happens.

For now, at least we finally got a little update on this dude.

He's running. The Yankees are winning. 

In my opinion there's absolutely no reason to rush anything.

A STANTON INJURY UPDATE YOU NEED

The Yankees are winning games, and that's great. But let's not pretend they're blowing the doors off anyone. There's a difference between stacking wins and looking like a team built to steamroll October, and right now, this club falls into the first category.

It's hard to dominate when Aaron Judge, Cody Bellinger, and Giancarlo Stanton are all wearing street clothes instead of pinstripes. That's three of the biggest bats in the lineup sitting on the shelf. No trade deadline pickup is replacing that kind of production.

That's why adding Luis García helps. He can chip in, lengthen the lineup, and take some of the pressure off everyone else. But let's be honest: García isn't the story. The Yankees' postseason hopes still hinge on getting their stars back healthy.

There is finally a little good news on the Stanton front.

According to reports, Stanton is expected to face rehabbing left-hander Carlos Rodón in a live batting practice session Monday, followed by Clarke Schmidt on Tuesday. Aaron Boone confirmed Stanton is getting close to that stage, though he stopped short of saying whether Stanton will actually swing the bat or simply stand in the box and let 95 mph fastballs whistle by. Baby steps, apparently. Boone doesn't really know anything anyway. 

Judge's update? Not nearly as encouraging.

There's still no date for new imaging, meaning Judge isn't doing strength work, upper-body workouts, or baseball activities. Translation: don't expect him back anytime soon.

So yes, Stanton may beat Judge back to the Bronx. But neither player's timeline should've changed Brian Cashman's deadline plans. The Yankees had to act as if both were unavailable.

The Yankees deserve credit for hanging around. They've found ways to win while missing the heart of their lineup. But surviving August isn't the goal. 

If this team wants to make noise in October, Luis García can help—but Judge, Bellinger, and Stanton have to be the ones carrying the orchestra.

STRATEGY OR PANIC?

If Brian Cashman's trade deadline strategy is "wait and see," Yankee fans have seen enough.

The latest name connected to the Bombers is Giants outfielder Heliot Ramos, and honestly, he makes a ton of sense, but where did this come from? 

He's a right-handed bat, mashes lefties, can hold down the outfield while Aaron Judge, Cody Bellinger and Giancarlo Stanton try to get healthy, and he's under team control through 2029.

In other words... exactly the kind of player the Yankees should already be making a serious run at.

But this a strategy or panic? 

Remember, the Yankees watched Lane Thomas become a Brave because Atlanta actually did what contenders are supposed to do—they identified a need and pulled the trigger. While Cashman was probably still "gauging the market," their GM was introducing his newest outfielder.

That's the difference.

The Yankees don't lose out on players because they don't know who they want. They lose out because someone else wants them more and the Yanks are too slow to the take.

Now they're pivoting to Ramos, but it feels like "Well... who's left?" rather than a Plan A. Like a roll of the dice. I don't know, I don't feel great about it. Also, that's not a strategy on how you win a division.

Let's be honest about the situation. Judge is hurt. Bellinger is hurt. Stanton is working his way back. The outfield has become a revolving door, and the infield still finds new and creative ways to turn routine double plays into adventure films. Just ask Volpe.

Every GM in baseball knows the Yankees need help. That's exactly why sitting on your hands is the worst strategy imaginable. Cashman has always loved the bargain aisle. He wants to make the trade where everyone says, "Wow, he really stole that guy."

Sometimes you don't steal the player. Sometimes you just pay the price because your team needs him.

Heliot Ramos is worth pursuing yes, but if the Yankees spend the next two days "checking in," "doing their homework," and "remaining engaged," don't be surprised when another team beats them to the punch... again.

At some point, Brian Cashman has to decide whether he's trying to win the trade...

...or win the World Series.

Right now, it doesn't look like he's doing either.

IS BRIAN CASHMAN WAKING UP FROM HIS SLUMBER?

If there's one thing we've learned about the 2026 Yankees, it's this: pitching isn't the problem. Scoring runs is.

Over their last five games, Yankees starters have allowed just two earned runs, and somehow this team managed to stumble to a 2-3 record. Let that sink in. Your pitching staff practically throws shutouts every night, and the offense still can't cash in. That's not bad luck. That's roster construction.

So when reports surfaced that Brian Cashman is aggressively trying to land Nationals slugger Luis García Jr., it was the first rumor in a while that actually made sense.

According to multiple reports, the Yankees are pushing hard to complete a deal before the deadline, with pitching prospect Jack Cebert reportedly a key name being discussed. Whether that's ultimately enough remains to be seen, but at least the Yankees appear to recognize what everyone else has known for weeks.

This lineup is running on fumes.

Aaron Judge is hurt. Cody Bellinger is on the injured list. Giancarlo Stanton is still working his way back and hasn't been available to provide the thunder this lineup desperately needs. Every night feels like the Yankees are hoping someone accidentally runs into a baseball.

That's not exactly a championship strategy. Luis García Jr. changes that immediately.

He's putting together the best offensive season of his career, leading the American League with a .560 slugging percentage while launching 23 home runs and driving in 76 runs. Those aren't empty numbers on a rebuilding club. That's legitimate middle-of-the-order production, exactly what the Yankees have been missing while their stars recover.

Now, yes, there are legitimate questions. García is left-handed, and the Yankees have spent much of this deadline searching for right-handed bats. He's also primarily a first baseman, where Ben Rice and Paul Goldschmidt have already been sharing duties. On paper, it isn't the cleanest fit.

Then again...

Since when has this offense been in any position to turn down a hitter because he bats from the wrong side of the plate?

When you're struggling to score two runs with a pitching staff that's practically begging for support, you stop worrying about perfect roster symmetry. You worry about getting someone who can actually change a game with one swing.

That's García. The irony here is almost impossible to ignore. Brian Cashman spent the first half of the season assembling a roster that looked powerful on paper but became painfully dependent on Aaron Judge staying healthy. The moment Judge went down, the entire offense collapsed like a cheap folding chair.

Maybe this trade is Cashman finally admitting what everyone else already knew. This team needs another legitimate run producer.

Will Luis García Jr. solve every problem? Of course not. Aaron Boone still has to manage this club. The front office still has plenty to answer for after another season of offensive inconsistency and questionable roster decisions. One hitter won't magically erase months of questionable planning.

But for once, the Yankees seem to be targeting the actual problem instead of pretending it doesn't exist. Imagine that.

If Cashman can pull this one off before the deadline, it would be one of the few moves this season that actually feels proactive instead of desperate. And after watching this offense waste brilliant pitching performances night after night, Yankees fans deserve at least one reason to believe somebody in the front office has been paying attention.

Now finish the deal.

AARON BOONE IS CRACKING... AND IT SHOWS

Sure, the Yankees have a hitting problem, but they have a hitting problem because they have a horrendous leadership problem. IS ANYONE LISTENING TO ME? The manager has to go. it starts at the top.

The New York Yankees just lost another extra-inning game to the Chicago White Sox. Read that sentence again. The White Sox. Again.

This isn't about one bad afternoon. This isn't about one pitcher missing the strike zone. This isn't about one hitter failing to deliver with runners in scoring position. This is what organizational failure looks like. And it starts at the very top.

Brian Cashman built this roster. Hal Steinbrenner continues to endorse the direction and be MIA. Aaron Boone continues to manage as if the Yankees are one inspirational speech away from turning into the 1998 Yankees. Enough already.

Boone's postgame press visit tonight was the latest reminder that this franchise has completely lost its identity. When Fernando Cruz walked in the winning run on four pitches in the 11th inning, Boone wasn't interested in discussing what happened. He wasn't interested in accountability.

Instead, he barked at reporters.

"We've got to score a freaking point."

Really? This isn't football. It's called a run.

But seriously, that's your message? Of course, the Yankees have to score. Anyone with a television figured that out by the third inning. But here's the part Boone either refuses to acknowledge or simply doesn't understand.

Leadership isn't about stating the obvious. Leadership is about accountability.

Yes, players swing the bats. Nobody is disputing that. The Yankees were a pathetic 4-for-31 with runners in scoring position over the last two games against Chicago and stranded 21 runners. That's embarrassing.

But when the same failures happen over and over and over again, the manager doesn't get to shrug his shoulders and blame execution. At some point, the manager owns the product. That's what being the manager of the New York Yankees is supposed to mean. Instead, Boone has become the master of excuse-making.

Someone's hurt. Somebody almost came through. The at-bats were competitive, but we gotta do better. The guys battled but we came up short.

How many years have Yankees fans heard the same script? The names change. The excuses don't, and Boone is still there... are you getting it yet? Maybe it's not the personnel, it's the dude riding the bus.

Meanwhile, Brian Cashman watches this slow-motion disaster unfold and somehow keeps convincing ownership that this is all just bad luck. Bad luck? The Yankees have spent years constructing a roster that is too one-dimensional, too injury-prone, too dependent on home runs, and too incapable of producing a simple base hit when it matters most.

That's not bad luck. That's bad construction.

The injuries to Aaron Judge, Cody Bellinger, and Giancarlo Stanton are real. Nobody denies that. But championship organizations don't completely collapse because three players go down.

They adapt. They develop. They respond. And the manager helps to navigate that.

The Yankees do none of those things. Instead, they roll out the same lineup, expect different results, and then act shocked when another game slips away.

Ryan Weathers did his job. The bullpen did its job for nearly the entire afternoon. Even Fernando Cruz had done quality work before running out of gas in the 11th.

The offense? Missing. Again. And Boone's answer is to yell at reporters? That tells you everything.

Managers who are confident don't explode over legitimate questions. Managers who know they have answers don't become defensive every time someone mentions the trade deadline.

When Boone was asked whether the Yankees needed reinforcements, he snapped.

"It doesn't matter."

Actually, Aaron, it matters a lot. Because if this roster is good enough—as you continue insisting—then you're admitting something else. You're admitting the manager isn't getting enough out of it.

Which is it? Is the roster flawed? Or is the leadership failing? You can't have it both ways.

The most frustrating part is that the Yankees continue operating as though mediocrity is acceptable as long as someone can explain it away during a postgame press meeting.

That's not the standard this franchise was built on. George Steinbrenner would have demanded answers. Today's Yankees demand patience. That's the real problem. The front office has become comfortable with failure. Aaron Boone is great at failing. And Yankees fans have become far too familiar with watching both happen in real time.

The bats absolutely deserve criticism. But without accountability from the dugout and competence from the front office, this cycle never ends. Boone cracked tonight... and that tells you all you need to know. Bottom line?

They need new leadership. Because if this week proved anything, it's that the biggest thing missing from the Yankees isn't offense.

It's urgency. Just watch that press meeting tonight with Boone... he was lost. Why? Well... when you can't handle a job... you freak.

Boone is freaking out. 

BYRON BUXTON ON THE YANKEES RADAR...

Allegedly!

The Yankees' outfield problem went from concerning to critical in a matter of days.

Cody Bellinger's strained left hamstring couldn't have come at a worse time. Already without Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton, the Yankees are now missing another key piece of an offense that's been hanging on by sheer determination. They've managed to keep winning, but anyone watching this team knows the margin for error is getting smaller by the day.

That's why Brian Cashman can't afford to sit back as the trade deadline approaches.

The Yankees have been connected to several outfielders in recent weeks, but one name continues to stand above the rest: Byron Buxton.

ESPN's Buster Olney and other baseball insiders have identified the Minnesota Twins' All-Star center fielder as an ideal fit for a Yankees club desperately searching for another impact bat. It's easy to understand why.

Buxton is putting together one of the finest seasons of his career, hitting .271 with 25 home runs, 45 RBIs and an OPS north of .850. His production earned him a starting spot in the American League All-Star Game, but his value extends well beyond the numbers.

He brings athleticism, speed and elite defense to center field—qualities the Yankees desperately need. While Trent Grisham has done an admirable and Jasson Dominguez and Spencer Jones are still adjusting, Buxton would immediately elevate the position on both sides of the ball. He changes games with his glove, creates havoc on the bases and adds another dangerous right-handed bat capable of lengthening a lineup that has become far too dependent on role players.

That dependence has become impossible to ignore. The Yankees know it. Their front office knows it. And the rest of us fans know it too.

The biggest obstacle isn't determining whether Buxton would fit in New York. It's convincing Minnesota to move him. My opinion of course. I like this alot.

Buxton holds a full no-trade clause, giving him complete control over his future, and Twins officials have publicly stated they have no plans to part with one of their franchise cornerstones. If the Yankees want to make something happen, it would almost certainly require a significant package of prospects and Buxton's willingness to waive his protection.

That's a difficult conversation.  But championship-caliber players rarely become available without difficult conversations. Can we ship out Volpe?

With the August 3 trade deadline rapidly approaching, the Yankees have reached a difficult spot. They can hope their stars return quickly and their current roster continues to outperform expectations, or they can aggressively pursue an impact player capable of changing the trajectory of their season.

History has shown that standing still at the deadline rarely wins championships. Just look at the Yankees.

If the Yankees truly believe this roster is built to make a deep October run, this is the moment to act boldly. Whether Byron Buxton ultimately becomes available remains uncertain, but one thing isn't.

The Yankees don't just need another outfielder. They need another bat and athlete. They need someone who can change the conversation.

THE STATE OF MY YANKEES RIGHT NOW

The Yankees keep winning just enough to convince everyone that everything is fine.

It isn't. And the loss yesterday just screams to me that we are flawed.

That's the dangerous part of this season. The victories have become a disguise, masking problems that haven't gone away—in fact, they're becoming more obvious with every passing week. The standings may still look respectable, but anyone watching this team every night knows they're crawling through the summer rather than charging toward October.

Championship teams don't survive on hope.

Right now, the Yankees are missing Aaron Judge indefinitely with a rib stress fracture. Giancarlo Stanton remains sidelined without a clear timetable. Cody Bellinger is now hurt as well. Suddenly, what was already a top-heavy lineup has become painfully thin, forcing role players into everyday situations they were never meant to carry.

The numbers tell the story. The Yankees have piled up 900 strikeouts this season. That's not simply an ugly statistic—it reflects an offense built around home runs with very little margin for error. When the ball isn't leaving the yard, innings disappear in a hurry. Productive at-bats become rare. Rallies die before they ever begin.

The front office knows it.

Bob Nightengale's latest trade deadline report makes it crystal clear that Brian Cashman isn't looking for one missing piece. He's looking for several. The Yankees are aggressively searching for catching help, reportedly with Minnesota's Ryan Jeffers on their radar. They're also pursuing another late-inning reliever, with interest in Mason Miller, while continuing to shop for another offensive bat.

That isn't the shopping list of a complete baseball team. It's the shopping list of a roster with glaring weaknesses. And yet one glaring weakness continues to be ignored.

The shortstop position.

At some point the Yankees have to admit what everyone else already sees. They cannot realistically win a World Series without competent production at shortstop. That position touches every game. It anchors the infield defense, extends innings offensively, and stabilizes the entire club.

Instead, the Yankees continue pretending the problem doesn't exist.

Maybe it's organizational pride. Maybe it's stubbornness. Whatever the reason, refusing to acknowledge the obvious doesn't make the weakness disappear.

Adding a legitimate shortstop wouldn't magically solve every issue on this roster. But it would give this team its best chance to win. That's what championship organizations are supposed to do—address obvious flaws before those flaws eliminate them in October. The catching situation isn't much better.

For weeks it's been a revolving door of inconsistent offense and questionable production. Between the Volpe errors, the Caballero attitude at short, it's over for me. That's precisely why Cashman needs to be searching for help before the deadline. We need to be competent and go deep in the postseason.

Then there's the bullpen. The relievers have been asked to shoulder enormous workloads because the offense too often fails to create breathing room. Every close game becomes another high-leverage night. Every series becomes another test of endurance. Eventually, even elite bullpens crack.

That's why adding another late-inning arm isn't a luxury—it's becoming a necessity.

And then there's Aaron Boone. This is where the conversation becomes uncomfortable. Nobody is saying Boone is a bad manager, well I am, but the truth is he's considered "good" because of his winning record. But being "good" isn't the standard in the Bronx. It's like padding your numbers so you end up with a plaque in monument park.

Tiki Barber recently said it perfectly: Boone is a good manager. But he's not a great manager. Why? Because great managers win championships.

That's the measuring stick. Boone has presided over talented Yankee teams year after year, yet the endings always seem familiar. A strong regular season. A playoff appearance. Then the same tactical shortcomings surface when every decision matters most.

Whether it's bullpen management, lineup construction, in-game adjustments, or simply creating urgency, the Yankees always seem one step behind when October baseball demands excellence. The organization continues to reward consistency instead of greatness.

If the Yankees simply wanted someone to guide them into the postseason every year, they've certainly gotten their money's worth. But Yankee fans weren't raised on participation trophies. They were raised on championships.

The frustrating part is that none of these issues are new. We've discussed the strikeouts. We've questioned the lack of offensive depth. We've watched the revolving door behind the plate. We've begged for stability at shortstop. We've seen the bullpen stretched beyond reason.

Every season the problems receive temporary bandages instead of permanent solutions. Then October arrives. Then the Yankees fall short. Then the cycle starts all over again.

The trade deadline may improve this roster around the edges. Another catcher. Another reliever. Another bat. Those additions certainly help.

But unless this organization finally addresses its most glaring flaws—and unless the leadership both in the front office and in the dugout begins demanding more than simply reaching the playoffs—the outcome feels painfully predictable. The Yankees may continue winning games throughout the summer.

But they're not convincing me that they're built to win the last game of the season.

And until that changes, Yankee fans will continue watching the same movie every October.

Different year. Same ending.

HAMSTRUNG IN THE BRONX!

The goal was to add to the team by the trade deadline - but now the Yankees are dealing with a significant subtraction to an already banged up roster. Cody Bellinger is on the Injured List. When it rains on this team, it freaking torrential downpours.

The Yankees have spent the summer without some of their biggest star power. Now an already patched together outfield without Aaron Judge and DH Giancarlo Stanton gets more complicated. This team is the very definition of complicated but now losing Cody just makes it downright depressing. Although Cody slumped offensively heading to the All-Star break his defense has been unmatched, literally. He is the best defensive left fielder in the league. To date, he leads all left fielders with 19 defensive runs saved, Boston's Jarren Duran is a very distant second with 8 defensive runs saved. Cody's range and arm strength make him an elite defender.

While Cody is out, Spencer Jones gets the call from Triple-A. I really want to see him contribute and grow into a major league player that everyone else believes him to be. I'm just not a big Jones fan. He's 25 and hasn't figured out how to be a consistent, productive hitter. He's all or nothing and I'm tired of watching that every season on this team reincarnated.

The world seems to think he is going to be this guy who hits 30+ home runs, and drives in 100 runs. That's all great in theory but when you have a 40% strikeout rate those odds are increasingly NOT in your favor to make those kinds of stats. Oh and, if he can't achieve those numbers down in Triple-A, how does anyone think it just magically gets better in the majors? You know...where the talent level is higher. Am I the only one who believes it's possible that Jones could be just as likely to be Joey Gallo 2.0?

Okay, I will stop there because I think my frustration of Cody is making me go down a rabbit hole about Jones. My frustration is we seem to have more hamstring issues every stinking year. This time, it's a new experience for Cody, who said, "I've never had a hamstring injury before. It just feels a little tight," read more HERE. So the guy who's never had a hamstring before has no idea what he's dealing with yet and neither do the Yankees.

Side note - how do the Yankees not realize that they can avoid more of these hamstring issues by doing this cool thing called STRETCHING? Yes, it's this not new at all thing that many athletes around the world do. It helps with mobility and agility and my goodness there are many resources out there to help the Yankees with these things. There are classes, and hell I actually jump on this cool thing called YouTube and go through some videos. They are very helpful! If the Yankees added some stretching to their workouts and not just weight lifting, it would do wonders! Yoga and Pilates are not just girly activities, they are game changers!

Okay, rant over. No one knows how long Cody will be out. Hopefully he's back soon because anymore craziness and you could stumble across more of these ramblings. Get well soon, Cody....and add more stretching!

--Jeana Bellezza-Ochoa

BYB Senior Managing Editor

Twitter: @nyprincessj

THE WEIGHT ON GERRIT COLE'S SHOULDERS GETS HEAVIER

It's not easy being "the ace" of the pitching staff. It gets incrementally harder when the ace is coming back from reconstructive elbow surgery. The expectation is always high. The expectation is higher when your team is riddled with injuries and you need to execute every pitch and do everything you can to help your bruised team win.

The already heavy weight is now heavier for Gerrit Cole. Big bats of Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton are missing and they will be for a while. In addition, Max Fried is not pitching. Difference makers are not on the field, on the mound or in the batter's box. It's a big ask for a guy that hasn't pitched since the 2024 World Series and has been back in action for less than a month.

But Cole is doing it and as much as we need it, I am still uneasy. What we saw Tuesday against the White Sox isn't the norm for the Yankees. It always stings to give up that first inning home run, but then to retire 13 batters in a row while the offense scores 11 runs by the fourth inning is a rare treat. It's a rare treat as the Yankees need to find ways to win to maintain their lead against the Rays. It's not an easy ask.

It's about as easy of an ask as it is for the Yankees strength and conditioning team or medical staff to be worth a damn. It also means, the team that is 'all or nothing' needs to turn it up a notch and make sure the 'nothings' are few and far between. The streakiness can't exist. The Yankees need to play well against both good teams and bad teams. We can't afford the feast or famine anymore....and we can't put that weight on the shoulders of the guy who missed more than a full season. 

As much as I love Cole, and appreciate his mindset he can't do it on his own. The rest of the pitching staff can't do it on their own either. We need the offense just as much as we need the pitching. We need the "savages in the box" to come out and not the "averages in the box." There's no room for failure....or even average. 

The Yankees have won the last eight of nine games. That's great. But I am tired of the yo-yo up and down. Cole has always done his part for this team. There is no reason to believe he won't continue to do so, but everyone else does to. It can't only come down to Cole. We need next man up mentality! That's what separates the good teams from the best.

--Jeana Bellezza-Ochoa

BYB Senior Managing Editor

Twitter: @nyprincessj

THREE BAD CATCHERS, BUT A BIG YANKEE PROBLEM

The Yankees currently have a catching situation that can best be described as a three-ring circus — and unfortunately, nobody's laughing in the Bronx.

Two struggling catchers are on the major league roster, and the third, Austin Wells, is working his way back from the injured list. Wells was sidelined earlier this month with cervical headaches just before a series against the Red Sox, leaving J.C. Escarra and Ali Sánchez to handle duties behind the plate.

The problem? Neither has provided much reason for optimism.

Then again, neither has Wells.

And that's where the real blame belongs: the Yankees front office.

Virtually every Yankees fan saw this coming. The organization entered the season acting as if a collection of backup-caliber catchers would somehow turn into a strength. For one of the most successful and storied franchises in sports, settling for mediocrity behind the plate feels like an odd strategy. If the Yankees thought fans would embrace "good enough," they badly misread the room.

At some point, Wells will return. The question isn't whether he'll be back — it's how long the Yankees can afford to wait for him to figure things out.

If the headaches were contributing to his struggles, which I believe is why he's out, perhaps a healthy Wells can turn things around. But if he returns looking like the same hitter we've seen all season, the Yankees may be forced to confront a problem they never expected to have when spring training opened.

Wells has been one of the least productive hitters on the roster, posting a miserable .166/.278/.255 slash line. Simply put, the Yankees cannot continue getting this little offense from a position that already lacks impact around the league.

That's why trade speculation is beginning to heat up.

One name that continues to surface is Orioles star catcher Adley Rutschman. The fit is obvious. Baltimore has elite catching prospect Samuel Basallo waiting in the wings, while the Yankees are desperately searching for offensive production behind the plate.

Rutschman would instantly become the Yankees' best catcher. Through 51 games, he's hitting .265/.343/.481 with eight home runs and 15 doubles. With Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton currently sidelined, adding another legitimate bat has become an even greater priority.

Of course, talent is only half the equation.

Would the Orioles really trade a star catcher to their biggest division rival? Would the Yankees be willing to pay the enormous price it would take to make such a deal happen?

That's where this fantasy starts to get complicated.

The Yankees clearly need help at catcher. Everyone can see it. The bigger question is whether they have the courage to admit they got it wrong and make a bold move before the trade deadline.

For now, Yankees fans are left watching three catchers struggle and wondering how a franchise with championship aspirations ended up here in the first place.

Stay tuned.

THE INTERNET'S BUZZIN' WITH TRADE RUMORS TO REPLACE INJURED JUDGE

I don't even want to think about this, but after being asked about this constantly at work and now seeing rumors on the internet with every click I make....it feels impossible to avoid. Aaron Judge is sidelined and it's going to be a while. Now the Yankees moved back in first place over the weekend and everyone is asking how the Yankees are gonna keep it, without Judge playing.

If I am being honest, I am asking the same thing too. There are two very different versions of this team. There's the version with Judge playing that averages more runs score per game and then there is the version with no Judge and about two runs less scored per game. Not pretty splits to consider in a very right race with the Rays for the AL East.

And now we have to worry about exactly how long Judge is going to be out. The Yankees expect him to be back this season, but we do not know when. There's still a lot of baseball left so that's a lot of time that he could still be out. So now, the internet is abuzz with who the Yankees could trade for to fill-in for him until he does return.

That Judge fill in could be Seiya Suzuki, read more HERE. The Cubs are in a tough spot, they have been dropping games and the possibility of the Cubs becoming sellers at the deadline is becoming stronger. The Cubs have not played well since May 7th and unless they turn a corner, there is no reason for the Cubs to become a buyer by the deadline when they are 7.5 games back in their division.

And that makes the Cubs likely to trade away some of their impending free agents and that could easily mean Suzuki. He's a free agent at the end of the season and even though he had a rough stretch in May he's rebounded nicely in June with a .383 average, five home runs, and seven RBI's.

Suzuki is currently considered day-to-day after jamming his right knee after diving for a ball on Saturday. Initial reports are fine, the Cubs don't seem concerned but....time will tell. It's an option, and one the Yankees could consider with the injury bug still biting with Giancarlo Stanton and Trent Grisham. Confidence isn't as high as it should be with Jasson Dominguez and Spencer Jones so the Yankees will sniff around. But the question is where and around who?

The Yankees may need a rental. I don't like to think about it because we NEED Judge, but it might be a harsh reality.

--Jeana Bellezza-Ochoa

BYB Senior Managing Editor

Twitter: @nyprincessj