Sunday, February 26, 2012

WHEN YOU WISH UPON A STAR...

Pete Caldera of the Bergen Record is there to make you think about Mariano Rivera. Read HERE. Caldera has a piece about Mariano and his final wish, to play center field for 1 inning. You gotta love it. In everything that Mariano Rivera has accomplished, wouldn't it just make sense that Mariano wants to give center field a crack?

As Caldera writes: "If it's late September, the pennant race settled and the Yankees in a meaningless game, Mariano Rivera's wish to play center field ought to be granted. Just one inning."
Think about that. Seeing Mariano Rivera in center field, no doubt it would be at Yankee Stadium and as he ran out to center, could you imagine the stadium erupt? I love that kind of crap. It gets me quite emotional. Much like what I had suggested for Jorge Posada and Mariano when he was going for save 602. Why NOT have Posada go out there behind the plate for those last three outs last year (Read WHY SAVE 602 SHOULD BE MARIANO TO POSADA.) Of course it didn't happen, and life went on, but I can only imagine that those that agree with Caldera's idea of Mo in center field would also have been the same people that got behind my brief "Mo to Posada 602 crusade", right? But while Mariano to Posada for his 602nd save is literally just sentimental to Yankee fans, Mariano Rivera in center field could be potentially dangerous, don't you think?

Look, I love Mo and he has been recognized as one of the most athletic pitchers ever, but even if Mo was to go into center field in a "meaningless" game before the playoffs begin, can you imagine if a ball just out of Mariano's reach offered a tragic event like a twisted angle or fall, putting him out of commission for the 2012 playoff run? Not only would Joe Girardi be crucified, but all of Yankeeland would want the Brothers' Steinbrenner on a silver platter. Look, the odds of Mariano getting hurt is slim to none and Caldera has fun with his piece and we all know Mo wants to do it, but hey, you just never know. Read what Mariano said about it:

"You know what? I want to...I have to talk to that man over there...I'd love too. I'd love to. It's not something that I'd think of as a joke. I want to do it right."

Hey look, stranger things have happened. Sure, I worry, after all, we've now seen Mariano Rivera become the greatest closer before our eyes and now, just one time, he'd like to try something different. Would you want him to do it? In the end, reading Caldera's piece... even I agree... give Mariano a shot.

Please comment, we have DISQUS, it's easier than ever. Let me know what you think and follow me on Twitter @BleednYankeeBlu and look for the hashtag #BYB. Also, join the group Bleeding Yankee Blue on Facebook, just type it in.

IMAGES OF YANKEELAND IN TAMPA: PART 2

Looking at our New York Yankees in Florida as they prepare for Opening day was one of the most popular posts for Bleeding Yankee Blue in a while, so here's Part 2. Enjoy this.Here the Yankees are running it out. No doubt cardio is probably one of the most important things the Yankees will do to prepare for the long season. It's good to see the boys of summer warming up. Ladies, calm down, I know you are all digging David Robertson right now.

Mariano Rivera is showing the others just how good he is, fielding a ball and no doubt throwing to first. Mariano is the greatest and one of the most athletic pitchers in the game today. I'm so happy he's a New York Yankee and I cannot imagine him in any other uniform.

No doubt Derek Jeter was just told to read Bleeding Yankee Blue's SABATHIA & BURNETT EXCHANGE TEXTS: PART 4 post and he thinks it's absolutely hysterical. Or, he's just happy to be starting up baseball again.

This is Joba Chamberlain, Cory Wade, Phil Hughes and Ivan Nova running, running, running... I'm looking forward to Joba coming back and to Phil being the Phil of 2010. I can't wait.
Here's a look at Hiroki Kuroda throwing down in Tampa. I didn't really care for the guy coming to the Bronx, I was one of the few, but now I'm getting excited to see him in with the Yankees. Of course it's a different ballgame in New York compared to LA, so we'll need to stay tuned...
Francisco Cervelli shows his passion as he chucks it down to second base here. No doubt, right after he fist pumped... I don't care, I love the heart on this guy.Ivan Nova is definitely going to fight for the #2 slot on the Yankees this year. Who knows what will happen, but it's exciting to think that the Yanks actually have 5 guys that can get them to a World Championship in 2012.

More to come, if you like this, we'll give you a Part 3... just comment and let us know you long for more.

Please comment, we have DISQUS, it's easier than ever. Let me know what you think and follow me on Twitter @BleednYankeeBlu and look for the hashtag #BYB. Also, join the group Bleeding Yankee Blue on Facebook, just type it in.

WHY RIVERA NEEDS TO PITCH IN 2012 FIRST...

We need to stop the hysteria. Mariano is not retiring now… but he may at the end of the season. So what the hell is the New York Sports media doing? The media frenzy is all over this since Mariano told everyone that he knows what he will do and he will tell us all when the time is right...read HERE. So... now we guess and I guess we guess all season. People and media is right now at this moment trying to piece together who can replace the irreplaceable Mariano Rivera. Look, I love Mariano Rivera, I’m not afraid to say that…I’ll stand on the top of a mountain and scream it, don’t challenge me... but the point is this... life goes on after Mo. Let’s get real, Mariano is the greatest closer ever, but guess what, there will be another. We will survive without Mariano Rivera.That's not a slap, that's the reality and my point is give the guy alittle space for crying out loud, he still has work to do.

We can’t sit here before 162 games are even played and panic like this. We need to give the man respect. He hinted toward possibly retiring... or not. We don’t know… he knows… Derek Jeter probably knows, but we don’t know, so shouldn't it just be business as usual for us? Seriously, I believe we should sit back and watch the man work. Let’s enjoy him again for another season before we get nutty here.

Let’s look at the good things in Mariano’s career. I remember that lanky kid come up and set up John Wetteland and even then he was exciting, but like I wrote in WHY SEIZING THE MOMENT MAKES YOU NEW YORK’S DARLING, he found a niche as the Yankees closer and he never looked back. He fine tuned his craft and to this day, I still don’t know how the hell he goes out there with 1 pitch and Mow’s them down…no pun intended. He has 603 saves and he’ll have plenty more this season. My point is, the guys got a lot of baseball in him and we’re already thinking about his replacement. I say we as fans need to love every moment with him, it's not our job, nor the NY Sports media’s job to do find a replacement for Mo, it’s Yankee brass and according to Hal Steinbrenner, they have so much respect for Rivera, they’ll do whatever Mariano wants to do. Read HERE.

Sure, speculations fun, we do that kind of stuff here on occasion, but nothing's set in stone yet. Just a lot of baseball to play. Mariano this year will provide leadership to the new guys coming in as well as offer confidence when he takes the mound. He’s done it for years and he’ll do it again like it’s business as usual, whether the man is retiring at the end of 2012, tomorrow or not at all, his game plan never changes, wins are what are important and it's been the same approach for him for years. So yeah, my take on this is simple, one thing we can’t do is panic. Can we ask questions about who his successor will be? Sure, but don’t replace this great man yet, Mariano is one of a kind, and we need to enjoy him while we still can.

Please comment, we have DISQUS, it's easier than ever. Let me know what you think and follow me on Twitter @BleednYankeeBlu and look for the hashtag #BYB. Also, join the group Bleeding Yankee Blue on Facebook, just type it in.

Saturday, February 25, 2012

WHY IBANEZ HAS LEARNED TO LOVE PINSTRIPES

"I'm still mad about the 2009 World Series loss...Up until about a week ago, I was still mad about it, and then I said, 'OK, now I'm over it.'"
-- Raul Ibanez to reporters in Tampa
You have to appreciate the passion of Raul Ibanez. That 2009 World Series clearly was a bad loss for the Philadelphia Phillies and I remember Ibanez in that series and I remember thinking then I respected him as a ballplayer. I felt like he was in a number of big plays, and that got me thinking about his career....16 years and I felt like I always saw him playing the Yankees and he always did something to help put his team ahead where it was with the Phillies, the Mariners or the Royals. This about it, Ibanez is 39 years old, he's been around. Sure, you may think that's old, but the fact of the matter is, it could be worse, he could be 40... like me.Ibanez finalized his 1 year, $1.1 million deal with the Yankees last week and while he wasn't great in 2011, he is a decent ballplayer and the Yankees clearly wanted him over guys like Hideki Matsui and Johnny Damon, guys they were familiar with and guys that were familiar with the Yankee way. Believe me, money had a lot to do with it, but they believe in Ibanez which is why they're giving him a shot. I believe that Ibanez will contribute too, he told reporters:

"Putting on pinstripes you saw so many great players put on before you, it's an honor and a privilege."

Wow, that gave me chills... I wonder if it gave him chills saying it. Welcome aboard Raul, we're excited to have you.

Please comment, we have DISQUS, it's easier than ever. Let me know what you think and follow me on Twitter @BleednYankeeBlu and look for the hashtag #BYB. Also, join the group Bleeding Yankee Blue on Facebook, just type it in.

WHY IT'S TIME TO PASS THE TORCH TO CANO

You can see leadership already when it comes to Robinson Cano and when he needed to be the number 3 guy in the lineup after Alex Rodriguez was out for an extended period of time, he didn't blink. Instead, he embraced it and dominated and hopefully that will continue in 2012.

Peter Caldera, writer for the Bergen Record had a terrific story today, read HERE, and in a nutshell, suggests that the Yankees are confident with Cano in that role and Cano, well, he wants to do what's best for the team and win. Another guy clearly groomed in the Yankees organization early and understands the importance of leadership. As Caldera states in his piece: "It's where Babe Ruth hit in the '20's, where Mickey Mantle hit in the '50s and where Don Mattingly hit in the '80s." Good company? I'd say so.Bleeding Yankee Blue wrote about Cano in that role as well, WHY CANO SHOULD GET USED TO BEING #3. This was written on January 29th. Kudos to Jeana Bellezza for being ahead of the curve. We love Cano there in the 3 slot. There's a comfort level with him in that role; he produces and he makes the others around him better.

It will be interesting to watch how team's handle him in 2012 and if they will now pitch around him to try and do damage on some of the other Yankees that follow, like for instance, an aging Alex Rodriguez. It sounds crazy because just a few years ago, Rodriguez was mashing the ball, but now after injuries and age creeping up on Alex, many wonder if Cano is more of a threat than ARod now. It's crazy to think this way, but it's the reality we live in now.Cano's 29 and there's a lot baseball to be played. He's finished in the MVP voting twice in the top 6 in 2010 (3rd) and 2011 (6th) and has had an average over .300, 5 times of his 7 years playing in the majors. Of those .300 seasons, he batted .342 in 2006, .320 in 2009 and .319 in 2010. Not too shabby. Plus, since 2009, he increased his home runs into the 20's. 25 in 2009, 29 in 2010 and 28 in 2011. I'd be a fool if I didn't mention his RBI season high was in 2011 with 118.

Robinson Cano is built for the 3 hole, just like the other hitting greats of Yankees past... Donnie Baseball, the Mick and the Babe. 2o years from now, we'll add Hall of Famer Robbie Cano to that list of great #3 hitters in Yankee history... without a doubt.

Please comment, we have DISQUS, it's easier than ever. Let me know what you think and follow me on Twitter @BleednYankeeBlu and look for the hashtag #BYB. Also, join the group Bleeding Yankee Blue on Facebook, just type it in.

IMAGES OF YANKEELAND IN TAMPA: PART 1

We've waited all winter for Spring Training to see our boys getting ready for our Quest for 28. I've collected some of the best images so far of Spring Training with more to follow. For instance, Derek Jeter above is a great way to start, you gotta love the Captain always arriving to camp early to set the tone. For the most part, these are some great shots and I'll try my best to get more posts like this up all Spring for ya'll. Enjoy this.Freddy Garcia warms up as he will fight for the 5th spot against Phil Hughes in the Yankee rotation. This should be interesting.
This is Phil Hughes, Boone Logan and CC Sabathia stretching it out. There's something about this shot that I just love, I guess it represents the beginning of baseball. It's awesome.

Rafael Soriano doing a drill. Soriano actually looks comfortable, not like last year where I don't think I saw him smile all year. I hope he does well for us this season.
Curtis Granderson is getting the balls collected for another round of hitting. You got to love this guy and I hope to God he has a great season like he did last year. I love to watch the Gentleman work.
Here is CC Sabathia letting one fly. Love this dude and I expect the monster to win 20 again this year. He took off some weight again and I look for him to kick some ass.
Russell Martin does some catching while he thinks about negotiating his contract with the Yankees at the end of 2012. I hope he has a great season.

I'll collect some more great pictures and post them, it's fun stuff. God bless the New York Yankees.

Please comment, we have DISQUS, it's easier than ever. Let me know what you think and follow me on Twitter @BleednYankeeBlu and look for the hashtag #BYB. Also, join the group Bleeding Yankee Blue on Facebook, just type it in.

SABATHIA ON PINEDA: "HE'S ELECTRIC!"

You have to love Michael Pineda. He showed up to Spring Training 1 week early and Russell Martin says the kids got amazing stuff. Thank God. Sure, it’s way early and we’re just getting warmed up, literally, but you always want to hear good things about your New York Yankees and when a 23 year old kid comes into spring training willing to show results through hard work, how much do you want to embrace this guy?

According to Bryan Hoch of MLB.com, read HERE, Girardi was pretty impressed with Pineda’s fast ball and slider. CC Sabathia was impressed with how Pineda handles himself on the mound as well and here’s his quote about him:

“He’s electric. To be that young, throw that hard and be able to throw the ball over the plate is impressive.”

Hoch went on to talk about how Cashman believes that work still needs to be done with Pineda and Rothschild is working on Pineda and his change-up a bit. George King III wrote in his piece HERE, that CC has plans to talk with Pineda about a change up, but was quick to say: “If he wants to talk about it, I will talk to him... I don’t want to force it on him. It’s hard to trust [the change] when you throw as hard as he does."

Cashman believes that while Pineda can be a superstar in the Bronx, he’s not going to just wake up in April and be the Yankees number 2 starter. I found that interesting and you know what? It makes sense. People tend to forget that this kid is 23 years old and while he throws hard, don't forget, by the end of last season he broke down no doubt due to his age, innings increase and fatigue:

Before the All-Star Break in 2011: 8-6, 3.03 ERA

After the All-Star Break in 2011: 1-4, 5,12 ERA

Think about it, Pineda’s only pitched 1 full season in the major leagues. So the idea of just throwing him into that #2 role is possible but if you have someone like Ivan Nova or Hiroki Kuroda, why force it? All I'm saying is you don't HAVE to throw a guy that age in there and expect him to throw 200 innings in his second year in the majors. That being said, Pineda appears to have the talent. Even Russell Martin had said how impressed he was by Pineda and the way he carries himself this spring so far. Good... things are changing in Yankeeland now that AJ Burnett has made a home in Pittsburgh...maybe now we can all move forward... damn that's exciting to think about.

Please comment, we have DISQUS, it's easier than ever. Let me know what you think and follow me on Twitter @BleednYankeeBlu and look for the hashtag #BYB. Also, join the group Bleeding Yankee Blue on Facebook, just type it in.

Friday, February 24, 2012

WHY THE YANKEES & MARTIN STOPPED EXTENSION TALK

Just when you thought maybe the Yankees and Russell Martin were going to get together on a 3 year extension...suddenly...nothing.

According to Andrew Marchand HERE, the Yankees and Martin have decided that maybe they should wait to negotiate a deal after the season when Martin is a free-agent. Clearly Martin enjoys being a Yankee and the Yankees like Martin... remember when Cashman called him "Munson-like"? Damn that must have killed Jorge Posada. Anyway, according to Jon Heyman of CBSSports.com, Russell Martin is seeking more than the 3 year, $20 million the Yankees offered him. Read HERE.

So what needs to happen for Russell and the Yankees to get back together at the end of 2012? Martin needs to have a good season and be "Munson-like" again and the Yankees need to appreciate him even more and sign Martin for what he's worth. Hopefully it all works out and even though Martin will become a free agent, the marriage will continue.... but yeah, as of right now, talks are off...

Please comment, we have DISQUS, it's easier than ever. Let me know what you think and follow me on Twitter @BleednYankeeBlu and look for the hashtag #BYB. Also, join the group Bleeding Yankee Blue on Facebook, just type it in.

WHY MISGUIDED HUGHES SPECULATION GETS US NOWHERE

I think it is entire unfair to float an article about a starting pitcher possibly being put into the minor leagues to get "stretched out" only 1 week into the Spring Training season. I mean Andrew Marchand’s a bright guy, he's respected, but is there really nothing better to do than to float the possibility that Phil Hughes may need to go to the minors if he doesn’t get the 5th spot? Can we at least start the competition this Spring before we start floating ridiculous speculation? I'm not a real big fan of that. Sure, anything could happen, but seriously, it's week 1 of spring training.

Andrew Marchand wrote his piece titled Hughes to minors? Not impossible. Read it HERE. In the short piece, it suggests that Joe Girardi would need to make a “tough” decision about Phil and Girardi went on to say “I expect Phil to bounce back.” Now, I’m not sure if I hated seeing Marchand’s headline, or the fact that the article itself didn't give me a clear sense that there is actual concern about Hughes and a chance to be sent down if he didn’t make the 5th spot. Let’s be honest, there’s nothing in his article that even suggests it, in fact, Girardi said this: “There are a lot of different things we could do for him, He has had success in the bullpen.We have to decide what is best for him and us.”

Look, I may be a fan blog, but I also get journalism. Reading Marchand today, I still don’t know if the Yankees are interested in sending Hughes down if he loses out or if he's making the whole thing up. I say simply, can’t we talk about this later? It's February 24th. There’s plenty of Spring ball to be played… it’s way to early for this crap. Read Marchand, he speculates...nothing more... and this is under the ESPN flag. I don't get it. I read plenty of other stories today about Phil Hughes, none of them speculate like this, why?

Klapisch: Leaner Phil Hughes turns focus to No. 5 spot

Hoch: Yanks looking for improvements from Hughes

LoHud: Known and unknown at the back of the rotation

Maybe I'm just tired. Or then again, maybe I DO get it. It's Spring and there are no scandals surrounding the New York Yankees this year...it's too quiet. I guess we’re all just hanging on anything to get readers these days.

For the record, I love Marchand, but I’m lost on this one.

Please comment, we have DISQUS, it's easier than ever. Let me know what you think and follow me on Twitter @BleednYankeeBlu and look for the hashtag #BYB. Also, join the group Bleeding Yankee Blue on Facebook, just type it in.

WHY I HAVE A PROBLEM WITH MORE WILD CARDS

I was reading that Major League Baseball may be putting the extra Wild Card teams into place in the 2012 season, instead of 2013. That statement came from Buster Olney's tweet HERE. The reality is, Bud Selig wants this and he's pushing and pushing because I guess ultimately, it helps the game of baseball... everyone makes money, except the fan.

Man, I tell you… I am really not a fan of more Wild Card teams… it bothers me. Look, I like the game of baseball the way it is, and while some rules needed to be tweaked as we move forward in life, like challenging home runs with instant replay, adding more Wild Card teams is getting alittle ridiculous now, isn’t it?

Look, the whole idea of a Wild Card is exactly what it is…a WILD CARD. Right now you have 3 divisions in each league and a 4th team in each of those leagues that has a shot to make the “Wild Card” and get into the playoffs. OK, fine. Never liked it, but to be perfectly honest, I’ve learned to accept it. After all, the Yankees have needed it a few times since the rules existence, you know? But that brings me to my point; if you already have 3 division champs and 1 Wild Card in each league, shouldn’t that be it? We’re already letting in an extra “1st place of the losers” team to compete... so why more?

All this means to me is Major League Baseball will have teams that "almost win" squeak into the playoffs because they came "close" to winning but didn’t. Or, in other words, the team that missed the “Wild Card” (or the second place winner), now gets a shot to win it all in the playoffs too. What is this, Little League? Should we give out 4 inch trophies to everyone at the end of the season too? After all, it’s no longer about “winning”, it’s apparently now about “trying”. Where the hell did the competition go?

It's always been about climbing the mountain and being the only one on top...that's not only a sports thing, that's a life thing too. What ever happened to “may the best team win?” How can the best team win if you don’t have a batch of best teams competing? Now it’s the best teams and then teams that are less deserving too… all for the sake of making money for Bud.

Sometimes I think it would be a hell of a lot better if there was a 1 Game championship series and no playoffs, just like the Superbowl. What’s next, a 7 game series for all playoff rounds and 6 wild cards? How about this... just call Major League Baseball the Major League Playoffs and have all teams compete in the playoffs. Then... that's it.

My point is simple, we forgot what it's like to be the best in this country and that goes for everything including baseball. It's watered down. It's no longer about being 1st, it's about being 1st, 2nd, 3rd, or in some cases, "just like everyone else" for the sake of being fair. Damn... where the hell did our balls go?

Please comment, we have DISQUS, it's easier than ever. Let me know what you think and follow me on Twitter @BleednYankeeBlu and look for the hashtag #BYB. Also, join the group Bleeding Yankee Blue on Facebook, just type it in.

WHY YANKEE NOTES MAKE THE WORLD GO 'ROUND

Spring is here, and here come the nuggets from camp that will quench your thirst until the first Spring Training game pitch is thrown.

Mariano Rivera: Hal Steinbrenner spoke to MLB.com HERE about Mariano Rivera and if, he decided this year WASN'T his last year, how Hal and the Yankees would certainly want him to return. Here are some quotes, definitely worth reading: "He's obviously a lifelong Yankee... When he decides to retire someday -- whenever that may be -- we all hope he's going to be wearing the pinstripes. No doubt about that.... If he were inclined [to return], we absolutely would be talking to him about coming back. Yes, of course." For an employer to speak so highly of one of their employees is something these days, isn't it? That quote will stay with me all season.

Austin Romine: Now that Jesus Montero is gone, Romine doesn’t have a shadow to climb out from behind and good for him, but not so fast. Word from Yankee camp is he will miss a day with a sore back. Bryan Hoch has that HERE. I wanted to tell you guys just to tell you, but to be honest... I didn't need to know. No disrespect to Hoch or course. The other news out of Hoch's piece though is Girardi envisions Francisco Cervelli as being Russell Martin's backup with Romine starting in Scranton. I see that, unless Romine dazzles everyone in Spring Training... we'll see. I'm fine with either.

Eric Chavez: Chavez says he's glad to be back with the New York Yankees and why wouldn’t he be? The guy is loved in New York and he only played 58 games last year because of injury. The difference between his injury and others is Eric Chavez is productive when he returns and last year he did exactly what we all expected. Think about it, if the guy wasn’t hurt, he probably would have had a great season last year on defense and with his bat. Any way, read about Chavez HERE. Here’s his quote:

“If there was no interest at all, in my mind I was probably going to shut it down... I wouldn’t say ‘here or nowhere’ — but this was obviously coming back to a place I was familiar with. ... I knew this was going to be a good team, obviously a team that was going to have an opportunity to go back to the playoffs.”

I really like Chavez. People criticize him for always being hurt and yes, I rip on him sometimes too because it's frustrating, but all I can say is, when he's on the field, he's productive. That means something.

If any other news comes out of Yankeeland, we'll bring it to you. Stay with us, it's almost Opening Day. Gotta love it.

Please comment, we have DISQUS, it's easier than ever. Let me know what you think and follow me on Twitter @BleednYankeeBlu and look for the hashtag #BYB. Also, join the group Bleeding Yankee Blue on Facebook, just type it in.

WHY MATTINGLY BELONGS IN THE HALL OF FAME

The New York Yankees certainly have their share of plaques in the MLB Hall of Fame and, with the likes of Derek Jeter and Mariano Rivera as shoo-in first ballot inductees they will have more to come. However, there is one glaring omission from the ranks of Hall of Fame Yankees - Donald Arthur Mattingly.
The "Donnie Baseball" played 14 seasons for the Bronx Bombers, beginning in 1982 and concluding in 1995 after back issues prevented him from going any further. During that time he wowed Yankee Stadium crowds with both his bat and his glove. His style of play on the field and his quiet class off the field forever endeared him to New York Yankee fans, and resulted in his number being retired in 1997. Read about it in this 1997 article HERE, from a young Jack Curry.

Since his retirement there have been a number of his peers elected to the Hall of Fame that have either put up comparable statistics or worse statistics than Don Mattingly. For the sake of this argument, I have selected three of them for comparison.

Robin Yount, Paul Molitor and Kirby Puckett are all in the MLB Hall of Fame. All played in roughly the same era as Don Mattingly (with Yount and Molitor beginning their careers before Mattingly and with Puckett beginning after and completing the same years as Mattingly). All three are deserving in their own right of having a plaque in Cooperstown, but an argument can be made that Don Mattingly is just as deserving or even more so than each of them.

Before looking at numbers, let's examine accolades each of the four players earned in their stellar careers.
  • Robin Yount played 20 seasons - all with the Milwaukee Brewers. During that time he won two MVPs, three Silver Slugger awards, one Gold Glove and was selected an All-Star three times.
  • Paul Molitor played 21 seasons, all but the final six with the Milwaukee Brewers. He never was selected as MVP, won four Silver Sluggers, zero Gold Gloves and was selected an All-Star seven times.
  • Kirby Puckett played 12 seasons, all with the Minnesota Twins. He too was never selected as MVP, won six Silver Sluggers, six Gold Gloves and was selected an All-Star 10 times.
  • Don Mattingly played 14 seasons, all with the New York Yankees. He was selected as MVP once, won three Silver Sluggers, nine Gold Gloves and was selected an All-Star six times.
Based on accolades alone, one can see why putting Don Mattingly in the Hall of Fame would make sense. In addition to having more Gold Gloves than the other three, two of the others (Puckett and Molitor) never won an MVP - an award Mattingly has.

Besides awards won, the argument for Don Mattingly being in the MLB Hall of Fame would not be complete without a statistical comparison of the four players I have mentioned:
As I stated earlier, in each of the statistical categories above, Don Mattingly is either comparable or better than each of the other three. It should be noted that unlike the other three, Mattingly only played in one postseason, but hitting .417 is still HITTING .417!The statistics certainly show that Don Mattingly belongs among this group and is at the very least, the equal to each of them. Mattingly offered a lot more than just statistics and awards to New York Yankee fans. He was the quiet leader on the field and in the clubhouse. His achievements during the 1987 season alone should have virtually ensured his induction into Cooperstown. During that year Don Mattingly broke a record that had stood since 1955 for Grand Slams in one season - slugging 6. In addition, he tied a record set by Dale Long in 1956 for most consecutive games hitting a home run with 8. He brought excitement to an otherwise below-standard season for the Yankees.

During his prime, Don Mattingly was considered the premier first baseman in baseball. His cat-like reflexes and on-field leadership combined with his imposing presence at the plate set him apart from his peers.There is an argument that the reason Don Mattingly isn't in the Hall of Fame is that he does not have a World Series ring. The other three players I have compared him to in this article all have at least one. My response is that a World Series ring is the culmination of superior effort by a TEAM, not one specific individual. It takes a roster of 25 players to win a World Series, not one player. The fact that Mattingly had the misfortune of playing on teams that either lacked pitching or depth is no fault of his and should not be used as the reason he is kept out of baseball's hallowed territory.

Based on the numbers, based on the man, Mattingly belongs in the Hall of Fame. Do you agree or disagree? Tell us...comment.

(This article was also published by the Bleacher Report.)



--Steve Skinner, BYB Guest Writer


Please comment, we have DISQUS, it's easier than ever. Let me know what you think and follow me on Twitter @BleednYankeeBlu and look for the hashtag #BYB. Also, join the group Bleeding Yankee Blue on Facebook, just type it in.